[BigBruddah17]

BB1: Underrated
BB2: Underrated
BB3: Underrated
BB4: None
BB5: Underrated
BB6: Overrated
BB7: None
BB8: Overrated
BB9: Underrated
BB10: Overrated
BB11: None
BB12: Underrated
BB13: Overrated
BB14: Underrated
BB15: Underrated
BB16: None
BB17: None

[Shaun]

Underrated: BB4, BB8, BB1, CBB12 and CBB10.
Overrated: BB10, BB14, CBB16 and CBB13.

[Daniel.]

Overrated: BB9, BB14
Underrated: BB6, BB10, BB13

[Cal.]

Overrated: BB14, CBB13
Underrated: CBB10, CBB17

[Babayaro.]

Overrated: BB17 (still liked it though)
Underrated: BB9. BB6 is underrated by the casuals

[Looper]

To be fair I've only watched from BB1 to BB10.

Overrated: BB9 and BB7 (like it a lot but it did lose it's way mid way through, doesn't deserve to be anywhere near the top of BB's list)

Underrated BB4 (go ahead and shoot me , but I think it's far better then many give it credit for, no it's not a classic but it's nowhere near the worse imo)

BB10 (I thought it's first weeks were top notch, although it did badly lose it's way in it's last few weeks and I didn't like Sophie winning it she was undeserving and that every guy was fawning over Noirin and the show was kneeling to her demands. Also it has one of my most hated guests in Bea, she made for a great villain. But it's got some of BB's greatest moments and is deserving to be held up alongside peak BB for me)

[Epic.]

Overrated: BB17, CBB3, CBB13, CBB16, CBB19
Underrated: BB16 (still don't particularly like it though, but it is by NO MEANS the worst series), CBB8, CBB9

[reece(:]

Overrated: BB9, BB12
Underrated: BB3, BB8, BB10

[Daniel-X]

Underrated: CBB10, CBB17, CBB6
Overrated: CBB12, CBB4 (I mean I enjoyed the series but it certainly isn't what it's made up to be.)

[Ashley.]

BB5/BB17 overrated, BB8/9/10 underrated.

(I'm sure Lostie can vouch for me on BB9 x)

[Pete.]

Overrated: BB13, CBB16

Underrated: BB3, BB8, CBB6, BB11, CBB12, CBB15, (BB15)

[y.winter]

Overrated: BB5
Underrated: BB8-11

[Jamie89]

I'd say BB1 is hugely underrated, it's a much simpler kind of show but personally I love it. There's some great housemates, all of the interaction/drama is natural, no producer manipulation, and it stands alone as being the only series where the housemates had no idea what to expect. There's also more excitement to the live eviction shows because it was all so new and obviously such an unexpected success at the time and seeing that build week after week, I mean starting the finale with Davina in a helicopter... when will Emma? I love it.