Who is the most overrated pop girl?
 

The answer is Taylor

Hmm Beyoncé tbh

Bey

Beyoncé and it's not even close

everyone saying Bey when she's the only one who makes outstanding albums :( the delusion is real

Britney for the Queen of Gays status or Rihanna for the "critics loving Work for **** knows what reason" status. Did otherwise like Anti but that song is objectively terrible sorry!

People liked Meghan Trainor which was incorrect of them.

Beyonce

People treat her like she's the second coming of god though :laugh:

I'd agree with either Britney or Bey

.

is there anyone else more qualified to be the 2nd coming though :think:

I like her but Britney

not having this Bey shade at all. She produces the best albums and live shows out of all of them.

I love her but Britney is hugely overrated to almost comical levels.

CL

she is trash

britney is the definition of a female pop star

Beyonce. She's got a great voice but a lot of her music is pap. :joker:

:clap1:

So do all pop stans with their faves

Anyway the answer is Taylor.

Calling Beyoncé overrated is the edgy thing to do nowadays so if there was a poll I'd suspect she'd lead.

I'd do with Taylor, especially if we base it off vocals alone. Her voice is nothing too amazing? Not to say she hasn't had some bops though.

I don't feel like Britney is very rated within mainstream society anymore tbh
Most people who are fans of hers are die hard a bit it's not like you constantly hear about Britney anymore now comparison to Beyoncé, Taylor, Rihanna and even the likes of Gaga and Katy

I do often find the ex acts somewhat over rated - in particular Ariana and Selena tbh

xyz

Miley Cyrus.

I've been calling Beyoncé overrated for about 8 years, there's probably an age old thread on here with me saying the same thing
I don't deny her talent but I've only ever liked about two of her songs (and the only one I really care for is Crazy In Love) so given her status of course I'd find her overrated. I also don't find her as hot as everyone else does either

Gaga

Oh yeah. I'd forgotten about her. :joker:

All of them. In terms of music at least.

In terms of sexiness, it´s debatable.

All are overrated to a certain extent besides RihRih

- Lady Gaga (big time overrated)
- Miley Cyrus
- Taylor Swift (but she can be hit or miss, not totally overrated)
- Lorde
- Sia

Easily done in the year of 2017!

Cardi B

um :nono:

Had Lemonade not been a thing I would've said Beyoncé but I feel like she did take a risk with that and make an alteration in pop music so that saves her

Katy was overrated in the Prism era but less people care about her now so she's not really rated

How is Taylor Swift overrated?

The critics are hardly lining up to credit her talent or kiss her feet. She has been dragged through the pits the last couple of years.

I'd say critically Beyoncé has been overrated, BUT she is extremely deserving of the praise as her work is outstanding. However others have done work that hasn't received the same love when they deserved it. Solange for example.

I wouldn't call her a "pop girl" but I do think Adele is one of the most overrated artists of this generation.

Looking back i think Katy was great with Prism because Witness is a bad album the 3 singles,witness and hey hey hey are the only decent songs, the rest are filler and boring.

Taylor's new songs are good, but they're hardly record breaking are they?

Taylor by the general public, Gaga by the gays

Beyoncé, in music and looks

Agree with these too (I think Lorde is more overrated in USA though)

no shes amazing

Like you could forget about her. You mention her enough.

Clearly too much, off on a trip to banland it seems