View Full Version : Editing gives false version of events
On tonights HL show the editing gave the false impression that Noirin did not want to talk to Siavash when in fact Siavash would not talk to her, Noirin and Isaac decided that she would try to talk to him in the morning, Slick editing was used to give the impression that they did not care if the talked to him or not.Also nervous Laughter at the Awkwardness of the situation was portrayed as them laughing at Siavash when it was nothing of the kind
Welcome to Big Brother, who goes? They decide and you pay.
Vicky.
30-07-2009, 10:40 PM
Editing also convieniently cut out her comments of only kissing siavash ONCE when she was drunk...
Bet you dont complain about that...
:whistle:
Libra
30-07-2009, 10:44 PM
Originally posted by jjj2
On tonights HL show the editing gave the false impression that Noirin did not want to talk to Siavash when in fact Siavash would not talk to her, Noirin and Isaac decided that she would try to talk to him in the morning, Slick editing was used to give the impression that they did not care if the talked to him or not.Also nervous Laughter at the Awkwardness of the situation was portrayed as them laughing at Siavash when it was nothing of the kind
That was exactly how I saw it on the highlights.
There was no false editing, it was clear enough.
kisywisy
30-07-2009, 10:44 PM
a lot of people on here don't watch LF and they all think noirin is even more of a bitch for not talking to siavash. if they'd watched it last night, they'd know that wasn't true.
fair enough if siavash didn't feel ready to talk to them, but he then kept saying noirin hadn't even given him an explanation. :shrug: how could she explain enything if he didn't want to be in the same room as her??
sukymac
30-07-2009, 10:45 PM
the hl show was very good to her after what i saw last night from 1am till 3am..she didnt go anywhere near siavash, isaac did and he was told politley he wasnt ready to talk but was cool with the situation..all noirin did was make excuses as to why she went with siavash ie i was drunk and didnt know what i was doing etc etc...that was not shown
setanta
30-07-2009, 10:46 PM
Originally posted by VickyJ
Editing also convieniently cut out her comments of only kissing siavash ONCE when she was drunk...
Bet you dont complain about that...
:whistle:
Well said Vicky. I think they omitted alot of comments that would have cast her in an even worse light.
Originally posted by VickyJ
Editing also convieniently cut out her comments of only kissing siavash ONCE when she was drunk...
Bet you dont complain about that...
:whistle: Iwatched it last night until they went to bed and heard her tell him everything.
danny123
30-07-2009, 10:46 PM
Yep, I think there's no point if you don't watch the live feed as you don't understand the full thing. But it can get repetitive if you watch both.
kisywisy
30-07-2009, 10:47 PM
Originally posted by Libra
Originally posted by jjj2
On tonights HL show the editing gave the false impression that Noirin did not want to talk to Siavash when in fact Siavash would not talk to her, Noirin and Isaac decided that she would try to talk to him in the morning, Slick editing was used to give the impression that they did not care if the talked to him or not.Also nervous Laughter at the Awkwardness of the situation was portrayed as them laughing at Siavash when it was nothing of the kind
That was exactly how I saw it on the highlights.
There was no false editing, it was clear enough.
???
jjj2's point was that the HL show didn't show how it happened last night. siavash didn't want to talk to either of them last night. he didn't even want to be in the same room
Baggymad
30-07-2009, 10:47 PM
Originally posted by jjj2
On tonights HL show the editing gave the false impression that Noirin did not want to talk to Siavash when in fact Siavash would not talk to her, Noirin and Isaac decided that she would try to talk to him in the morning, Slick editing was used to give the impression that they did not care if the talked to him or not.Also nervous Laughter at the Awkwardness of the situation was portrayed as them laughing at Siavash when it was nothing of the kind
Oh dear.......very easily fooled i think!!
Whichever way it is edited...........Noirin has acted appallingly!!
:dog:
Libra
30-07-2009, 10:47 PM
Originally posted by kisywisy
a lot of people on here don't watch LF and they all think noirin is even more of a bitch for not talking to siavash. if they'd watched it last night, they'd know that wasn't true.
fair enough if siavash didn't feel ready to talk to them, but he then kept saying noirin hadn't even given him an explanation. :shrug: how could she explain enything if he didn't want to be in the same room as her??
He actually said that she doesn't owe him an explanation.
That's a lot different.
Vicky.
30-07-2009, 10:47 PM
Originally posted by jjj2
Originally posted by VickyJ
Editing also convieniently cut out her comments of only kissing siavash ONCE when she was drunk...
Bet you dont complain about that...
:whistle: Iwatched it last night until they went to bed and heard her tell him everything.
This was posted on the official BB twitter site.
It was not during LF hours.
MissKittyFantastico
30-07-2009, 10:48 PM
Originally posted by setanta
Originally posted by VickyJ
Editing also convieniently cut out her comments of only kissing siavash ONCE when she was drunk...
Bet you dont complain about that...
:whistle:
Well said Vicky. I think they omitted alot of comments that would have cast her in an even worse light.
They sure did.
Vicky.
30-07-2009, 10:48 PM
Originally posted by kisywisy
???
jjj2's point was that the HL show didn't show how it happened last night. siavash didn't want to talk to either of them last night. he didn't even want to be in the same room
Probably didnt want to be made to look more of a dick on TV...
tramp-stamp
30-07-2009, 10:49 PM
Originally posted by VickyJ
Editing also convieniently cut out her comments of only kissing siavash ONCE when she was drunk...
