[Tony Montana]

1. Man of Steel
2. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
3. Suicide Squad
4. Wonder Woman
5. Justice League

For me:

MOS > WW > BVS > JL > SS

I Expect Aquaman to clinch the top spot

[Scoot]

1. Wonder Woman
2. Batman v Superman
3. Man of Steel
4. Justice League
5. Suicide Squad

For some reason I loved Suicide Squad when it came out and saw it like 3 times in the cinema

BVS and MOS are pretty much even for me, and I haven’t rewatched JL since it came out to say for sure.

[Toy Soldier]

Originally Posted by Scoot

1. Wonder Woman
2. Batman v Superman
3. Man of Steel
4. Justice League
5. Suicide Squad

For some reason I loved Suicide Squad when it came out and saw it like 3 times in the cinema

BVS and MOS are pretty much even for me, and I haven’t rewatched JL since it came out to say for sure.

Yeah exact same order for me.

I feel like JL would probably have been higher if it had a half decent run time and hadn't been butchered and left on the cutting room floor after "reshoots". It had some development problems and you can just tell. Feels like two different movies stapled together.

Although they heavily changed the direction and tone of Suicide Squad too so that probably contributes to it being bottom. And it was all done in response to backlash against BvS which (despite one or two huge missteps and narrative issues) I really enjoyed...

[Scoot]

Yeah, I really wish they hadn’t interfered so much with SS and JL. Like, I’d rather they be crap and not have all this behind the scenes controversy surrounding them.

I really like BVS as well, but I completely get every issue people have with it. The fact that the extended version at 3 hours still needs you to make huge leaps to make sense of it all is very telling.

[Niamh.]

1. Wonder Woman
2. Suicide Squad
3. Justice League
4. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice

Didn't watch Man of Steel so left that one out

[Scoot]

Just to add as well Man of Steel would probably be number one if the third act wasn’t so bloated.