[lily.]

I will start a topic for each week, so that we can discuss the performances, and who went out etc.

In my opinion Chico shouldn't still be there, when real talented singers are fighting for their place (ie. Chenai). 4tune were no great loss because I don't think they would have cut it as the weeks went on.

I think Phillip was saved through the Irish backing, and also because he is a good looking guy. I also think the Conway Sisters are getting the Irish vote although I do not think they deserve it. The one who sings lead is an ok singer, and the rest just "oooo" along with her.

Tonight was a good show though.

[Dan_]

Rankings for tonight?

1.Nicholas
2.Shayne
3.Journey South
4.Brenda
5.Andy
6.Maria
7.4tune
8.Chico
9.The Conway Sisters
10.Chenai
11.Phillip

[lily.]

Phillip was a wee bit flat, but I wouldn't have put him at the bottom! And, come on man!!! Chico at #8... *smacks you with a trout!* lol

[BigSister]

Chico shouldnt have gone tonight he didnt lol but I still dont like him. I thought Philip should have gone

[jrc]

I can't believe Chenai's still there! Now she's shocking. And Chico? How did he even make the live shows, anyway?

[Dan_]

Originally posted by Stropz
Phillip was a wee bit flat, but I wouldn't have put him at the bottom! And, come on man!!! Chico at #8... *smacks you with a trout!* lol

He was flat as a pancake. Even Cowell's coming round to Chico

[lily.]

Join the Chico haters JRC!!! I'm appalled that he got this far!

[jrc]

What number member can I be?

[lily.]

3 i think.. we are a small faction! Lmao

and, Dan, I prolly have a soft spot for Phillip cuz he is a good lookin lad!

[BigSister]

Im a member too and im the founder member of the Hate louis Walsh club

[lily.]

oh, in that case JRC, u have to be 4.. cuz there's me, BigSister, and PiperGun.. and now u..

LoL@the Loui hater! nice one girl!

[jrc]

How do you get the writing red?

[Dan_]

Oh I will join that club Rebecca.

Philip looks like Connor off Neighbours.

[lily.]

u put [ color=red ] then type the words.. dont put any spaces between the [ and the words tho.. and. when ur done put [ /color ] .. again, without spaces.. k

[jrc]

Thanks, I've done it now. Thanks for letting me join your club. I've got to go now, but I'll talk to you later.

[lily.]

later mate!

[BigSister]

Dan

[lily.]

k guys.. gotta shoot.. catch up with you later.. be good! xxx

[Pipergun]

Glad to see we've got more recruits for the hate Chico movement!

Did you hear how when Sharon said "Chenai" Louis twisted her into saying "to stay"? Such a twisted little man.

They should make a feature show on him entitled: "When Leprechauns Go BAD!"

[Arneldo]

Iam Very Disapponted in ALL of you!!

You voted to SAVE Coco!!!!

What have i dont to deserve that!!!!

And to put Chenai in the last 2! - How Dare you! lol

It should have been Philip and Coco in final 2!!

[makosifan]

yeah i agree with bb4eva i think philip and chico SHOULD have been the bottom 2.
Brenda was amazing tonight as was Shayne
I do like chenai and i am glad she was saved by Sharon

[Ruth]

I was really shocked by last night. IMO, Phillip was absolutely awful. He completely murdered that song, and should have certainly been in the bottom two.

I thought Nicholas and Andy were the best two performances of the night, with Brenda a close third. Last week, Nicholas ruined a lovely song, but last night he really pulled something special out of the bag. As soon as the music started, I recognised the song as Marvin Gaye and I wondered what on earth we were going to be subjected to - but fair play to Nicholas for giving the performance that he did. I also thought Andy was superb - no surprises there. Brenda s great and I think she'll go a long way, because she's also got such a lovely personality. Maria was good too, and looks amazing.

I thought Shayne was okay, but wasn't as amazing as the judges kept going on about. A lot of his appeal is in the way he looks, especially as far as Sharon's concerned! But to be honest, I really can't stand that song he sang, so it was difficult for me to be objective.

I thought Chenai's performance was okay, but nothing special to be honest, but I didn't think she deserved to be in the bottom two.

Journey South were great. 4Tune were boring, but that was mainly down to the song they sang. I could not believe that they were in the bottom two. The Conway Sisters were better than last week, but still boring and forgettable.

I can hardly believe I'm going to say this, but I actually enjoyed Chico's performance last night. He's not a great singer, in fact a lot of the time I could hardly hear him, but he made me smile. I pretty much agreed with what Simon said about him.

I thought the bottom two should have been Phillip, who was always pretty forgettable, and last night was terrible - and The Conway Sisters, who are just boring.

Also, the bitching between the judges - especially Simon and Louis - is getting tedious. It's Louis far more than Simon. When Sharon had to pick between 4Tune and Chenai, he kept saying she should save Chenai because he saved Chico last week. That's a pathetic reason to save someone; it's not about the judges doing favours for each other, it's about saving the best act. And he's always trying to humiliate Simon. If they do another series, I really hope that Louis isn't in it.

[~Kizwiz~]

OMG…. Last night was great but I have to admit that I missed the booting off show! *shame on me*
Ok so as far as I’ve gathered it was 4Tune and Chenai that were in the bottom two which I was shocked about to be honest.

I don’t personally like 4Tune but I don’t think their performance was bad enough to put them in the bottom. However, I’ve believed all along that those type of “bands” are a bit outdated and have seen better days!

I thought Shayne’s performance was good, I didn’t like the song but he sang it well and I think he might last the distance. And I agree with Ruth that he wasn’t as amazing as the judges said he was!

Maria’s performance really impressed me. I wasn’t a big fan of hers but I thought she had a certain spark about her last night.

Journey South blew me away last week but I wasn’t too bowled over by them this week. I think they have a lot more to offer.

The Conway Sisters, Nicholas & Chenai didn’t light my fire I think they need to step up to the bench and really belt out some tunes to impress me.

Brenda was great but I still don’t think she’s got the X-factor! There’s something missing…. Sure she’s a great singer but I’m not convinced yet!

I was disappointed with Andy’s performance, I think he could have chosen a bitter song, he has a very powerful voice and I believe that he does have a future in music ahead of him! But does he have the power to become a star? I mean I liked Steve wotshisname last year but I knew he wouldnt pull in the punters when it came to selling records! And where is he now???

Phillip on the other hand….. What the hell is he still doing there???? Last nights song was shocking!!!! He looked like a rabbit caught in your headlights??? Scared, jittery and so flat you could sprinkle lemon juice on him and eat him for Shrove Tuesday! (I don’t like pancakes BTW)

Which leads me to the last person….. Chico! No words really can be uttered that sum up how I feel!
Ok….. Maybe one…… Shite!

[jrc]

Join the Chico to go go club. Just type in 'Chico-to-Go-Go Club - Member #4 - Chico haters unite!!!' do it in red.
Btw, the bottom two should definitely have been Chico and Chenai.

[Dan_]

How can you say Phillip shouldn't have been in the bottom 2, he was totally flat. Even Chico sang better than him!