[Cal.]

She can't control the judges, or any of her guests for that matter

The judges disagree with everything she says

Where is the justice for Sarah-Jayne?</3

[LeatherTrumpet]

She is fecking useless

[Liam-]

She's beyond awful, me thinks she should have stuck to the radio and left presenting to the professionals.. or at least someone who can actually control a show.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Flack and olly were fine

[Cherie]

Gave up on the xtra factor last year, sounds good might have to watch on catch up

[LeatherTrumpet]

It could be good but this girl is bobbins

[Liam-]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Flack and olly were fine

They were good, but not a patch on the lovely Willoughby!

[zakman440]

I love Sara-Jane, but I feel like the production of the show this isn't that good and too gimmicky (Judges in the studio rather than at the desk, letting them pick the callers etc).

[LeatherTrumpet]

she looks like




from Rainbow

[Jamesy]

Bring back Konnie Huq

[Marc]

Love her

[ruiphillips]

She is awful and needs to stop fake smiling

[LeatherTrumpet]

she kept on asking simon about a Harvester last night and he ignored her

Why?

Because it was a joke that ended like 3 weeks ago


Caroline or Holly would never have made that error

This girl will last 1 series

[Raph]

Holly was the queen of xtra factor.

But #JusticeforSarahJane

[Cherie]

Just watching it, she is AWFUL, no chemistry with the judges at all

[Firewire]

I actually really like her

[Cold Sweat]

I like her and have watched Xtra Factor more this series than i had ever previously watched it - because of her.

I also find myself tuning into R1 when her show is on...

[Strictly Jake]

She isn't too bad, for some reason simon seems to like to show the presenters up. He is always interrupting everyone at the moment, especially cheryl but he is also doing it to Sarah jane and dermot with the whole asking of his hand thing. I think the judges are making it really hard work for her. It would have been fine for Caroline as she was used to it but Sarah Jane is relatively new to this and trying to do a good job but there are lots of awkward moments. I think she will return next year but with a male accompanying her

[bwoty]

Originally Posted by ShakeyJake10

She isn't too bad, for some reason simon seems to like to show the presenters up. He is always interrupting everyone at the moment, especially cheryl but he is also doing it to Sarah jane and dermot with the whole asking of his hand thing. I think the judges are making it really hard work for her. It would have been fine for Caroline as she was used to it but Sarah Jane is relatively new to this and trying to do a good job but there are lots of awkward moments. I think she will return next year but with a male accompanying her

Maybe Ben Shephard?