Seriously! Own up!
 

DO you think ONE DIRECTION CAN SING???

Or is it cause they are fit like?

Liams a good singer and so is Harry

**** no.

They are alright singers.

Liam and Zain can definitely sing.. not so sure about the others. I think they sound good together though as a group.

They arent bad. Nowhere near as bad as people on here make out.

And Liam is good, definitely.

no there worse than what i make out.:hugesmile:

My Opinion!

Liam is the only good singer (Average at best)

All the others are pathetically bad and are only in cause of their looks.

Plus I am astonished how Zain is in as he has not sung in tune yet! Wagner is better!
Sorry Stacey.

I think they're carried by Liam really, Harry and the Blonde one have decent voices but the other two SHOULD be glorified back up singers. I don't know why they keep giving Zain solos :laugh:

Zains voice isnt strong enough for solo. He sounds like hes whispering D:

they're alright singers but far too young for me, fit wise!

Yes they can. I refer everyone to their first [and best so far, might I add] performance:



It was actually this performance that made me begin supporting them, contrary to what jedward_fever seems to believe. They've not had great performances on the Live Shows because the backing track has been so loud - through no fault of their own. But generally I support the most commercially viable acts - and they are one of them.

Nah, I find them a bit cringey to be honest. I do belive Liam is very talented and in my opinion should have been put throught to the boys group.. but the rest of them are fairly bland.

the reason why they have the backing track so loud is because there ****,and i think they have zero stage pressence.

They can sing, not wonderfully, but they can. They also are good-looking, but I'm not personally attracted to them, they just seem so young somehow (younger than they actually are).

I do like them though, and I'm not sure why. There's just something very likeable about them. I don't vote for them and I wouldn't be gutted if they left or anything, but I quite like having them in the competition.

You think their judges houses performance was ****e?

yes.

LOL. Each to their own I guess :)

Matt
Rebecca
Aiden
Paije
One Direction/Mary depending on how they're next performances turn out

Boybands do not have to be great singers. They are a pop package deal and its more about a combination of good looks, personality, good songs and performance. Plus overall presentation.

Liam and a couple of others are half decent singers but nothing special.

but aren't one direction the new beatles:laugh:

They're alright. Getting better.

They sound good when singing together.

Oh I see what you mean now when you said you'd already answered, I accidentally posted it as a reply here instead of as a new thread, so had to delete it and post it as a topic :S

Liam definately can and really is too good to be hampered by the rest, the others are okay when all are singing but its just blending the voices, no real harmonising.

Zain always looks awkward and as if he doesn't know what's coming next and has too weak vocals to be given any lines, when he finishes a song as with Total eclipse of the heart, it was a waste of time, you could hardly hear him and the vocal was very shaky.

Liam,has the style and voice but is hampered in this group.