[Tony Montana]

She was a fantastic islander and single handedly saved post Casa Amor last year. I'd even dread to think what we'd be watching if she wasn't there. Her constant claims about being ''loyal'' were an absolute scream to watch. Love her or hate her, she made S4, and is one of last years highlights and one of its best islanders.

That being said tho, no, she shouldn't return. In fact, I'd prefer it if no previous islander returns. They've all had their shot in the limelight, let some new batch of islanders take over.