[JerseyWins]

I don't think Survivor would ever do this but I personally would love to see this. A season with a bunch of terrible players playing against each other. People who have made obvious dumb mistakes, maybe got carried to the end as a goat, or destroyed their game early as an early boot.

Who would you cast in an 18 or 20 person season with this theme? (not sure what the exact name would be either)

[JerseyWins]

Dreamz and Phillip came to my mind immediately when I thought of this just now. Jason (Micronesia) just came to mind now as well. I'll probably try to think of a full list at some point but I'd like to see what others think.

EDIT: I think this would be a good way to get Alecia Holden back on the show even though she wasn't that bad of a player. But the Mental Giant being such an early boot and making a lot of enemies early kinda fits the bill I guess.

[Calderyon]

Franceska and Woo.

[DouglasS]

Lill [Survivor; Pearl Island - I know she made it far, but she was a mess at her first tribe and was kinda a mess thoughout flip flopping and was so bad at final tribal council
Courtney [Survivor; Panama - There was a reason almost everyone wanted her at F2 - a messy character also - good TV]
Sylvia [Survivor; Fiji - That architect that annoyed everyone and looked for idols blatanlty she was hilarious
Sandy [Survivor; Tocantis - she had no clue but was interesting]
Francheska [Survivor; Redemption Island/Camaroan - Kinda have to have her on a season of 'bad players']
Shambo [Survivor Samoa - lol]
Na'Onka [Survivor; Nicaragua - enough said]
Abi Maria
Roxy [Survivor; Phillipines]
J'tia [Survivor Cagayan; her in immunity challenges lol]
Nina [Survivor; One World]

Shane [Survivor; Panama - great TV - he had no clue how to play the game though and was just dumb and people disliked him]
Chicken [Survivor; China - he was so dumb, might be interesting to see him again]
Dreams [Survior; Fiji - Mess]
Erik [Survior Micronesia/Caramon - I really like him, but hes made one of the dumbest moves ever]
Randy [Survivor Gabon/Heroes vs Villans - he'd bring drams]
Jimmy T [Survivor Nicaragua - he was so bad but in a funny way]
Matt [Survivor; Redemption Island]
Tarzan [Survivor; One World]
Zane Knight [Survivor; Phillipines - I swear he offered himself up as strategy wtf - may need to see him again]
Shamar [Survivor; Caramoan - he made me lol and dragged his whole team down and they still kept him]

There are terrible players in people like JT but I couldn't bare to see him again

[JerseyWins]

Yeah a lot of those would make perfect sense.

Forgot about Francesqua... they'd have to include her in this after two first boots. Imagine if it happened a third time --- or she won a season like this.

A season like this is just made for Abi's 3rd appearance. Courtney & Shane's returns would be imminent too (even though I don't like Courtney but whatever I wouldn't mind seeing her again).

[AarynGriesfan]

Tai belongs on this season.

[Headie]

Russel Hantz xoxo

[reece(:]

It's a shame about Fran snatching first boot twice as she seems quite capable as a strategic player

[reece(:]

Tribe 1 - Terrible and youthful
Chris Noble (Ghost Island) - for a second coming of the well gathering.
Patrick Bolton (HvsHvsH) - young and abrasive!
Alecia Holden (Kaoh Rong) - also young and abrasive!
Liz Markham (Kaoh Rong) - a second chance might see her try to have human emotion again?
Woo Hwang (Cagayan) - honour and integrity over smart gameplay anyday!
Vince Sly (Worlds Apart) - a nutty hippie
Jon Misch (SJDS) - fun and aloof!
J'Tia Taylor (Cagayan) - the worst challenge performer ever?
Kat Edorsson (One World) - the cringe factor
Angie Layton (Philippines) - cookies > tribemates <3

Tribe 2 - Terrible and "wise"
Wendy Jo (Nicaragua) - frantic and eccentric oldie!
Jimmy Tarantino (Nicaragua) - deserves a second chance and was a MESS.
Abi Maria - crazy brazilian woman about to turn 40? Yes!
Keith Nale (SJDS) - stick to the plan!
Kass McQuillen (Cagayan) - will bring the usual chaos
Dan Lembo (Nicaragua) - insert gif of him jumping into the water and throwing the ball
Sandy Bergin (Tocantins) - ha mouth would get ha in trouble
Crystal Cox (Gabon) - I think everyone would be here for a 40 year old Crystal Cox!
Jean Robert (China) - would bring drama
Lisi Linares (Fiji) - no explanation needed