[Mystic Mock]

Oh and I'm not on my own as have a look here.

http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showt...php?p=80529899

MysteriousOz - I saw it and noticed she only "sings" about 50% of the song and the backing track was still very loud

The girl can dance though

And here's another one.

ArtyAttack - Great performance but most of it was clearly mimed. I did enjoy watching it though

ageappropriate - The only part I found entertaining was working out which bits were mimed and which were sung live. Very poor from both of them

Only on TIBB where "sassy" and "fierce" females be allowed to mime and only a handful notice it.

I bet however if Ben or Leona had've mimed, or even worse Coldplay or Adele there would've been hell breaking loose on here.

How certain people get away with anything eh?

[Marsh.]

No, I don't even like Fleur's stuff. If I noticed ANYONE mime I'd say so.

A link to DS doesn't prove anything. I asked for a clip.

Edit - Oh, hold up the comment you quote is referring to Fleur's performance on the One Show in November. What exactly does that have to do with what we were discussing?

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

You're saying Fleur was miming because her vocal was flaw-free?

Despite us hearing her breathing with all the jumping about and other obviously live ad libs?

Can you pinpoint the time in the video where we hear her voice when she's not actually singing into the mic?

I'll watch it on the Youtube video in the minute to try and pinpoint it.

And it's a good thing that Fleur was breathing, we don't want another Louisa onstage now do we?

But yes I did not here anything live about Fleur except for maybe the chorus of Sax.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

No, I don't even like Fleur's stuff. If I noticed ANYONE mime I'd say so.

A link to DS doesn't prove anything. I asked for a clip.

Edit - Oh, hold up the comment you quote is referring to Fleur's performance on the One Show in November. What exactly does that have to do with what we were discussing?

I did that link and some posts from their duet, I did a mix of both.

So you're saying that people are wrong when they say that she mimed on two different shows? That's a bit hard to believe don't you think? Especially when some of them are half complimenting her so aren't "haters" of Fleur.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

I did that link and some posts from their duet, I did a mix of both.

So you're saying that people are wrong when they say that she mimed on two different shows? That's a bit hard to believe don't you think? Especially when some of them are half complimenting her so aren't "haters" of Fleur.

I asked for an example of her miming during her duet, not a collection of other people's opinions from DS.

Whether she mimed or not three weeks ago on the One Show has no bearing on the performance from two days ago that we're discussing.

It's like me discussing the merits of Leona's vocals on Saturday by posting videos of her performing in the US three months ago. It's irrelevant.

[Mystic Mock]

Here you go, it starts at about 3:39 and then she starts putting the Mic back to her face at about 3:42.

Youtube video

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

Here you go, it starts at about 3:39 and then she starts putting the Mic back to her face at about 3:42.

Youtube video

yes that's not miming, she shouted woo and then she sang which was clearly live

[Jordan.]

The only part that is mimed is the chorus to Black Magic. Fleur sang all of her bits live

[Marsh.]

She sang "woo" into the mic. She obviously wasn't even pretending she was miming to the backing track. She sings along with it like every pop star does with every song.

Did you not wonder why she starts to sing loud notes along to the backing track for the following 30 seconds after the bit you mentioned Mock? You know, rather than the words being sung as backing?

[Mystic Mock]

That's fair enough, I just think it looks dodgy.

[Marsh.]

Doing an ad lib of "wow, wow, woooooooowwww" over backing vocals of...

I need a stay up brother with a James brown soul
The type of red hot love that got me freezin' cold

is not miming.

That would be if she was mouthing those words and pretending the backing vocals were her own.

[RichardG]

Yeah she's definitely singing live in that video