Well (Spoiler)

[Roy Mars III]

Looks like BB3 has been matched for the worst jury decision ever.

a disgrace really

[Roy Mars III]

if anyone can tell me why Ian deserved to win over Dan, please do

[Marc]

I think Dan played a ruthless but very successful and intelligent game. It's just a shame Ian was sat beside him because he played a clever game too and didn't backstab as many people, he won a lot of times and without knowing he saved his ass on two occassions.

Ian won because he was the only person to evade Dan targetting him.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, Ian played it right, Dan played it the best.

[LemonJam]

and so it begins...

[Marc]

Dan needed to win that final HoH to win, if he had evicted Ian then he would have won.

What was he going to do if he won?... I didn't catch it properly.

[Roy Mars III]

Originally Posted by Marc

I think Dan played a ruthless but very successful and intelligent game. It's just a shame Ian was sat beside him because he played a clever game too and didn't backstab as many people, he won a lot of times and without knowing he saved his ass on two occassions.

Ian won because he was the only person to evade Dan targetting him.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, Ian played it right, Dan played it the best.

Ian's game was boring and bland and should not have been rewarded

[Marc]

I understand your disappointment.. I am too a fan of the ruthless player but this was no where near his BB10 performance which was more sneaky IMO.

[Roy Mars III]

Originally Posted by Marc

I understand your disappointment.. I am too a fan of the ruthless player but this was no where near his BB10 performance which was more sneaky IMO.

oh, yea, I agree with that. Besides the Funeral veto, Dan played much, much better in 10

[Marc]

It's a shame so many jurors get so pi**y about being played.

[LemonJam]

I'll just say that Ian considered that he was playing with human beings and was ruthless only when he really needed to be. Dan NEVER seemed to consider "hmm, this jury may be pissed off at me"

I don't agree that flashy moves = good moves. I kindof called that he'd lose once he hosted his own funeral (just saying ) because from that point on he was playing a Russell Hantz of a game.

When someone plays ruthlessly like that, they should realise that in past seasons it doesn't always work out once you're sat with the people you pissed off holding your fate (See Alison, Nicole, Danielle [although I don't technically think the bitter votes came from her gameplay, but she still pissed them off with her confessionals], Natalie)

I still say the BB3 jury is the worst because most of them were butthurt about Danielle in the DR rather than the way she played the game. Not saying that Dan didn't play an at least interesting game, just Ian played a lot better.

[starry]

I don't like the comparison to Russell Hantz. Russell won both final competitions in his main two seasons. He was a threat in the physical game as well as the mental. There was plenty of humour to him, the ego stuff was part of his whole act. Survivor is more ruthless than Big Brother. Ian deserved to win way more than someone like Natalie ever did And of course Sandra is famously crap at competitions. Russell did the hard work and went out and found those idols for himself to help his own destiny as well as building alliances that would take him to the end.

[LemonJam]

If you're trying to say Russell was a great player then lolnope but dear God let's not make it into another of those threads because there's already about 54854398 of them floating around.

I think the comparison's very obvious - both made flashy and sometimes unnecessary moves to get to the end without considering how the jury would feel about them afterwards.

[starry]

Again, Survivor is way more brutal. And I think Russell made necessary moves in that context and established some strong alliances.

[Roy Mars III]

Dr. Will would have made the same moves as Dan and won

[LemonJam]

I think Dr Will would've found someone to do the dirty work for him. (Nicole/Janelle)

[Roy Mars III]

Yea

[Marc]

Poor Russell..

[SoBig]

Dan was going to lose no matter how he played. Since the reset button was hit the house guest were saying that they would NEVER vote for a coach to win especially one that won before. Shane, Jenn and Joe said that constantly. I knew Dan was screwed from then if he didn't sit next to someone like Boogie if he wanted to win again. In the backyard interviews Jenn and Joe basically said that Dan played the best, but he won before and they wanted someone new to win.

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

just Ian played a lot better.

Ian did not know what was happening half of the time. He was completely clueless. Ian even believed that he created the Quack Pack an alliance that was created in week 3 before the reset.

[LemonJam]

considering Ian has $500,000 dollars and Dan has $50,000 that kindof speaks for itself

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

considering Ian has $500,000 dollars and Dan has $50,000 that kindof speaks for itself

No. Just look at what the past house guest on twitter are saying. They all agreed that Dan played the better game and is the better player. It could have been Danielle sitting next to Dan and he still would have lost. Dan's biggest fault was that he won the game before. They were never going to vote for him to win again. What the houseguests said on the live feeds and in the backyard interviews back that up.

[starry]

Still dislike Joe. This from an interview:

Let's talk about Willie for a moment because I'm curious. There have been a lot of people wondering on the feeds, did you actually get headbutted more than once or was it only once?

It was kind of what I call a rub, we were so close, I thought he was going to kiss me at first. I was like dude, you aren't really gonna kiss a man on the show, are ya? He was pushing back on my head, he was upset wasn't he. I mean he was definitely upset, they were little love taps, 2 or 3 but they weren't hard. He was so close to me, it was either going to be a kiss or a headbutt. I didn't know what I was going to get.

[Roy Mars III]

He would have beat Jenn and Frank

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by Roy Mars III

He would have beat Jenn and Frank

He wouldn't have beaten Frank. Ashley, Joe, Shane and Jenn would have voted for Frank.

He would have lost to Jenn too. Shane, Frank, Ashley and Joe would have voted for her.

Dan only would have won against Mike Boogie or possibly Joe. Too bad those were the people that were after him. He would have had a good shot against Janelle too.

[SoBig]

Jenn HATED Ian and loved Dan, but she still voted for Ian and Dan never backstabbed her. That should tell you all that you needed to know. Jenn even agreed that Dan played a better game.