[Tom4784]

I think it is, Hopefully next series he leaves. He is the weak link in the judging panel who is stuck in the past. His song choices are always almost horrible and he votes tactically to get rid of stronger singers. Plus he's a tosser who tries to outsmart Simon only to get bitchslapped back down. Bring in someone who actually knows what they are doing I say. All he's capable off is telling people to stand up off a stool at key changes and air grabs.

[hannah.]

Yep, definitely

[hannah.]

Especially seeing as I'm sure simons onto the fact that he's being sabotaged

[rayheartbliss]

i think simon is thinking of that!



maybe he'l get will young to be a judge because he kept on goin on about him caring for what the contestants are doing...so maybe

[Loukas]

Yeah it is. He is a grupmy old fool. Maybe Will Young will replace him?

[Tom]

I want them to bring in a well established DJ (that isn't Chris Moyles) to replace him then the panel is covering basically everything. Dannii knows about performing in general and being successful on a global scale, Cheryl knows what position the acts are in, what they are going through and what it takes to be successful and shake off the reality TV tag, Simon knows about the managers side and what is successful and what isn't, and the DJ would know about what is popular with listeners and what the public want.

Louis is past his sell by date and isn't needed on the show anymore. If the show can survive Sharon quitting then it can definitely survive Louis quitting. He just doesn't gel into the panel anymore like he used to when Sharon was there and he's turned into a pathetic old man with cringeworthy come backs in arguments.

[Princess]

Yes!!!!!!

I'm ashamed that we have people like that representing Ireland.

[Killian]

Originally posted by Princess
Yes!!!!!!

I'm ashamed that we have people like that representing Ireland.

I agree! He needs to go by next series. He's childish, immature, and completely unprofessional.

[Locke.]

No, Louis is my favourite.

[Dom:D]

I think he should go but it wouldn't be the same

[SiaSiaSia]

Originally posted by David
No, Louis is my favourite.

You always have to be different

[Tom]

Originally posted by SiaSiaSia

You always have to be different

I know, its getting boring/predictable now

[Locke.]

Originally posted by SiaSiaSia

You always have to be different

He is my favourite, though. And I agree with most about X Factor acts this year.

[rayheartbliss]

let him be if hes favourite is loius!

but he does need to be replaced. i dont see what help hes giving to the contestants, hes just trying to be the stick judge now!


bring back frieman! lol

[NettoSuperstar!]

He went before and we missed his silly childish comments god love him hes hilarious!