[Tom]

Kelly who?

Some level of irony in that shes sat in Cheryls chair too

[Jords]

Shes coming across good! And it would be cool to have a winner a judge at some point, like Alesha over on SCD.

[Niamh.]

Surprisingly enough I like her, I hated her when she was a contestant.

[Vicky.]

I agree. But I do like Kelly too.

Would prefer Alex to replace Tulisa, but that wouldnt happen

[Locke.]

Better than Kelly but hasn't been amazing

[muchadoaboutnothing]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Surprisingly enough I like her, I hated her when she was a contestant.

I agree Niamh. I hated Alexandra as a contestant but not doing too bad, so far, as a judge. I find Kelly Rowland intimidating and she seems to have an aggressinve attitude. The typical shouting and pointing of fingers to get across her point of view regardless of what others think. Personally I wouldn't mind seening the back of Kelly.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by muchadoaboutnothing

I agree Niamh. I hated Alexandra as a contestant but not doing too bad, so far, as a judge. I find Kelly Rowland intimidating and she seems to have an aggressinve attitude. The typical shouting and pointing of fingers to get across her point of view regardless of what others think. Personally I wouldn't mind seening the back of Kelly.

I liked Kelly a lot during the auditions but I can't bear the sight of her anymore. I don't think shes right for the UK series because of her attitude but would be good on the US panel, just like Nicole was good on the UK panel but terrible in the US. If both sign up for another year they really need to swap them over. Would love to see a Gary, Alexandra, Nicole and Louis panel next year

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

agree. kelly is too american and uninterested

[Tom]

What do people think of Alexandra's "I might be back" comment? Just a quip towards Gary or letting the cat out of the back regarding Kelly and the whole situation around her?

[Gillian-73]

I liked her as a judge, i had thought she'd just be nicey nicey but she wasn't she made some good points and observations! i've gone off kelly.

[Callum]

Liked Alex to begin with but I'm looking forward to Kelly returning next week.

[Marsh.]

I never liked Alex so much when she was a contestant, she annoys me with her over pronunciations and overconfidence at times but I appreciated her attempts at giving positive and negative feedback with constructive criticism.

A refreshing change from Kelly's constant "You SMASHED it my girl. [Insert some inaudible American phrase]" *click click*

[Kerry]

Never liked her but I was pleasantly surprised

[Tom4784]

I thought she was a very good judge, I can definitely see them picking her up if one of the female judges leave.

[Callum]

She is getting so much hate on Twitter

[Black Dagger]

WHAT?

She was horrific...

Cringeworthy... no definitely not for me, cue the return of Kelly.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Callum

She is getting so much hate on Twitter

JLS fans who still bear a grudge 3 years on that made their minds up as soon as she was announced

Lose-lose situation though, Nicole would have got a lot of hate from Cheryl fans regardless of her performance

I think she lost it a bit towards the end. I'm no longer thinking she should be permanent but was a nice refreshing change and preferable to Kelly

[King Gizzard]

First time I've watched it this series, she was the best judge I think (and I think she's a completely overrated 'popstar')

She done well not to react to Gary when he said ''don't worry she's only here for one night''...I'd of gone off at him

[Callum]

Originally Posted by Nathan

She done well not to react to Gary when he said ''don't worry she's only here for one night''...I'd of gone off at him

Agreed, that was totally uncalled of from Gary. He really is the worst judge.

[Marsh.]

I think she was good for one night, if she was full time we'd get bored of her.

The start of the series everyone was happy with the refreshed panel but are now tiring of at least one of the four.

I think if anything this proves they need guest judges throughout the series. Especially in the live shows we need some variety because it's very tedious and we end up with the same thing every week.

[fruit_cake]

I can't stand Alex she's so full of her own importance and was very rude to Louis, Tulisa won't stand for it though if she stays hopefully. She's good for the show though much better than Kelly

[LeatherTrumpet]

Why they dont have Chris Moyles on is a mystery to me


Alexandra knows feck all about diddlysquat

[Tom]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Why they dont have Chris Moyles on is a mystery to me


Alexandra knows feck all about diddlysquat

Chris Moyles would be ideal to replace Louis when Louis is finally sacked/leaves. would be good to have a DJ on the panel too

[Black Dagger]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Why they dont have Chris Moyles on is a mystery to me


Alexandra knows feck all about diddlysquat

Because he's an egomaniac, bore and has said himself he doesn't really know an awful lot about music...

Plus isn't he one of those rooting against the X Factor not getting Christmas number I again this year?

[Beastie]

Alex was good last night. But X Factor is just a pile of poo which I watch because there is nothing else on.