[Mystic Mock]

Well first off what a fantastic season, mostly great contestants, a strong twist, brilliant tasks, and a strong winner, and some bonkers strategy going on.

There was only two contestants that I didn't like in the season because I felt that one was a sycophant, and the other just really rubbed me up the wrong way.

Anyway if you see your favourite low on my rankings it's not that I hated them or even disliked them, it's more to do with the fact that there's so many great contestants to choose from imo.

Anyway my rankings.

1. Andrew
2. Jon
3. Rupert
4. Christa
5. Sandra
6. Shawn
7. Burton
8. Osten
9. Tijuana
10. Nicole
11. Trish
12. Ryan S
13. Darrah
14. Michelle
15. Ryan O
16. Lillian

I absolutely love the season and I've got to thank Macie Lightfoot for mentioning it on one of the threads otherwise I wouldn't have probably checked it out for ages.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I'm glad I played an influence in this but NOT if Andrew is really #1 and Lill is really #16

[Mystic Mock]

Andrew was great, Lillian had this really annoying entitled attitude and I don't like the fact that such a bore helped take out nearly all of the best contestants in the season imo.

[Macie Lightfoot]

ummm Andrew was wayyyyyyyyyyy more entitled than anyone else on his season and than most people in Survivor history. He's smug, cocky, and he hasn't grown up since high school. His entire MO was to round up all the people who appeared athletic and pretty and then run smear campaigns against the people who didn't fit his idea of high school cool. If you want Skinny Ryan and Lill out, just own it. Don't try to make it out that they're worse in challenges than ****ing Osten and say that you need to get them out for the greater good of the tribe. No, you want to get them out because they're not as cool as you or Ryno or Osten and they're not as pretty as Darrah and Tijuana. Even 12 years later he's still entirely up his own ass about how he was robbed and the game was his to lose and how he led Morgan to one of the greatest comebacks EVER and it's such laughable fan fiction but since he's buds with Probst it's somehow become Survivor canon? ****ing gag me.

Compare that to Lill and I don't have a clue how one can consider her entitled. She's just a fickle menopausal basketcase who spent 39 days weeping along the beach in a scout uniform <3 She's completely absurd and ridiculous and is right up there with Sandra and Rupert in providing laughs the whole way through, and Pearl Islands is pretty much a fantastic season because of Lill and her gameplay? Every round was chaotic and flipped all because Lill just voted with whichever argument sounded more enticing to her in the moment. Just look at the end game, she had the balls to take part in a Burton coup at F5, she freaked out at Darrah and took her out at F4 all bc Darrah made some throwaway comment about how Lill's a threat and Jon fueled the fire, AND THEN she completely clowned the **** out of Jon at F3 just for fun. Lill's the centerpiece for the chaos and madness in the season's post-merge.

[Black Dagger]

Lill is flawless

[Mokka]

Probably one of my fav... If not my actual favourite season

Rupert >>>>>>>>... Forever.

[LemonJam]

amazing season and a cast ranking is so hard to do cos so many people deliver.

1. Rupert
2. Sandra
3. Lill
4. Shawn
5. Jon
6. Burton
7. Ryno
8. Christa
9. Trish
10. Tijuana
11. Osten
12. Darrah
13. Michelle
14. Ryan S
15. Nicole
16. Andrew

[Mystic Mock]

I honestly think that the season would've coped perfectly fine without Lillian's annoyances as there was so many big characters in there like Andrew and Jon as villain types, Burton and Shawn as trainwrecks, and most of the others was kind of funny.

[Braden]

But Lill is so amazing

[Dominic]

By far the best Survivor season imo.