[Janette]

We're down to four, who do you think will win?

I love Will but I think Gareth will win because his voice is more suited to pop.

[LEE]

I also think Gareth will win, though I'm afraid he's fourth on my list.

1 = Darius
2 = Will
3 = Zoe
4 = Gareth

However, as much as I prefer Darius and Will I think that Gareth and Zoe are far more suitable to the role of 'Pop Idol' and therefore I would be quite happy for either of them to win.

Both Will and Darius would be suited far more to a musical career that was not rectricted to the type of music and deal that the winner of this competition will be, and I think they will be better off not winning. Does that make sense?

Hopefully all of them will be offered music deals. I'm sure we have not seen the last of any of them.

[Mark]

Or wouldn't it be great if the 3 out of 4 people make a group together!!

That would be nice as one or two of them wouldn't be left out!

Mark

[Kaz]

This is difficult, as who I think will win is not necessarily who I want to win!

I think Gareth will win, with Will second, Zoe third and Darius fourth.

However, I would like Will to win, with Darius second, Gareth third and Zoe fourth.

I agree that Gareth's voice is better suited to 'pop' music, so that's probably why he'll win. However I think Will is the one with the special talent, who will ultimately have the most successful and varied career.

All four should, without question, be offered recording contracts, and I hope that they all go on to enjoy great success - they deserve it.

[kaphc]

Good point Kaz!

My "who I want to win" list is:

1. Will 2. Zoe 3. Darius 4. Gareth

but I think the final result will be

1. Gareth 2. Will 3. Zoe 4. Darius

Tho' I have to say at this stage I would quite happily listen to any of them sing. And I hope they bring out a CD / video of the best bits from the finals.

e.g. Hayley singing "Show me heaven " and "That Ol devlie called love"
Zoe singing "Get Happy"
Gareth singing the Abba song he did
Will singing just about anything except the Big Band song!

[Janette]

Originally posted by kaphc
And I hope they bring out a CD / video of the best bits from the finals.

e.g. Hayley singing "Show me heaven " and "That Ol devlie called love"
Zoe singing "Get Happy"
Gareth singing the Abba song he did
Will singing just about anything except the Big Band song!

I so agree with you, especially Hayley's two songs, she blew me away with both!

[Kaz]

That is a brilliant idea, kaphc.

It might just be a possibility, given that they brought out a video showing the best bits from all the auditions. I would certainly buy a CD of the best songs from the finals.

[Mark]

Maybe we, as a forum could write into Pop Idol and beg for Kate to read out the suggestion and see what the contestansts say......

Just an idea!

Mark

[chilledbootz]

I want Will to win. However i'm slightly disillusioned about Pop Idol and other shows like this. Last year all we and the press were talking about was Hear'say, how they could all sing, what each one would bring to the band etc, etc. This year even before Kym left it was Crap Hear'say this, can't sing, she's a bitch, he's gay(like there's something wrong with that!). It really annoys me, and while The Scum are building Gareth up now you can bet your life they'll come after him in a couple of months time. Just like they do with BB housemates

[kaphc]

I'm up for e-mailing Pop Idol - I'll find the e-mail address and let you know what I say.

I'm having pop Idol Party on Saturday where we watch ITV1 and ITV2 for hours and hours - how sad is that??

[LEE]

Very sad, but a damn fine idea!!

[Kaz]

chilledbootz - sadly, I have to agree with you. The British press's attitude to people in the news is abysmal. When they are flavour of the month, they are behind them and back them to the hilt (as the Sun did with Helen) 'cause they know it will sell papers. However, once they become less newsworthy they drop them like a stone (unlike us true fans!) and then take great pleasure in picking fault with them.

Just now they are backing Gareth to win Pop Idol but I've no doubt that, even if he does win, a few months down the line they'll be trying to dig up any dirt they can on him. It's sad, but unfortunately true that the tabloids only build someone up so that they can knock them back down again.

kaphc - it would be fantastic if you did e-mail Pop Idol. I'll be listening out on Saturday to see if your idea is read out on air. Fingers crossed!

