[Jordan.]

Wagner - 3/10, 1/10
One Direction - 6/10, 5/10
Mary - 8/10, 6/10
Cher - 8/10, 10/10
Rebecca - 6/10, 6/10
Matt - 7/10, 9/10
Katie - 7/10, 8/10

[Mystic Mock]

wagner 9/10 7/10
one direction 0/10 0/10
mary 8/10 7/10
cher 2/10 6/10
rebecca 4/10 7/10
matt 8/10 10/10
katie 0/10 8/10

[fruit_cake]

One Direction - 7/10, 8/10

Matt - 4/10, 8/10
Rebecca - 6/10, 7/10

Mary -5/10, 5/10
Cher - 6/10, 6/10

Wagner - 1/10, 1/10
Katie - 0/10, 7/10

[Maia]

Wagner - 10/10, 10/10
One Direction - 5/10, 5/10
Mary - 8/10, 7/10
Cher - 9/10, 8/10
Rebecca - 4/10, 7/10
Matt - 8/10, 8/10
Katie - 2/10, 3/10

[Stacey.]

Wagner - 3/10. 1/10. He sang way better in the first song, then just went back to his normal self again on the second one.
One Direction - 5/10. 8/10. Good night for them, the second song showed off their vocals, they sounded great on it.
Mary - 2/10. 5/10. So boring. Preferred her doing a more upbeat song though, it suits her better and shows she's versatile.
Cher - 10/10. 10/10. Amazing night for her. Thought it couldn't get any better when I heard her first song, then the second one overtook it. She looked amazing, sounded amazing and gave another great peformance.
Rebecca - 6/10. 3/10. She was good on the first one, but not as good as normal. Then on her second song I just wished she'd done another ballad or something.
Matt - 8/10. 9/10. Amazing night for him. He's got everything, he's versatile and looks like a star.
Katie - 8/10. 6/10. Great songs. Her first one well impressed me though, she tried to connect with the audience and stuff, and I think she sang it really well.

[joeysteele]

Have to say it was far better week than I thought it would be.

Wagner, 6/10 4/10 Loads better than I expected,2nd song I don't like though.
One Direction, 4/10 3/10 Poor overall on both for me.
Mary, 8/10 6/10 Great first song, weak 2nd song
Cher, 4/10 4/10 Didn't really like either performance.Just at best average.
Rebecca, 6/10 8/10 First song didn't work too well, nice to see her enjoy the 2nd one.
Matt, 8/10 10/10, Good 1st song but I love that Moody Blues song,Brilliant.
Katie, 4/10 7/10. Didn't hate her performances, think she is in the semi final.

Matt was amazing on The Moody Blues song 'Nights in White Satin', he 'must' record that no matter what happens to him now on the X Factor, faultless performance.

[Locke.]

Cher - 6/10 - 8/10 = 14/20
Matt - 6/10 - 8/10 - 14/20
Katie - 7/10 - 6/10 - 13/20
Rebecca - 4/10 - 6/10 = 10/20

Wagner - 5/10 - 3/10 = 8/20
One Direction - 3/10 - 2/10 = 5/20

Mary - 2/10 - 1/10 = 3/20

[nanaimo]

wagner 9/10 6/10
one direction 1/10 2/10
mary 8/10 7/10
cher 2/10 4/10
rebecca 8/10 9/10
matt 8/10 10/10
katie 1/10 2/10

Must say matt was outstanding tonight with nights in white satin, easily best performance tonight, Terrific

[Z]

Wagner 7/10, 3/10
One Direction 6/10, 5/10
Mary 6/10, 4/10
Cher 4/10, 3/10
Rebecca 6/10, 7/10
Matt 8/10, 9/10
Katie 2/10, 4/10

[Boothy]

Wagner - 10/10, 8/10 - His first song was incredible.
One Direction - 6/10, 4/10 - Not a good week for these, second song wasn't good at all.
Mary - 4/10, 4/10 - Boring act now. Probably gonna go tomorrow.
Cher - 2/10, 6/10 - her first song was awful and her second not much better.
Rebecca - 8/10, 10/10 - Second song was the best of the competition IMO
Matt - 7/10, 9/10 - Between him and Rebecca to win. Rebecca just edges it for me.
Katie - 4/10, 6/10 - Started off the competition well and has progressively got worse. Would put my money on her going tomorrow.

[Tom4784]

Wagner - WAGNER/10 Both performances were simply glorious.
One Direction - 5/10, 6/10 Decent but forgetable.
Mary - 7/10, 5/10 The first was better then the second but she's still boring.
Cher - 7/10, 7/10 She was pretty good, nothing new ut nothing bad either.
Rebecca - 7/10, 8/10 Best of the night, the first performance was a bit boring but I loved the second.
Matt - 6/10, 7/10 The first was better then last week but was ultimately generic. The second performance was better but nothing we haven't seen before.
Katie - 7/10, 7/10 Two good all round performances although she got a bit carried away in the first performance.

[Shaun]

Wagner:
8/10 for Creep
4/10 for Addicted to Love
12/20

One Direction:
1/10 for Summer of 69
2/10 for You Are So Beautiful to Me
3/20

Mary:
7/10 for All I Want is You
5/10 for Brass in Pocket
12/20

Cher:
1/10 for Girlfriend
5/10 for Walk this Way
6/10

Rebecca:
3/10 for I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For
8/10 for (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction
11/20

Matt:
5/10 for whatever his first was.
9/10 for Nights in White Satin.
14/20

Katie:
5/10 for Sex on Fire
2/10 for Everybody Hurts
7/20

[IheartBB]

#1
Wagner - Epic - 4/10
One Direction - Boring song choice. Disappointing after their previous 3 performances - 4/10
Mary - Good at times, flat at others (just like last week). Hopefully her time is up and she’ll be gone tomorrow - 4/10
Cher - The track completely ate her up. The tempo was too fast, it sounded like she was struggling to keep up. I must be watching a different show to those judges - 3/10
Rebecca - I thought this was rock week? Same performance for the 8th week in a row - why has it taken at least one of the judges this long to pick up on it?! - 3/10
Matt - Not his best, not his worst. It wouldn’t really matter either way, he’s safe as houses - 6/10
Katie - Great performance, but she doesn’t have the vocals to suit the rock theme - 5/10

#2
Wagner - Just as epic. And in all seriousness, his best two performances of the series - 4/10
One Direction - So much to say. First of all, this was an obvious ploy to (to quote South Park) “make little girl’s ginies tickle”. I’m in no position to say whether or not it worked. Second of all, the two at the end should have just gone home (and the Irish one can stay there) because they didn’t actually do anything. Zain (?) needs to stop with his jerky head when he sings because it distracts us from his pretty decent voice. Great vocal by Harry - he’s the star of the band and could have been a contender as a solo artist - 6/10
Mary - Very karaoke - 3/10
Rebecca - Make that nine performances without a single movement of her feet. Making a rock song into a soul song isn’t really fitting of the theme. At least this was up tempo... - 4/10
Katie - In her comfort zone with this song. Worthy of a place in the semis - 6/10
Matt - Clever choice of song. Best vocal of the night - 8/10
Cher - Not a good night for Cher. This song has been done to death and she did nothing to make it her own. Boring stuff - 3/10

[ElProximo]

In order starting from astonishing down to useless...

Matt - 8/10, 10/10
Rebecca - 8/10, 8/10
Mary - 8/10, 6/10
Wagner - wtf/10, wagner/10
Cher - 4/10, 4/10
Katie - 2/10, 2/10
One Direction - don't even watch or listen. zero to me.