[decdec456]

How unbelievable were the judges on Saturday , fair enough Dannii and Simon had to stay loyal to both of their acts but seriously the point of the X factor is to find an act who is
(a) strong vocally and (b) a potentially popular recording act

and did Cheryl and Louis adhere to this? Nope
Were drowned by Daniel's manipulative sob story and kicked out some young blood with potential to keep someone in just because they feel sorry for him

I'm sorry but I believe the only judge who would have sent daniel home would have been Simon in any scenario e.g. if Simon was the girls mentor i think between Scott & Daniel he would have sent Daniel home

The other three need a serious rain check on their decision making and producing talented people not letting people they have soft spots for go through in the competition while messing up the reputation altogether!!!!

Rant Over ....

[rayheartbliss]

loius voted scott off so that simon would loose one of his boys!

i agree ther

[Annie]

They based it on their performace in the sing off and that is all and at the end of it. Daniel was better in the sing off.

[Kornetto]

Originally posted by Annie
They based it on their performace in the sing off and that is all and at the end of it. Daniel was better in the sing off.

I agree with Annie

[Barbie]

Both needed to go... but i do believe personal feelings pushed the decision for louis.. Daniel i think was only kept in because of the sob story..

i dont agree with them backing their own acts either.. if one was awful their mentor should say they were awful.. its to find talent not a battle between people in the music industry

[rayheartbliss]

the sad story made hes performance seem more emotional....
scott did better me thinks