[Rocks Lady]

I would like the results to be
1 Darius
2 Zoe
3 Gareth
4Will
But i think it will be
1 Gareth
2 Will
3 Zoe
4Darius
Good luck to them all they have all done well

[Janette]

Originally posted by Rocks Lady
I would like the results to be
1 Darius
2 Zoe
3 Gareth
4Will
But i think it will be
1 Gareth
2 Will
3 Zoe
4Darius

Why Darius? Not that I'm complaining, it's nice to see someone who's rooting for someone different!
Welcome to the board by the way

[LEE]

Originally posted by janette246
Why Darius? Not that I'm complaining, it's nice to see someone who's rooting for someone different!

Hi Janette

If you look back at my earlier post you'll see that Darius was top of my list too.

I've always liked him, even back in those rather embarrasing 'Popstars' days.

I'm not sure exactly why, there's just something about him that appeals. Will is probably a fairly close second and Gareth isn't even in the running.

[Janette]

I like Darius, he's cute and he's got a great voice, but where would you put that voice? He's definitely not pop material, maybe stage work would be better for him.

The same could be said for Will, can anyone really see Will singing a pop song?

In a way I hope Gareth does win because he isn't really good enough to be anything more than a pop singer!

And I've heard that Hear'say want Zoe! I don't know whether that's a good move for her or not, I don't think they're going to be around much longer.

[LEE]

Originally posted by janette246
In a way I hope Gareth does win because he isn't really good enough to be anything more than a pop singer!

Agree with you 100%. I prefer Darius and Will but think they will do better outside the confines of the show.

[Rocks Lady]

Why Darius? Not that I'm complaining, it's nice to see someone who's rooting for someone different!
Welcome to the board by the way
ok heres why lol
Darius Darius your the best
your better than all the rest
you have charisma
you have style
you have the ability to make me smile
you are handsome you are true
you make me vote for you
Darius Darius your the man
you can do it sure you can
we will be sitting with baited breath waiting for you to beat the rest
come on Darius we love you
show them all you can do it too
your my idol idol man vote for Darius cause he's the man

[LEE]

Like it Rocks Lady

On 'Pop Idol Extra' earlier this evening on ITV2 Kate Thornton was interviewing Simon Cowell and he said that he thought Darius had an excellent chance of winning it. He said that his share of the votes was getting more and more and that he was going to give both Gareth and Will a run for their money.

Go Darius Go

[Honey]

My favourite is Gareth because he just has everything a pop idol requires, and I'm sure he will win.
I think Will is an exceptional talent and will, I have no doubt be a huge star, although at first in pop, I think he will be more successful in a wider field.
Zoe again is very talented and will definitely be a popstar, she has the makings of a 'Diva' in the same vain as Aretha, all I can say is watch this space!
Darius is unique and different and has improved over the weeks, he will do well, but I'm not sure if he'll sustain a career in pop, but it takes all sorts so you can never tell!
All the remaining four have done incredibly well, even some successful popstars have been quoted as saying they would not have done even half as well if they had had to go through what the pop idol contestants have been put through, so hats off to them, and I hope they all do fantastically well, they more than deserve it.

[Janette]

Apparantly they are singing two songs each tonight, that should be good!

Looking forward to it, although I hate it when one leaves

I think Darius or Zoe will leave tonight

[Mark]

Oh no!!!

I just got home and asked my mum what happened and she said Zoe got awful comments and she might leave.....

What happened??

Mark

[Mark]

OMG its 21.29 and Zoe has left

Im in a state of shock!!!!!

Mark

[Janette]

If it makes all the Zoe lovers any happier, if the programme was having a female pop idol, she won! She was the last girl and she deserves a record contract.

[LEE]

I think all the four who sang tonight have proved themselves remarkably talented over the last few months. Last week Zoe sang brilliantly and was, in my opinion, the best. This week however I agreed with the judges that neither her or Will sang to their full potential.

Zoe does have a great voice, especially for a 16 year old, but tonight she was trying too hard and she was forcing her voice and over-singing. It's really easy to fall into this trap - I've been told on several occasions that I do it myself.

It's sad to see anyone go, but I think if it was judged soley on tonights performance it was right that it was Zoe.

I thought the best tonight was Darius - by quite a long way, follwed by Gareth then Will then Zoe.

Before tonight I thought the final two would be Will and Gareth, now I'm not so sure I think it might be Darius and Gareth.

As I have said before I'm sure we're going to see a lot more of all of these people, whoever eventually wins.

What do you all think?