David's dead was far superior

Punchgate isn’t even in the top 5 :laugh:

My top 5 would be

1. David is dead
2. Pantsgate
3. Punchgate's conclusion episode
4. All 4 Jackie Stallone episodes
5. Julie's eviction + HL's leading up to it

Kim is one of my favourites but adulterer is hardly a top 5 episode when not much really happens up till that point :laugh:

Literally 10 of Kim Woodburn's moments beat this.

This punchgate moment really wasn't alllllll that. :shrug: It was decent but.. for one, it was a bit too scummy to be THAT iconic and two, really one of the few greats parts about it was when Roxanne walked into the backyard and stopped and shook her head @ the others having a meeting about her lies / exaggerations :joker:

Stacey and Jessica arguing about who’s had a more difficult life after Jessica tried to defend Kim woodburn <3

Eh I wasn't really thinking about it as an entire episode but CBB19 still had multiple better episodes, maybe ones that aren't branded with names or are underrated in the BBUK community, and David's Dead is an obvious one that's better than this for me.

You do know I mean the episode she left

Put that in the title then

Otherwise people will assume you mean the actual ‘Incident’ episode itself

Its obvious tho

I don't remember the two (or 3 or 4) episodes apart regardless :joker: It was all one big blur for me

She didn't?

She had a couple of "moments" across a couple of episodes.

None of which provided one entire classic episode like the others mentioned.

:idc:

punchgate conclusion is definitely a classic episode but ok

It was a good episode, but probably not the best. I'm sure there was better in the glory days of Big Brother.

:nono:

it's like the most viewed episode in 3 years and the most talked about episode probably ever (maybe other than david's dead)

the CBB22 launch had 2.51 million viewers while Punchgate at most had 2.23 million viewers

(and let's not talk about how nearly all of CBB19's episodes beat that figure :smug:)

you really thought i was gonna go back and check all the figures huh, ANYWAY t'point is punchgate is undisputedly a classic

Honestly I would probably rate punchgate higher if more happened in a single episode, but it’s definitely more of a soap storyline played out over several episodes.

As an individual episode I’d probably put the Hardeep/Sally racism episode higher than the episode with the ‘incident’ tbh. The episode when everyone finds out/turns on Roxy is the best of the series though.

I edited the title, I thought it would be obvious, the ep of the incident was trash