[Matthew.]

Originally Posted by Matthew.

Pre-Series Ranking
1. Tommy
2. Cliff
3. Christie
4. Kemi
5. Isabella
6. Jessica
7. Jack
8. Analyse
9. David
10. Ovi
11. Jackson
12. Kathryn
13. Nick
14. Sam
15. Holly
16. Nicole

Launch
1. Tommy (-)
2. Jack (+5)
3. Cliff (-1)
4. Kemi (-)
5. Sam (+9)
6. Jessica (-)
7. Christie (-4)
8. Kathryn (+4)
9. Isabella (-4)
10. Ovi (-)
11. Analyse (-3)
12. Nick (+1)
13. Jackson (-2)
14. David (-5)
15. Holly (-)
16. Nicole (-)

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Premiere:

1. Holly
2. Sam
3. Nick
4. Kemi
5. Jack
6. Cliff (didn't like him too much, just for perspective on the list )
7. Jackson I guess
8. Kathryn I guess (definitely feels better than I expected at the least)
9. Analyse
10. Ovi
11. David
12. Christie
13. Tommy
14. Nicole (eh maybe a bit of potential though just a really cringey/extra start)
15. Jessica
16. Isabella

While a majority aren't very good on first impressions, they also aren't too bad either... just a lot of ok or unknown which felt like a lot more than usual. Mostly going by pre-season opinions as I didn't get much from a lot of them on that premiere. Won't even color-code them in tiers... they're kind of all a blue-orange blend atm and Isabella is annoying.

Ep 2 & 3 + feeds

1. Kathryn
2. Sam
3. Holly
4. Cliff
5. Jackson
6. Nick
7. Kemi
8. Ovi (was maybe more of an orange-tier / a few spots lower until the messiness of ep 3 lol)
9. Analyse
10. Tommy
11. David
12. Jack
13. Christie
14. Isabella
15. Nicole
16. Jessica

Better impression on the cast now but still not LOVING too many people. At the same time, I don't hate anyone (even more-so than I felt during the premiere). Anyone below David I've had a slight disliking towards though.

[caprimint]

1) Kathryn Dunn
2) Sam Smith
3) Jackson Michie
4) Nicole Anthony
5) Analyse Talvera
6) Ovi Kabir
7) Cliff Hogg
8) Nick Maccarone
9) Holly Allen
10) Isabella Wang
11) Kemi Faknule
12) Jack Matthews
13) Tommy Braco
14) Jessica Milagros
15) Christie Murphy

[brat.]

Originally Posted by brat.

1: Isabella
2: Kemi
3: Nick
4: Analyse
5: Tommy
6: Jackson
7: Christie
8: Cliff
9: Sam
10: David
11: Kathryn
12: Jessica
13: Holly
14: Ovi
15: Jack
16: Nicole

none are red... yet

1: Isabella (-)
2: Kemi
3: Kathryn (+8)
4: David (+6)
5: Nick (-2)
6: Analyse (-2)
8: Ovi (+6)
9: Sam (-)
10: Nicole (+6)
11: Tommy (-6)
12: Cliff (-4)
13: Holly (-)
14: Jackson (-8)
15: Jack (-)
16: Christie (-9)

welp it didn't take long for someone to be racist

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

episode 2

1. Cliff
2. Jack
3. Analyse
4. Jessica
5. Kemi
6. Sam (+3)
7. Christie (-1)
8. Nick
9. Tommy (-2)
10. Holly
11. Nicole
12. Ovi
13. Kathryn
14. David
15. Jackson
16. Isabella

episode 3

1. Jack (+1)
2. Sam (+4)
3. Analyse
4. Cliff (-3)
5. Kemi
6. Jessica (-2)
7. Christie
8. Nick
9. Kathryn (+4)
10. Holly
11. Ovi (+1)
12. Tommy (-3)
13. Nicole (-1)
14. Isabella (+2)
15. Jackson
------
16. David (-2)

[Jigs]

