[EspeonBB]

Cirie is flawless. I wasn't aware she had haters lol

[Headie]

She is my #1 favourite of all time. Sandra and Natalie make up my top 3. Crystal and Tasha top 5 (although there's so many I love I could legit make an endless list and the order changes daily tbh)

[EspeonBB]

My #1 of all time is either Cirie or Sandra I can't choose. Jerri, Parvati and Natalie Anderson make up the rest of the top 5

[Headie]

Originally Posted by EspeonBB

My #1 of all time is either Cirie or Sandra I can't choose. Jerri, Parvati and Natalie Anderson make up the rest of the top 5

Yeah Cirie and Sandra are definitely the indisputable top 2

There's so many amazing female contestants, it;s a shame there aren't that many male ones.

[Calderyon]

What Cirie is a three time loser.

In terms of wins, Sandra could be considered as the all time survivor, since she has 2 wins out of 2. Which i respect, even though i don´t like her.

[Headie]

Originally Posted by Calderyon

What Cirie is a three time loser.

In terms of wins, Sandra could be considered as the all time survivor, since she has 2 wins out of 2. Which i respect, even though i don´t like her.

Cirie is the ultimate mastermind of Survivor. She is literally the Danielle Reyes of Survivor...

[Calderyon]

"An ultimate mastermind" who i guess has lost 3 times on purpose then. And if she is ever brought back, will lose yet again.

Ultimate mastermind in her own mind.

[EspeonBB]

Lol Cirie was the mastermind in both Panama and Micronesia and would have won the latter season if it wasn't for the final 2 twist right at the end. In addition she has an amazing personality who makes her gameplay fun and exciting to watch, she is an amazing castaway and a true legend

Disliking her is fine but acting as if she is some flop who sucks at the game is not.

[Calderyon]

I didn´t really say she is a flop though, who s*cks at the game. Just not a mastermind or ultimate mastermind. And whether you like it or not, she has lost the game three times.

[Pete.]

Rupert has lost 4 times and Russell has lost 3 times and from what I've seen they're still adored as players

[iRyan]

There's something about Tasha I find irritating tbh

[Macie Lightfoot]

oh Tasha is definitely petty and smug and a bit of a petulant brat. Kass alleges that after she flipped in Cagayan Tasha didn't talk to her for, like, ten days and I fully believe it. I never thought Tasha was all that and I said before Cambodia that she's definitely the person who has the most potential to ruin her reputation.

Also alol I didn't know Cirie had a single hater, let alone someone who dislikes her WITH A VENGEANCE like what on earth.

[Braden]

My top 3 of the seasons I've watched so far:

1) Richard Hatch
2) Jerri Manthey
3) Ami Cusack

I'm watching Panama atm & love Cirie She's a fabulous narrator, and I can't wait to watch her future seasons. I've heard good things about Micronesia and pretty much know how it goes down, so I expect to like it.

[Headie]

I don't want to live in a world with Cirie haters

[iRyan]

Originally Posted by Braden

My top 3 of the seasons I've watched so far:

1) Richard Hatch
2) Jerri Manthey
3) Ami Cusack

I'm watching Panama atm & love Cirie She's a fabulous narrator, and I can't wait to watch her future seasons. I've heard good things about Micronesia and pretty much know how it goes down, so I expect to like it.

Damn, I totally forgot about her. She was a good castaway. I don't remember Vanuatu too fondly though.

[Calderyon]

Maybe disliking with a vengeance is a bit too much over exaggerated. A relatively major dislike would be more appropriate.

Also Rupert s*cks and i can´t believe that i used to like him at some point. And Russell, while i like him and consider him top 5-10 of my all time survivors ever, i do recognize his flaws. Like being delusional (on how people see him ie: jury control), super arrogant, ***holish and unable to take the backseat and adapt to the game.

[Pete.]

It's basically impossible to win survivor, so to only credit contestants who have only won is a bit flawed imo

[Calderyon]

The how can 29 people have managed to do that (one person has done it twice), if it´s impossible? You should have said, it´s very hard/extremely hard to win.

[Headie]

^He said "basically impossible", meaning very unlikely. Everyone only has a 1 in 20/18/16 shot of winning, which is a pretty small chance.

[Braden]

Originally Posted by iRyan

Damn, I totally forgot about her. She was a good castaway. I don't remember Vanuatu too fondly though.

It's fresh in my mind so I totally love it/her

I feel that it's a very underrated season, definitely one that I'm keen to re-watch in the future.

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Hayden

^He said "basically impossible", meaning very unlikely. Everyone only has a 1 in 20/18/16 shot of winning, which is a pretty small chance.

And a lot isn't dependent on strategy but on twists/swaps too.

[Calderyon]

Originally Posted by Hayden

^He said "basically impossible", meaning very unlikely. Everyone only has a 1 in 20/18/16 shot of winning, which is a pretty small chance.

Yeah, i agree with this.

[Headie]

Originally Posted by reece(:

And a lot isn't dependent on strategy but on twists/swaps too.

Yep which is why Cirie lost Micronesia </3

[Macie Lightfoot]

Rupert and Cirie are deities SHAME ON YOU LINDSIE

[Dominic]

Cirie is the best Survivor contestant of all time. By far one of the best gameplayers too. Winning/losing doesn't define someone's game. Just because someone lost doesn't mean they suck and just because someone wins doesn't mean they're an amazing player.