[nanaimo]

The X factor is a total contradiction, we hear all the time about all the sixteen acts performing well last night but Nu Vibe were rubbish, not that i am a fan of 2 Shoes, the song they did was a poor choice, more like something kinda uck!, but Nu Vibe did not perform as a group compared to The Risk, who i am not a big fan of either but as a boy boy they were tight and performed as professionals, Nu Vibe sang as individuals and not as a group and was a poor choice to keep them in.
I don't get Frankie either, he has the appearance of a teen idol but his singing is weak and it is clear that he is garys favourite, James has more talent on his big toe than him and should have gone through, i think he would have got better and better as the weeks went by with the right song choices.
Is it a recording voice or a novelty act louis wants, it's geat to have an act that can be entertaining and fun but the have to be able to sing aswell, i think Johnny can sing but louis is doing what louis does best and that is turn someone with potential into a freak, he says we need a recording artist and then says we need fun, thats fine but the singing has to be tops, think this is the only category that got it right as Jonjo was the weakest act but if he wasn't so nervous he could have been great.
Now the main event and the strongest category, Like Gary, Sophie Habibis is clearly kellys favourite but i think she got this totally wrong, sophie lacks the charisma and charm of Amelia, who i thought would make it to the end and also has a clear love of music and one of the strongest voices, but after Jade not getting through who was the best female out of all of them, it doesn't surprise me Amelia is gone, this season of x-factor will be probably the most annoying one of all time, as we will see week after week, great talent being sent home and the favourites of the judges being kept as the public don't have the final say as we saw with Katie wassiel last year, hopefully Craig, janet, Rhythmix and a few more will stay until the end, maybe they will get it right and we hopefully will see early departures from Kitty, Frankie and Sophie, doubt it though

[Callum]

Sophie should have gone over Amelia, Nu Vibe over 2 Shoes and Frankie over James. That would have been my perfect outcome. I hope Amelia gets a record deal but even if she does I doubt she will have much chart success because she was out in week 1.

[H.Stacey]

yeah I wont deny Im beginning to get bored of them. We need new material.

This forum will never degenerate into the state that tatugirls forum is because there are moderators here.
But even when the moderators are beginning to question them, you should know that somethings wrong.

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by H.Stacey

yeah I wont deny Im beginning to get bored of them. We need new material.

This forum will never degenerate into the state that tatugirls forum is because there are moderators here.
But even when the moderators are beginning to question them, you should know that somethings wrong.

-prefers the viagra trolls-

[robb]

I though Jade and Amelia were nailed-on certs for the last 3....shows how much I know!!!

[Ryan244]

It was a poor twist they were always going to pick their favourites regardless.

[Rawrbear]

4/4 was wrong should of been
Frankie-Sung pretty bad that week
Sophie-Abit lost in copitition a Paige type
Nu vibe-Shocking
Johnny Robbinson- look for England next big singer, yeah he has a chance

[Doogle]

Misha shouldn't be there imo. Amelia and Sophie both deserve it.

But I'm worried people will turn on Sophie.