After episode 3

1. Christie
2. Nick
3. Kathryn
4. Kemi
-
5. Cliff
6. Isabella
7. Holly
8. Jessica
9. Nicole
10. Tommy
11. Ovi
12. Sam
-
13. Analyse
14. Jackson
15. Jack

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Ep 2 & 3 + feeds

1. Kathryn
2. Sam
3. Holly
4. Cliff
5. Jackson
6. Nick
7. Kemi
8. Ovi (was maybe more of an orange-tier / a few spots lower until the messiness of ep 3 lol)
9. Analyse
10. Tommy
11. David
12. Jack
13. Christie
14. Isabella
15. Nicole
16. Jessica

Better impression on the cast now but still not LOVING too many people. At the same time, I don't hate anyone (even more-so than I felt during the premiere). Anyone below David I've had a slight disliking towards though.

1. Kathryn (by far #1 tbh, if not for Sam it'd be even more by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar lol)
2. Sam
3. Jackson (debatable with Holly but I've seen way more of him, overall a pretty "weak" #3 honestly but I'm not loving this cast all that much)
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Nick
7. Ovi
8. Kemi
9. Isabella
10. Analyse
11. Tommy
12. David
13. Christie
14. Jack (bad attitude, kinda gross... I'd say he could rank #15-16 at times or in orange around #12-13 at times, depends on the moment)
15. Nicole (strangely annoying which can get a bit grating at times lol)
16. Jessica (she's inoffensive but consistently annoying to watch)

[caprimint]

1) Kathryn Dunn
2) Sam Smith
3) Jackson Michie
4) Holly Allen
5) Nicole Anthony
6) Christie Murphy
7) Isabella Wang
8) Jack Matthews
9) Nick Maccarone
10) Cliff Hogg
11) Analyse Talvera
12) Ovi Kabir
13) Tommy Braco
14) Jessica Milagros
15) Kemi Faknule

[Matthew.]

Originally Posted by Matthew.

Launch
1. Tommy (-)
2. Jack (+5)
3. Cliff (-1)
4. Kemi (-)
5. Sam (+9)
6. Jessica (-)
7. Christie (-4)
8. Kathryn (+4)
9. Isabella (-4)
10. Ovi (-)
11. Analyse (-3)
12. Nick (+1)
13. Jackson (-2)
14. David (-5)
15. Holly (-)
16. Nicole (-)

Week 1 - David and Ovi evicted
1. Kathryn (+7)
2. Cliff (+1)
3. Tommy (-2)
4. Christie (+3)
5. Kemi (-1)
6. Jessica (-)
7. Ovi (+3)
8. Nicole (+8)
9. Isabella (-)
10. Analyse (+1)
11. David (+3)
12. Sam (-7)
13. Holly (+2)
14. Jackson (-1)
15. Nick (-3)
16. Jack (-14) (!!!)

[Wojtek]

Launch:

Originally Posted by Wojtek

1. Isabella
2. Kemi
3. Jessica
4. Analyse
5. Tommy
6. Christie
7. Nicole
8. Ovi
9. Cliff
10. Holly
11. Kathryn
12. Jack
13. David
14. Nick
15. Sam
16. Jackson

Week 1:

1. Kathryn (+10)
2. Isabella (-1)
3. Ovi (+5)
4. Kemi (-2)
5. Christie (+1)
6. Tommy (-1)
7. Jessica (-4)
8. Analyse (-4)
9. Nicole (-2)
10. Cliff (-1)
11. Holly (-1)
12. David (+1)
13. Sam (+2)
14. Nick (-)
15. Jackson (+1)
16. Jack (-4)

Can't believe I had Kathryn at #11 just a few days ago

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by Matthew.

