Should they allow bands on X Factor?

[Arneldo]

Anyone else think they should allow bands on the The X Factor?

They've allowed so many crappy group through, and over-rated solo singer. But there are a lot of bands trying to get their big break but the only show that really has a place for them would be 'Britain's Got Talent', yet the only band we saw was some crappy female 3-piece band.

I think it would be brilliant to see a category for Bands, maybe in place of either the 'Boys' or Girls', and got back to have the mixed '16-24s'.

To see how the bands take on the weekly themes, and could add their own unique style to songs would be great.

[Shaun]

Let them in with the "groups". Playing your own instruments is something not to be sneered at I guess.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Shaun
Let them in with the "groups". Playing your own instruments is something not to be sneered at I guess.

Yeh, was thinking that as well. Instead of forming groups with solo rejects, let some bands audition.

[bronaaaa]

Yes, but I like the seperate boys and girls, like Shaun said, with the groups yeah

[Nicky.]

They should, definetely.

They allowed the scottish duet a few years ago to play the guitar, so just allow everyone to play instruments and it's happy days!

[Billy]

They probably do.
Most bands wouldnt though, for the whole credibility thing.

[andybigbro]

what do you mean by bands?

Like rockbands etc?