Rachel: Amy Winehouse: Rachel axe was 'disaster'

[setanta]

AMY Winehouse said no, no, no when Rachel Adedeji got the boot from X Factor last Sunday.


The Rehab singer's dad Mitch told online channel Liv how she thought it was a "disaster" to get rid of Dannii Minogue's act in favour of Lloyd Daniels.


He said: "Amy and I and the family were watching X Factor and when Rachel got knocked out - we thought it was a complete disaster.


"We were having a lovely dinner - I was having a chicken vindaloo and Amy was having a chicken korma and we almost choked - almost put us right off our food."

See, yet another famous singer who can see the talent Rachel possesses.

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage...-disaster.html

[Dr.Gonzo]

Doesn't she look like Gollum?

She does.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by Dr.Gonzo

Doesn't she look like Gollum?

She does.

When you can sing like her it doesn't really matter does it, although could you imagine her trying to win the X Factor? lol.

[30stone]

Originally Posted by Dr.Gonzo

Doesn't she look like Gollum?

She does.

Who Amy or Rachel cant really see it.
Either way, Another Artist see's potential, yet vast majority of the public know they wouldnt buy her records i guess.

Never connected with her any week she was there, though she put on 2 good performances vocally and i could still hear flaws, shes good but is becoming overated and boring now.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by 30stone

Who Amy or Rachel cant really see it.
Either way, Another Artist see's potential, yet vast majority of the public know they wouldnt buy her records i guess.

Never connected with her any week she was there, though she put on 2 good performances vocally and i could still hear flaws, shes good but is becoming overated and boring now.

Lol, you'll never accept that she's talented and in a different league to the other two girls. The public in general are easily manipulated into liking certain individuals on the show.... that's how it works.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Why on God's earth would that alcoholic drug addict train crash of a pop singer's opinion matter one iota?

oh

it does not

[30stone]

Originally Posted by setanta

Lol, you'll never accept that she's talented and in a different league to the other two girls. The public in general are easily manipulated into liking certain individuals on the show.... that's how it works.

"In a different league" - No i never would because shes not.

Stacy has been pushed on us more than rachel.


But Lucie has got virtually no coverage, none in comparison to rachel at all, Rachel has been pushed on us quite a bit more than lucie and less than stacy.

Yet she is still voted in.
For me lucie is the best singer on form.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Why on God's earth would that alcoholic drug addict train crash of a pop singer's opinion matter one iota?

oh

it does not

I suppose winning 5 Grammy's among numerous other awards validates her opinion somewhat.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by 30stone

"In a different league" - No i never would because shes not.

Stacy has been pushed on us more than rachel.


But Lucie has got virtually no coverage, none in comparison to rachel at all, Rachel has been pushed on us quite a bit more than lucie and less than stacy.

Yet she is still voted in.
For me lucie is the best singer on form.

Lucie has been given loadsa coverage, from auditions straight up to now. It's quite obvious that they favoured her heavily prior to the beginning of the live shows, but her dullness may be her undoing. Oh, and she's not in the same league as Rachel - nothing to her voice. Technically good but boring.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by setanta

I suppose winning 5 Grammy's among numerous other awards validates her opinion somewhat.

yes, awards ceremonies. the harbingers of merit and a yardstick for us all

[setanta]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

yes, awards ceremonies. the harbingers of merit and a yardstick for us all

Well, usually I'd agree but the Grammy's are a big deal, as well as the Ivor Novello awards she's won. You just have a problem with her, that's all - or maybe just with Rachel.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by setanta

Well, usually I'd agree but the Grammy's are a big deal, as well as the Ivor Novello awards she's won. You just have a problem with her, that's all - or maybe just with Rachel.

winehouse is a disgrace. she had a couple of good songs but then so do tons of folks. She is a junkie and an abomination.

Rachel is history.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

winehouse is a disgrace. she had a couple of good songs but then so do tons of folks. She is a junkie and an abomination.

Rachel is history.