16. Jack (-14) (!!!)

[caprimint]

1) Kathryn Dunn
2) Sam Smith
3) Christie Murphy
4) Nicole Anthony
5) Isabella Wang
6) Jack Matthews
7) Ovi Kabir
8) Kemi Faknule
9) Cliff Hogg
10) Nick Maccarone
11) Analyse Talvera
12) Tommy Braco
13) David Alexander
14) Holly Allen
15) Jackson Michie
16) Jessica Milagros

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Kathryn (by far #1 tbh, if not for Sam it'd be even more by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar lol)
2. Sam
3. Jackson (debatable with Holly but I've seen way more of him, overall a pretty "weak" #3 honestly but I'm not loving this cast all that much)
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Nick
7. Ovi
8. Kemi
9. Isabella
10. Analyse
11. Tommy
12. David
13. Christie
14. Jack (bad attitude, kinda gross... I'd say he could rank #15-16 at times or in orange around #12-13 at times, depends on the moment)
15. Nicole (strangely annoying which can get a bit grating at times lol)
16. Jessica (she's inoffensive but consistently annoying to watch)

1. Kathryn
2. Sam
3. Jackson (getting closer to Sam, had to actually think about who I preferred for a little bit)
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Nick
7. Kemi
8. Analyse
9. Ovi
10. Isabella (maybe #8/9 though)
11. David (he's just reeeally boring and not that appealing to me in general but solid guy so he's tough to rank)
12. Tommy
13. Christie (I don't actually mind her despite being consistently this low, I just don't mind the people above her either and she can get too much )
14. Nicole
15. Jessica
16. Jack (I don't particularly hate him at all despite the nasty attitude but there's just not that much redeeming about him either and while I can find Nicole or Jessica more annoying at times I think they've been less so this week)

Might start ranking Christie higher because I find her funnier / more entertaining than some of these others and I do value that more than the downside of simply having some moments of becoming annoying

[caprimint]

1) Kathryn Dunn
2) Sam Smith
3) Nicole Anthony
4) Christie Murphy
5) Jack Matthews
6) Kemi Faknule
7) Isabella Wang
8) Jackson Michie
9) Cliff Hogg
10) Ovi Kabir
11) Analyse Talvera
12) Nick Maccarone
13) Holly Allen
14) David Alexander
15) Tommy Braco
16) Jessica Milagros

[Matthew.]

Originally Posted by Matthew.

Week 1 - David and Ovi evicted
1. Kathryn (+7)
2. Cliff (+1)
3. Tommy (-2)
4. Christie (+3)
5. Kemi (-1)
6. Jessica (-)
7. Ovi (+3)
8. Nicole (+8)
9. Isabella (-)
10. Analyse (+1)
11. David (+3)
12. Sam (-7)
13. Holly (+2)
14. Jackson (-1)
15. Nick (-3)
16. Jack (-14) (!!!)

Week 2 - Kemi evicted
1. Kathryn (-)
2. Cliff (-)
3. Kemi (+2)
4. Christie (-)
5. Tommy (-2)
6. Jessica (-)
7. Ovi (-)
8. Nicole (-)
9. Sam (+3)
10. David (+1)
11. Michie (+3)
12. Analyse (-2)
13. Holly (-)
14. Nick (+1)
15. Isabella (-6)
16. Jack (-)

[Wojtek]

Originally Posted by Wojtek

Week 1:

1. Kathryn (+10)
2. Isabella (-1)
3. Ovi (+5)
4. Kemi (-2)
5. Christie (+1)
6. Tommy (-1)
7. Jessica (-4)
8. Analyse (-4)
9. Nicole (-2)
10. Cliff (-1)
11. Holly (-1)
12. David (+1)
13. Sam (+2)
14. Nick (-)
15. Jackson (+1)
16. Jack (-4)

Week 2:

1. Kathryn
2. Isabella
3. Ovi
4. Kemi
5. Jessica (+2)
6. Nicole (+3)
7. Christie (-2)
8. Tommy (-2)
9. Analyse (-1)
10. David (+2)
11. Cliff (-1)
12. Holly (-1)
13. Nick (+1)
14. Sam (-1)
15. Jackson
16. Jack

[caprimint]

1) Kathryn Dunn
2) Sam Smith
3) Kemi Faknule
4) Christie Murphy
5) Nicole Anthony
6) Isabella Wang
7) Jack Matthews
8) Jackson Michie
9) Ovi Kabir
10) Cliff Hogg
11) Analyse Talvera
12) Nick Maccarone
13) Holly Allen
14) David Alexander
15) Tommy Braco
16) Jessica Milagros