Bet you dont complain about that...
:whistle:
agree :thumbs:
kisywisy
30-07-2009, 10:49 PM
Originally posted by danny123
Yep, I think there's no point if you don't watch the live feed as you don't understand the full thing. But it can get repetitive if you watch both.
this is what pisses me off. if we had the 24/7 LF we would know everything that was going on in the house. bb put in what they want you to see
boomoo
30-07-2009, 10:54 PM
She did not just kiss Siewash once. She kissed him several times and she was not drunk. She was kissing Siewash under the covers in the middle of the afternoon and she certainly was not drunk.
They do not get enough alcohol to be drunk.
She did want to speak to Siewash but she was advised by various housemates to give Siewash time to come to terms with it. But she should have just gone and spoken to him.
what could she have said that would have helped Siewash, he felt an idiot and that was his own fault.
He thought he was somehow in with a chance where Sree and Marcus had no chance.
Vicky.
30-07-2009, 10:56 PM
Originally posted by boomoo
She did not just kiss Siewash once. She kissed him several times and she was not drunk. She was kissing Siewash under the covers in the middle of the afternoon and she certainly was not drunk.
They do not get enough alcohol to be drunk.
She did want to speak to Siewash but she was advised by various housemates to give Siewash time to come to terms with it. But she should have just gone and spoken to him.
what could she have said that would have helped Siewash, he felt an idiot and that was his own fault.
He thought he was somehow in with a chance where Sree and Marcus had no chance.
Exactly,
yet she told isaac she had kissed him once only, and while she was drunk.
Noirin fans need to accept that she was actually given a favorable edit today, because if this comment had actually been shown, she would be even more hated.
tedmaul
30-07-2009, 10:56 PM
Originally posted by jjj2
On tonights HL show the editing gave the false impression that Noirin did not want to talk to Siavash when in fact Siavash would not talk to her, Noirin and Isaac decided that she would try to talk to him in the morning, Slick editing was used to give the impression that they did not care if the talked to him or not.Also nervous Laughter at the Awkwardness of the situation was portrayed as them laughing at Siavash when it was nothing of the kind
I must have watched a diffrrent HL show to you, Isaac tried to talk to Siavash but Siavash wasn't ready to talk to Isaac. Noirin wanted to talk to Siavash but Isaac wasn't sure she should.
In the HL show I watched there was not even a hint that Noirin and or Isaac were laughing at Siavash.
Lisa and David were laughing and loving every minute of Siavash's discomfort while they were in the diary room.
setanta
30-07-2009, 10:59 PM
Originally posted by VickyJ
Originally posted by boomoo
She did not just kiss Siewash once. She kissed him several times and she was not drunk. She was kissing Siewash under the covers in the middle of the afternoon and she certainly was not drunk.
They do not get enough alcohol to be drunk.
She did want to speak to Siewash but she was advised by various housemates to give Siewash time to come to terms with it. But she should have just gone and spoken to him.
what could she have said that would have helped Siewash, he felt an idiot and that was his own fault.
He thought he was somehow in with a chance where Sree and Marcus had no chance.
Exactly,
yet she told isaac she had kissed him once only, and while she was drunk.
Noirin fans need to accept that she was actually given a favorable edit today, because if this comment had actually been shown, she would be even more hated.
Exactly.... so much of their conversation was left out. So many gems spoken between them- two absolutely self absorbed gameplayers.
rayheartbliss
30-07-2009, 11:01 PM
she said what she said
shes done what shes done
its not like they manufactured all the things shes done and said!
remember they only have 45 minutes to show a whole days event!
You tube VTs of the show are exposing the important event of the show which dont make it into the HL show and should be
Originally posted by rayheartbliss
she said what she said
shes done what shes done
its not like they manufactured all the things shes done and said!
remember they only have 45 minutes to show a whole days event! you are very naive ,leaving out an important word or sentence can cast someone un fairly as a villian
Vicky.
31-07-2009, 04:52 AM
Originally posted by jjj2
you are very naive ,leaving out an important word or sentence can cast someone un fairly as a villian
Yes, they left out the most important sentance of the night.
'I only ever kissed siavash once, when i was drunk'
So in this instance, they have favoured her in what they showed :wink:
Shasown
31-07-2009, 04:56 AM
Originally posted by jjj2
you are very naive ,leaving out an important word or sentence can cast someone un fairly as a villian
Equally can make a villain seem almost angelic
you cant believe everything you read you have to have vt this year and all the VT not just the bits they want you to see i mean Live feed.
Vicky.
31-07-2009, 05:07 AM
Originally posted by jjj2
you cant believe everything you read you have to have vt this year and all the VT not just the bits they want you to see i mean Live feed.
I fail to see why the official BB twitter would say that she said something if she did not say it.
There is no reason at all for this.
Shasown
31-07-2009, 05:32 AM
During the LF she did mention that she had kissed him the once when drunk and gave him the odd cuddle.
Isaac said well things like that will happen in this sort of environment.
the interesting point to me about it was the fact his eyes said something totally different, they were saying its okay I know the truth and will pay you back.
http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=131578
http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=131774&page=2
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.