[fruit_cake]

who is yours out of all the judges please vote for your favourite three!

mine are 1,Danni 2,Tulisa 3,Louis

[Jordan.]

Simon, Tulisa and Dannii

[Niamh.]

Oh I only voted for one, woops, I would have picked Dannii & Louis, not sure about the third, how come Kelly isn't on there?

[Tom]

Sharon, Cheryl, Louis in that order

I really miss these days, so much better than series 4 onwards

[Callum]

1. Sharon Best judge ever, when she walked into the door with Louis was one of the funniest X Factor moments ever.
2. Dannii, great judge who gave constructive criticism every week.
3. Simon, I loved his brutal honesty in the earlier seasons so that's why I've put him 3. He was awful in his last two though.

[Locke.]

Louie

[fruit_cake]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Oh I only voted for one, woops, I would have picked Dannii & Louis, not sure about the third, how come Kelly isn't on there?

oops completely forgot about Kelly

[Adamw92]

Dannii

[Doogle]

Sharon, she made the show entertaining and it wasn't at the expense of the acts (Wagner, Johnny etc) and the singers remained as actual singers while she along with Louis and Simon made the judging panel a joy to watch and I loved watching it just for them sometimes. Dawn's audition in XF4 has to be one of my favourite TV moments of all-time tbh. Sharon however was a crap mentor, but she did know talent.

Then Danni, I found her a very good judge after XF4. She wasn't annoying, trying to show off, or trying to get attention (something admittedly Sharon did a lot) and she seemed to be a better mentor and always gave acts some good criticism when they needed it. I also don't feel like she was too biased towards her own acts which I liked.

Finally Simon, BEFORE Cheryl joined. The reason people loved him. Very critical and harsh, but had a soft spot for those with real talent.

The panel was just brilliant with the 3 oldies though. I like Danni, Tulisa and Kelly but it's just not the same with them. I liked it before the judges were singers and stuff, though it was good to have one so they have that experience but other than that I didn't care much for it.

[reece(:]

the oriiginals

[Harry!]

Miss Dannii Minogue <3 Team Minogue for life <3

[Marc]

Simon > anybody

[Smithy]

you missed kelly

[Jords]

1. Danni
2. Simon
3. Sharon
4. Tulisa

Simon lost his spark towards the later series, and Tulisa is most likely going to climb, love what shes brung this year.

[Smithy]

wtf you put nicole?

she was there for 2 weeks