[Paige22]

1. Kathryn
2. Kemi
3. Nicole
4. Jessica
5. David
6. Christie
7. Ovi
8. Sam
9. Cliff
10. Holly
11. Tommy
12. Analyse
13. Jackson
14. Nick
15. Isabella
16. Jack

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Kathryn
2. Sam
3. Jackson (getting closer to Sam, had to actually think about who I preferred for a little bit)
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Nick
7. Kemi
8. Analyse
9. Ovi
10. Isabella (maybe #8/9 though)
11. David (he's just reeeally boring and not that appealing to me in general but solid guy so he's tough to rank)
12. Tommy
13. Christie (I don't actually mind her despite being consistently this low, I just don't mind the people above her either and she can get too much )
14. Nicole
15. Jessica
16. Jack (I don't particularly hate him at all despite the nasty attitude but there's just not that much redeeming about him either and while I can find Nicole or Jessica more annoying at times I think they've been less so this week)

Might start ranking Christie higher because I find her funnier / more entertaining than some of these others and I do value that more than the downside of simply having some moments of becoming annoying

1. Kathryn (I'm thinking top 10 Jen Johnson type status atm )
2. Sam
3. Jackson
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Kemi
7. Analyse
8. Nick
9. Isabella
10. Ovi
11. David
12. Tommy
13. Christie
14. Nicole
15. Jessica
16. Jack

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Kathryn (I'm thinking top 10 Jen Johnson type status atm )
2. Sam
3. Jackson
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Kemi
7. Analyse
8. Nick
9. Isabella
10. Ovi
11. David
12. Tommy
13. Christie
14. Nicole
15. Jessica
16. Jack

1. Kathryn (I'm thinking top 10 Jen Johnson type status atm )
2. Sam
3. Jackson
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Kemi
7. Ovi
8. Analyse
9. David
10. Isabella
11. Christie
12. Tommy
13. Nicole
14. Nick
15. Jessica
16. Jack

Something like that. The orange are toughest to rank this season because I see some positives and negatives and don't feel super crazy about any of them.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Coming away from that episode with Nicole in your bottom four CHRIST WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU x

[JerseyWins]

She moved up one

Wasn't that special tho

[Paige22]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Kathryn (I'm thinking top 10 Jen Johnson type status atm )
2. Sam
3. Jackson
4. Holly
5. Cliff
6. Kemi
7. Ovi
8. Analyse
9. David
10. Isabella
11. Christie
12. Tommy
13. Nicole
14. Nick
15. Jessica
16. Jack

Something like that. The orange are toughest to rank this season because I see some positives and negatives and don't feel super crazy about any of them.

I’m sorry but HOW can you have Nicole that low and have ANY of Gr8ful above her, especially Bella. I would think as A DECENT HUMAN you could see how horrible the treatment of Nicole (& others) is...

[Paige22]

Pre Camp Comeback Comp

1. Kathryn
2. Nicole
3. Kemi
4. Jessica
5. David
6. Ovi
7. Christie
8. Sam
9. Cliff
10. Holly
11. Analyse
12. Tommy
13. Jackson
14. Jack
15. Bella
16. Nick

Nicole stays and Kemi wins comeback

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by Paige22

I’m sorry but HOW can you have Nicole that low and have ANY of Gr8ful above her, especially Bella. I would think as A DECENT HUMAN you could see how horrible the treatment of Nicole (& others) is...

Was the TV edit tonight the worst of it of Gr8ful vs. Nicole? Yeah they were assholes and Bella spoke to her pretty awfully (and I felt a bit bad for Nicole) but at the same time it really wasn't that bad at all and almost felt exaggerated for the story? Nicole specifically was just ok, not that entertaining of a character for me, nothing to get excited over. I find Bella's stank attitude mixed with her really messy/aggressive gameplay to be kinda funny/entertaining so I'm not totally off Bella. At the same time she can be a bit annoying and too much for sure so I wouldn't say I'm pro-Bella either.

Overall, even though I'm not a fan it was probably one of Nicole's best episodes though as I've found her annoying in plenty other ones