[Tom]

She was great in the earlier rounds but in the live shows she only seems to like her own acts and finds fault with everyone else. Shes not as constructive as she was in previous rounds and shes become very annoying too

Shes an absolute crap judge and I hope she doesn't return next year so she can make space for Nicole Scherzinger when she gets booted off the American panel

[Smithy]

Kelly >>>>>>>>

tbh

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Kelly >>>>>>>>

tbh

To be fair shes still the best out of the new 3 but thats not exactly hard when you're up against personality vaccuum Gary Barlow and a Tesco Value Cheryl, but at least those 2 are a little less biased and give good feedback

[Kerry]

What? You don't think she's Putting it Dooooooooown????

[Locke.]

Better than Danni, much better than that twat Nicole, but still isn't very good.

Get Cheryl back instead.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Tulisa & Louis >>

[Strictly Jake]

I love kelly

[Z]

Some of the things she did on the audition shows were pretty funny but I've not been able to see her feedback on YouTube ('cause the X Factor channel just shows the performances) but she does tend to just say very vapid things that don't really grab my attention.

[Callum]

I liked her in the auditions and boot camp but have been going off her ever since. The phrase "put it down" really irritates me now and I get the impression she sometimes bites her tongue instead of saying what she really thinks of the performance. I miss Dannii, she was a better judge.

[Doogle]

I'd rather the judging panel were Simon, Danni, Kelly, Louis if I could choose.

Actually no, it'd be Simon, Sharon, Louis...but I won't go into that again.

[Tom4784]

Dannii was better but I really like Kelly, she's very entertaining.

Also I'm sorry but Tulisa a Tesco version of Cheryl? LMAO. I thought I'd hate her but Tulisa's been a brilliant judge, unlike Cheyl she's got a personality and she actually knows what she's going on about. Cheryl's comments were the epitome of vapid pointless rubbish. She never said anything constructive.

[MeMyselfAndI]

My judging panel would be (out of the people who have been there):

Louis,Tulisa,Danii & Simon.

[LeatherTrumpet]

She is about as useful as a marzipan missile

[Jords]

I like her but I dont really think shes essential. Never really get constructive critism out of her.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

Dannii was better but I really like Kelly, she's very entertaining.

Also I'm sorry but Tulisa a Tesco version of Cheryl? LMAO. I thought I'd hate her but Tulisa's been a brilliant judge, unlike Cheyl she's got a personality and she actually knows what she's going on about. Cheryl's comments were the epitome of vapid pointless rubbish. She never said anything constructive.

Cheryl: "You're my cup of tea with 2 sugars"
Tulisa: "You're just my cup of tea"

Its all Tulisa said last night, then look at their image too, like they're off the same conveyor belt

Tulisa has the personality of a wet lettuce. I do quite like her and she can be a bit constructive at times but ultimately shes boring

Originally Posted by Doogle

I'd rather the judging panel were Simon, Danni, Kelly, Louis if I could choose.

Actually no, it'd be Simon, Sharon, Louis...but I won't go into that again.

Simon, Sharon & Louis best panel ever

Would've liked to have seen Cheryl Cole on the panel with Sharon

[StraightEdge695]

i like her

[Ryan57]

Found her annoying from the start.

[Marc]

Kelly is brilliant. She would have been better suited for the groups though

[WARING]

Kelly is a horrible judge. Voting Amelia Lily off was the last straw. Amelia Lily WAS the best girl she had IMHO.

[Marc]

Originally Posted by WARING

Kelly is a horrible judge. Voting Amelia Lily off was the last straw. Amelia Lily WAS the best girl she had IMHO.

See I saw her as the weakest and the least likely to do well after TXF and deal with each week (her and Janet) I think the decision was just.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Marc.

See I saw her as the weakest and the least likely to do well after TXF and deal with each week (her and Janet) I think the decision was just.

I think Amelia was the most likely of the girls to win but I can see Misha having a huge career after X Factor whether she wins or not. As Gary said at the weekend watching her perform is like watching the guest performers, not a contestant

Don't get me wrong Kelly is a great mentor and other than Amelia's first song she has been consistently spot on with songs and arrangements. she knows exactly what shes doing, but where it counts is her criticisms and advice which as it stands is non existant.

[AndyEssex1]

Kelly has that typically annoying habit of not being able to say anything bad about someone. When she watches a bad performance on the live shows, I think she is a little dumbfounded. She was great at the auditions, especially when she was arranging the harmonies for the groups.

Tulisa in my opinion has sold herself out to the media circus. I cringed when she said "everybody's been waiting to hear the feisty side of me, so here it is ..... Gary, you're a muppet"

Embarrassing

[AndyEssex1]

Kelly has that typically annoying habit of not being able to say anything bad about someone. When she watches a bad performance on the live shows, I think she is a little dumbfounded. She was great at the auditions, especially when she was arranging the harmonies for the groups.

Tulisa in my opinion has sold herself out to the media circus. I cringed when she said "everybody's been waiting to hear the feisty side of me, so here it is ..... Gary, you're a muppet"

Embarrassing

[Colbert-Bump]

The live shows have been dreadful. At least Kelly & Tulisa are successful, Dannii's music career is something to forget.