Quote:
Originally Posted by Toy Soldier
There is room to be sad, it is sad, the whole situation is sad for everyone involved... but I still maintain that it's not even in the same ballpark as a human death and I still find it weird that people are quicker to react to it. And also, this idea that a dog's life is comparable to pretty much any human life is total madness. Unless we're talking about a truly horrendous human being, it just isn't.
|
There seems to be so much confusion in yours - and certain other members - abstract thought processing T.S.
On other threads - notably concerning ISIS or CHRISTIANITY - when usually countering my views:
A) You DENY God and Creationism and condemn religion.
B) You ADVOCATE Darwinism and the secular accident of Evolution.
Therefore - by your own often expressed opinions - HUMANS are nothing more than just another species of ANIMAL.
We may be
'prima inter pares' - 'first among equals', 'top of the food chain' - but by your definition we are mere animals nonetheless.
Now on THIS thread, you plead the UNIQUENESS of humans above ALL animals?
Without GOD just WHY then do you propose that we are unique?
Dogs, cats, corvids, cetaceans, primates, and a host of other animals display moral, cognitive and conscious behaviour. Even the humble Flatworm has qualities we humans lack. So Humans are no more 'Special' than any other animals - in fact; the word “special” is merely the adjectival form of “species”.
So being on an 'Equal Footing' with any other animal, is one human's LOVE and FONDNESS for his/her DOG any LESS VALID than another human's LOVE and FONDNESS for another human?
NO.
As humans we form attachments/relationships to satisfy our social needs - be they with other humans, with pets, or both, but INVARIABLY, a human-pet relationship is simpler and safer than human-human relationships, as equally rewarding, and involves less risk.
Pets - especially DOGS - can be accepting, openly affectionate, honest, loyal and consistent; all qualities that satisfy a person‟s basic need to be loved and feel self-worthy.
Unlike humans, Dogs will rarely 'Bite-The-Hand-That-Feeds-Them', and a dog's love is often more genuine, intrinsic, and instinctive.
So I will come to your statement that:
"And also, this idea that a dog's life is comparable to pretty much any human life is total madness"
And say; No - it is NOT madness and you are wrong.
The day I see a dog abduct a child from its mother, take it onto bleak moorland, torture it, then murder it.
The day I see a dog behead a cowering innocent human.
The day I see a dog set fire to a terrified innocent schoolteacher and burn her alive.
and the day I see a dog mercilessly beat an 84 year old pensioner to death after he has already surrounded his life-savings
is the day when I will agree with you and apologise to you.