She might be a disgrace in your eyes but she's an artist... singer and songwriter of huge talent.

And no, I don't think it's the last we'll hear of Rachel.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by setanta

She might be a disgrace in your eyes but she's an artist... singer and songwriter of huge talent.

And no, I don't think it's the last we'll hear of Rachel.

that is a double fail. get your things, put the light off and DONT bang the door on the way out.

[MissChelle]

Another talented singer that sees the talent that Rachel has then.

I hate to say it though, if the public didn't vote to keep her in the competition then she obviously has a problem with appealing to the masses (not me because I thought she was great!) but I doubt if she would have much success. An artist needs the whole package to be successful and if people just don't like her then it doesn't matter how great her voice is unfortunately.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

that is a double fail. get your things, put the light off and DONT bang the door on the way out.

Well judging from the wit involved in your last post I'd say you're well used to wandering around aimlessy in the dark. I turned the light off so hopefully you'll bang your head and it'll knock some sense into you.

[Stu]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Why on God's earth would that alcoholic drug addict train crash of a pop singer's opinion matter one iota?

Because you just made a post on her. Simple. Want me to take the bullet out of your foot?

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by ProbeEight

Because you just made a post on her. Simple. Want me to take the bullet out of your foot?

your logic would shame Mr Spock's dentist's cousin.

[Stu]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

your logic would shame Mr Spock's dentist's cousin.

As opposed to ''She is one of the most recognizable faces of the 21st century, spent a year on both the charts and the tabloids, but I don't like her, therefore her opinion should not matter''.

Flawless logic.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by ProbeEight

As opposed to ''She is one of the most recognizable faces of the 21st century, spent a year on both the charts and the tabloids, but I don't like her, therefore her opinion should not matter''.

Flawless logic.

I dont think anyone likes her. they may like some of her songs but the way she has consistently pissed her success, marriage and life up the wall for all to see is a unmitigated disaster and shame.

People recognise many people if they make the news good and bad. Can you give me the release date of her last single? or the date when she put in a good concert performance?

[Stu]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

I dont think anyone likes her. they may like some of her songs but the way she has consistently pissed her success, marriage and life up the wall for all to see is a unmitigated disaster and shame.

And what on earth has any of that got to do with her voicing an opinion on the bloody X-Factor?

Can you give me the release date of her last single? or the date when she put in a good concert performance?

Come again? What has that got to do with anything?

Actually, considering the circumstances, ''What has that got to do with anything?'' is my new stock response to all your posts.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by ProbeEight

And what on earth has any of that got to do with her voicing an opinion on the bloody X-Factor?


Come again? What has that got to do with anything?

Actually, considering the circumstances, ''What has that got to do with anything?'' is my new stock response to all your posts.

the answer to all your flailings is what i said originally.

[Stu]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

the answer to all your flailings is what i said originally.

So the answer to ''what on earth has me not knowing when her single is out got to do with anything?'' is that my logic is bad?

Irony and lolz in spades, you have, son. Could you please not bother getting into discussions with me unless you are prepared to actually answer questions?

You originally said her opinion did not matter. I pointed out to you the wrongness of this and how illogical is was that despite all her success her opinion does not matter. Your response to this was that MY logic was bad. Then your asking me for the release date of her single. And what good concerts she has performed.

You are, in essence, what we typically refer to as a 'nutter'.

[Jords]

Anybody would know Rachel>Llyod,
was wrong of Simon not to get rid of him.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by ProbeEight

So the answer to ''what on earth has me not knowing when her single is out got to do with anything?'' is that my logic is bad?

Irony and lolz in spades, you have, son. Could you please not bother getting into discussions with me unless you are prepared to actually answer questions?

You originally said her opinion did not matter. I pointed out to you the wrongness of this and how illogical is was that despite all her success her opinion does not matter. Your response to this was that MY logic was bad. Then your asking me for the release date of her single. And what good concerts she has performed.

You are, in essence, what we typically refer to as a 'nutter'.