Music Debates: Re-Up ~ The 2nd Wave (Tulisa VS Alesha)
 

Rules:
I post a controversial musical opinion and participants debate out their side whilst staying as classy and elegant as they can be. Once a debate reaches a natural conclusion we move onto another.

THE RE~UP: After the debate has finished, the result is decided by a separate poll!

Debate 1:

Both have been used by Timbaland to break him out into stardom but who's the best of Keri and Nelly (take into account; vocals, presence, diversity, relevance and charts)

The Canadian queen has shown to go from urban RnB to the indie pop of the The Legend Indestructible with effortlessness.

Maneater alone ****s on Jesus' discography which is only a few songs isn't it? Slay a little, Furtado
http://i.minus.com/ibaUga3oeaZzsV.gif

Results so far:

Nelly Furtado vs Keri Hilson - Nelly
The Saturdays vs Little Mix - The Saturdays
Jessica Mauboy vs Kat Deluna - Draw
Cheryl Cole vs Nicole Schzeringer - Nicole
Fergie vs Gwen Stefani - Gwen
Miley vs Demi vs Selena - NewMiley
Spice Girls vs Girls Aloud - Girls Aloud
Christina Milian vs Cassie vs Ciara - Christina
Kelly Clarkson vs P!nk - P!nk
Ellie Goulding vs Marina & the Diamonds - Ellie
Nicki Minaj vs Lil' Kim - Nicki
Jennifer Hudson vs Kelly Rowland - Kelly
Sia vs Foxes vs Paloma Faith - Sia

Jesus had one great album and after that I lost interest tbh. Also Loose > In a Perfect World I have to be realistic

I love a bit of our lord and savior kween keri but Nelly >>>>>>

http://i.minus.com/i4WC8WDZrk485.gif

http://i.minus.com/i4WC8WDZrk485.gif

I have no opinion on Hilson so Kween Nelly is victorious

This song > discographies

Have to say I haven't listened to her first album except I'm Like A Bird, is it worth a go?

Keri can have a few props for Return The Favor, which is a cute bop
http://i.minus.com/ibaUga3oeaZzsV.gif

Say It Right & Promiscuous > the other ones existence

tbh Nellys first two albums do nothing for me

Loose >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.

although Like A Bird, Turn Off The Light and One Trick Pony are jams

http://i.minus.com/i4WC8WDZrk485.gif

Also Reece this is one of the greatest thread ideas since the creation of the word

http://static.tumblr.com/v1asjlx/SGA...preach_gif.gif

remember this song :dazzler:

Keri Hilson was a flash in the pan, utterly forgettable IMO. If it weren't for the way Nelly Furtado debuted, I'd have said the same thing about her - the music she's made since reinventing herself as Timbaland's muse has been kind of awful but then you remember that this is the same woman who released I'm Like A Bird

Undoubtedly one of the best songs from Loose, SO underrated



ok the beat was plagiarised but who cares

I used to be OBSESSED with Nelly when I was like 11, I remember having a picture of the loose album cover on my Piczo page & when my friends laughed at it I said I was hacked :laugh:

Keri Hilson is at least 7 times better

:worship:

Thought we may as well hash it all out in one thread instead of new ones for each musical difference one has.
http://i.minus.com/ibaUga3oeaZzsV.gif

:joker:

Promiscuous was on my Piczo page at 11 :laugh: and ironically the site that provided the song was called musicjesus. Slay a little, Nelly

omg I was really bad at Piczo my page was literally just pictures

The Spirit Indestructable slays it deserved so much better

:dazzler:

This is one of the best songs of recent times, Nelly slaying those rock anthems.

The general consensus (bar Locke) appears to have reached an agreement that Legend Furtado is vastly superior....
http://i.cbc.ca/1.673486.1378504678!...p-11592714.jpg

Swiftly moving on
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi..._Sept_2011.jpg
vs
http://www.hellomagazine.com/imagene...x-nails--a.jpg

Nelly Furtado's 2nd album 'Folklore' remains her greatest work. :love:

Are there any songs from that album you could recommend? :spin:

The Saturdays for this masterpiece alone: