[LeatherTrumpet]

Said Gbarlow on Sunday blah blah blah

Do the judges not realise that Misha has been in the bottom 2 twice now.

People dont like her. They will not buy her material.

Its time the judges stopped being scared and told kelly and her mini-me that misha is crap and to f right off

[King Gizzard]

Bit like Danyl a couple of years ago

[Benjamin]

To be fair, it's not like the British public have much sense when it comes to the X Factor. They voted Matt Cardle winner last year and then nobody bought his music.

Maybe it's about time somebody that wasn't popular won, she may actually have some talent that would do well in the music industry.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Nathan

Bit like Danyl a couple of years ago

Yeah, i was thinking that too, though I think in both cases the judges had something to do with it by accusing them of being nasty to other contestants/bullys

[Callum]

She can never win now so next time she's in the bottom 2 they should vote her out. The public are not warming to her, she is an extremely talented vocalist but I think the bullying comments in week 2 turned a lot of people against her.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

To be fair, it's not like the British public have much sense when it comes to the X Factor. They voted Matt Cardle winner last year and then nobody bought his music.

Maybe it's about time somebody that wasn't popular won, she may actually have some talent that would do well in the music industry.

At the end of the day though, people vote for who they like best not who they think will get farthest career wise. I don't see why people shouldn't do that either, it's just an entertainment show and that's how people see it, we're not music producers you know.

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

At the end of the day though, people vote for who they like best not who they think will get farthest career wise. I don't see why people shouldn't do that either, it's just an entertainment show and that's how people see it, we're not music producers you know.

It isn't BB though, that's the trouble. Just because somebody is nice doesn't qualify them to win the show. Look where it has got most of the winners in previous years.

I know the fans are not music producers, but the point of this show is to find recording artists who have the X Factor, I think that has happened only once (Leona Lewis), every other year has been a hollow victory.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

It isn't BB though, that's the trouble. Just because somebody is nice doesn't qualify them to win the show. Look where it has got most of the winners in previous years.

I know the fans are not music producers, but the point of this show is to find recording artists who have the X Factor, I think that has happened only once (Leona Lewis), every other year has been a hollow victory.

No, you misunderstood me, I don't mean that people vote for who they like most personality wise. I mean vocally. But the person with best vocals isn't always the most marketable.

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by Callum

She can never win now so next time she's in the bottom 2 they should vote her out. The public are not warming to her, she is an extremely talented vocalist but I think the bullying comments in week 2 turned a lot of people against her.

This as well as the fact that she admitted she was a bully to others at school (which she may well have grown out of, but I seriously doubt it) - she has a real arrogance about her - and yes, I know that that arrogance is what got a lot of stars where they are today: difference was: they managed to make their public persona likeable....Misha isn't able to do that - or at least, no so far.

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

No, you misunderstood me, I don't mean that people vote for who they like most personality wise. I mean vocally. But the person with best vocals isn't always the most marketable.

Oh, my bad.

I do think X Factor has had its day now though. The whole point of the show seems to have been lost and the fact that after 8 years there has only been one winner that really had much impact on the music industry kind of reflects that the show is pointless.

[MusicXian]

Like last night on XtraFactor she called Craig a biscuit factory boy while MCing in one of their preview things. Fair enough, she didn't mean it in a bad way and it was actually funny, but you can see how other contestants may take her the wrong way.

On the record contract thing, she is a much poorer version of Missy Elliot, not sure she would sell records after the show as she isn't likeable either so even if she gets signed up, she will be dropped after 1 album I think.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

Oh, my bad.

I do think X Factor has had its day now though. The whole point of the show seems to have been lost and the fact that after 8 years there has only been one winner that really had much impact on the music industry kind of reflects that the show is pointless.

I think you're right and I think the whole competitiveness amongst the judges is getting tiresome and quite nasty towards the contestants some of whom are only kids really.

[Toxic]

Originally Posted by MusicXian

Like last night on XtraFactor she called Craig a biscuit factory boy while MCing in one of their preview things. Fair enough, she didn't mean it in a bad way and it was actually funny, but you can see how other contestants may take her the wrong way.

On the record contract thing, she is a much poorer version of Missy Elliot, not sure she would sell records after the show as she isn't likeable either so even if she gets signed up, she will be dropped after 1 album I think.

Misha'a voice is incredible, she is literally one of the best vocalist ever seen on X Factor and people hate her for that reason, the British public do this to every act who show any slight bit of confidence, they did it with Cher last year and Danyl the year before that. People who state Misha is a bad singer or average are either deaf, deluded or just saying it because they want their favourite to do better.

And the biscuit factory boy comment was a joke, Craig laughed himself and he doesn't even work there anymore anyway - the fact you have taken that comment as ammo to say she comes ascross as nasty shows you will slag her off no matter what.

At the end of the day, if an act shows confidence which Misha definately has done in every performance, then the British public will brand them as 'big headed' or 'cocky' or say that they 'have a bad attitude', but in reality Misha has never done anything to show any of the things listed, its all in peoples heads and the Tulisa comments a few weeks back have ruined any chance for Misha in this show.

[MusicXian]

She has a good voice but I dislike the way she does that snarl thing in all of her songs.

I didn't use that comment as such, just saying she prob does say things to the contestants and not all of them have a sense of humour like Craig!

[Livia]

There no doubt she's a good singer, but I just don't like her.

[Kate!]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

Oh, my bad.

I do think X Factor has had its day now though. The whole point of the show seems to have been lost and the fact that after 8 years there has only been one winner that really had much impact on the music industry kind of reflects that the show is pointless.

Is this Leona or Alexandra?

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by Livia

There no doubt she's a good singer, but I just don't like her.

her voice is 10 a penny and is replicated by hundreds of backing singers up and down the country

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Nathan

Bit like Danyl a couple of years ago

Forgot about him!


And I reckon Gary said that just to make his reasoning in keeping Misha sound better.

[Z]

Well personally I thought she was arrogant and didn't like her before Tulisa said anything. And as if Cher and Danyl are the only contestants who have been "confident" and therefore been automatically dubbed as arrogant/cocky/big-headed. They get those labels for a reason - because of their personality - not because of their performances. Marcus is hardly shy and retiring behind vocals, he's putting on big performances each week but he's not being branded with the same label. She's full of herself, too much so, and that's why people don't like her. She's not going to win but she could well pull off a solo career if the judges cheat her into the final, like they did with Cher last year.