Which judges will remain?
 

Robbie said he was a huge payrise when he is already making £10m so rule him out

Ayda just hasnt worked

Louis is most likley but ITV may force Simon to make changes

Simon needs to get Paloma Faith, James Blunt and someone else on board.

Just Si

I could see Robbie doing it again but not without Ayda and she's probably going.

Simon will want to keep Louis but he's not a great fit for the show.

I can even see Simon stepping down and becoming more production based again rather than on screen.

They are all **** judges apart from Simon.

Simons worse than all 3 put together though :skull:

Simon is **** but he's watchable. The other 3 are more dull.

Simon has been terrible sine he had a child

ayda has been the best judge in ages ah lov ha :love:

we want louis tulisa kelly n simon

Just Simon I think

Queen ayda will be too busy judging American idol

Simon. Paloma Faith. Ellie Goulding. James Blunt. You got your lineup!

Haven't watched any of it this year and it was mainly down to the panel.

Ideally Simon will return with Louis Walsh but I think he might try and snatch Olly from The Voice (which would be a terrible career move on Olly's part because he's doing well on The Voice, and would be dropped after one series on XF). For the girls I'm expecting Rita Ora to return and perhaps he'll persuade Cheryl?

This is good but you could pick someone less dull than James Blunt :joker:

James Blunt has already been an X Factor judge and was anything but.

James Blunt might be a good idea. Hes hilarious on Twitter. Paloma’s persona is a bit too much for me though.

Bring back Sharron and Nicole!

She was alright on The Voice

Karen Matthews on tibb?

I actually think Louis is OK, he's a bit more serious than most judges but :shrug: it's good to have different personalities.

Robbie has been good when he's been there but ****ing off for 3+ weeks is ridiculous. If he's back he needs to commit to the full run FFS.

Robbie's wife can easily be replaced. She's not awful but there are plenty who would be better.

When was he an X Factor judge?

X Factor Australia

Ohhh

Get rid of all of them tbh, they’ve all been a bit naff

Louis and Simon. James Blunt is a hoot.

Simon wants them all back I think

Would be surprised if Ayda is back though

Doesnt he say that every year then sacks them all

Blunt is hilarious

I would expect Brendan Murray to be asked but he will reject it

He's so funny!!

Oop I think I'm thinking of the wrong person

They will all most likely be back

Liked Ayda in the audition stages then she made some questionable decisions at judges houses(olatunji?) Then she took it to deadlock between Shan and A&A (I mean really? Shan was so robbed!!) Then had been irritating ever since so she can do one

Robbie when he had been there has been pretty great to be fair but I don't think he has the dedication nor the time to do another series

Louis I have hated the whole series and really don't want him to ever appear on my TV again

Simon needs to come back! Wouldn't be the show without him but he has been so rude tonight first having a dig at Fleur but also saying he noticed Scarlett being nervous and hopes the 2nd song will save her it's not the time for critism especially his own act and then saying Dalton was his favorite of the night but also saying the right three made it through and she was the girl who made it the furthest because she was real; yeah well so were your other girls and Shan was so unjustified in being sent home so...

Lets have...

Simon, Nicole(I missed her doing the duets where she steals the limelight from the acts, Tulisa(she was pretty great as a mentor) and someone new I'm thinking, Craig David