[LeatherTrumpet]

Shoehorned in as part of the big woke lets put lots of women in to talk about
mens football movement, now she is leaving, a very popular decision. But who
will get the gig?

[Zizu]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Shoehorned in as part of the big woke lets put lots of women in to talk about
mens football movement, now she is leaving, a very popular decision. But who
will get the gig?

Very popular with whom ?

She’s actually very good in the mornings - obviously loves football ( and Arsenal)
.. great sense of humour and works well with the ever fabulous Ally McCoist.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[bitontheslide]

don't know why it's in any way wrong for a woman to commentate on a mans sport. When i listen to the male commentators on the big media outlets i am continually squirming

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

don't know why it's in any way wrong for a woman to commentate on a mans sport. When i listen to the male commentators on the big media outlets i am continually squirming

I know, it's weird people have an issue with it.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

don't know why it's in any way wrong for a woman to commentate on a mans sport. When i listen to the male commentators on the big media outlets i am continually squirming

nothing wrong with there on merit

in this instance, like many, that is not the case

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

nothing wrong with there on merit

in this instance, like many, that is not the case

Don't agree at all. She's very knowledgeable about the game, I've seen her slap down a few blokes too. She can handle herself against idiots. Wasn't she sports presenter of the year twice? No one can questions her qualifications or her knowledge.

[Swan]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

don't know why it's in any way wrong for a woman to commentate on a mans sport. When i listen to the male commentators on the big media outlets i am continually squirming

How Lee Dixon and Steve McManaman have jobs is beyond me. They're not just annoyingly bad, they're also wrong on a regular basis. Can't remember the game, but McManaman was saying "on the keeper had no chance with that shot" yet the keep had actually tipped it over the bar

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Swan

How Lee Dixon and Steve McManaman have jobs is beyond me. They're not just annoyingly bad, they're also wrong on a regular basis. Can't remember the game, but McManaman was saying "on the keeper had no chance with that shot" yet the keep had actually tipped it over the bar

Agree. Dixon is OK but I dont want to hear any criticism of female presenters unless we also discuss Michael Owen, Robbie Savage, Gabby Agbonlahor etc I remember David Bentley trying to become a pundit; he could barely string a sentence together.

There is far too much criticism of female pundits and presenters and IMO not enough criticism of the men. Some male pundits are truly terrible

[Swan]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Agree. Dixon is OK but I dont want to hear any criticism of female presenters unless we also discuss Michael Owen, Robbie Savage, Gabby Agbonlahor etc I remember David Bentley trying to become a pundit; he could barely string a sentence together.

There is far too much criticism of female pundits and presenters and IMO not enough criticism of the men. Some male pundits are truly terrible

Rebecca Lowe is a really decent presenter on NBC for the PL. Kate Abdo is great on the Paramount CL coverage too (and she's ridiculously good looking, just saying ) Thierry Henry is clearly smitten with her, and nobody could blame him.

Im not really a fan of Alex Scott if im honest, i just don't rate her as a presenter.

But yeah, there are so many terrible male pundits. I almost forgot how awful Owen was too.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

don't know why it's in any way wrong for a woman to commentate on a mans sport. When i listen to the male commentators on the big media outlets i am continually squirming

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Agree. Dixon is OK but I dont want to hear any criticism of female presenters unless we also discuss Michael Owen, Robbie Savage, Gabby Agbonlahor etc I remember David Bentley trying to become a pundit; he could barely string a sentence together.

There is far too much criticism of female pundits and presenters and IMO not enough criticism of the men. Some male pundits are truly terrible

Its a bogus argument

Like saying no point having a go at Boris when you are not criticizing Hitler or Ted Heath

You can criticise awful women pundits who have got jobs (and djs like Zoe Ball) who have been put into positions because they are women/attractive and not because they are any good

and you can criticize male ones like John Hartson or Andy Walker

but you dont need to do both always together or make mention of them.

And to say the male ones dont get pelters too is inaccurate as they do, all the time

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Its a bogus argument

Like saying no point having a go at Boris when you are not criticizing Hitler or Ted Heath

You can criticise awful women pundits who have got jobs (and djs like Zoe Ball) who have been put into positions because they are women/attractive and not because they are any good

and you can criticize male ones like John Hartson or Andy Walker

but you dont need to do both always together or make mention of them.

And to say the male ones dont get pelters too is inaccurate as they do, all the time

Your first post mentions women shoehorned. I'd argue some players are shoehorned too but you dont want talk about it. i So are you, or are you not talking specifically about female presenters. Where's the Michael Owen is terrible thread.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Your first post mentions women shoehorned. I'd argue some players are shoehorned too but you dont want talk about it. i So are you, or are you not talking specifically about female presenters. Where's the Michael Owen is terrible thread.

i dont mind Michael Owen as it goes

"I'd argue some players are shoehorned too" - who?

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

i dont mind Michael Owen as it goes

"I'd argue some players are shoehorned too" - who?

The ones mentioned. No way should Robbie Savage be on TV

[GiRTh]

Bullard too but he's quite funny

[bitontheslide]

When Michael Owen was saying that liverpool were the best team in europe last season 2 mins after he had just watched them being beaten

[GiRTh]

In fact, I think more managers should become pundit. Wenger Martin O'Neil, Martinez are always good. Fewer player pundits, more manager pundits.

[Swan]

I found Emma Hayes pretty decent as a pundit.

Was it McManaman saying "oh i knew it would be 2 english teams in the CL final" a couple years back just before Real Madrid cancelled him?

[Swan]

Mark Lawrenson was bloody awful a while back too.

[bitontheslide]

don't even get me started on Ian Wright

[Swan]

He's not a great pundit, but i do like him in general.

[MTVN]

Originally Posted by Zizu

Very popular with whom ?

She’s actually very good in the mornings - obviously loves football ( and Arsenal)
.. great sense of humour and works well with the ever fabulous Ally McCoist.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Don't agree at all. She's very knowledgeable about the game, I've seen her slap down a few blokes too. She can handle herself against idiots. Wasn't she sports presenter of the year twice? No one can questions her qualifications or her knowledge.

Agreed, she's a very good broadcaster and genuinely passionate and knowledgeable about sport. It's not like she claims to be an expert on the game or anything but as a host she's very strong and like Zizu says she has great chemistry and banter with Ally McCoist

[MTVN]

Plus she's only leaving because she's obviously got something bigger coming up (probably a big role in TNT sports) so it's not like she's going to be fading away from sports broadcasting

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Plus she's only leaving because she's obviously got something bigger coming up (probably a big role in TNT sports) so it's not like she's going to be fading away from sports broadcasting

Indeed the clamor to have a female sports presenter at all cost is still very strong

[Mystic Mock]

Tbf to Laura Woods, all of them on Talksport talk out of their ass.

It's entertaining don't get me wrong, but the anti-woke brigade aren't going to see a massively different Talksport with her gone.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Don't agree at all. She's very knowledgeable about the game, I've seen her slap down a few blokes too. She can handle herself against idiots. Wasn't she sports presenter of the year twice? No one can questions her qualifications or her knowledge.

That's true tbf.

Especially when Talksport has the troll that is Simon Jordan on the platform.