Siavash, Guilty or Not Guilty?

[preformat2000]

Considering what has been discussed in the following thread

http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=133164

is Siavash guilty of cheating or not guilty?

[lukebartram]

[i]

Nott Guiltyyyyy

[ange7]

Not Guilty!!! unless loving is a crime. :P

He rolled the dice and lost.

[Tom]

Guilty. His girlfriend has been on BBLB and that is conclusive enough and his friend confirmed it too. He's also a liar and a hypocrite. He can't keep a consistent story. One minute he's had a girlfriend for a few months, the next its only been a month, the next he doesn't have one and made her up to stop anything happening in the house. And he went and told Noirin "don't lie" :rolleyes:

[NettoSuperstar!]

Guilty but I'll forgive him, hes young and been foolish, at least hes shown remorse and will learn from it and has suffered for it

[nellysjade]

GUILTY wivout a doubt
at first didnt think so but now i know he has a girlfriend GUILTY:thumbs2:

[preformat2000]

Originally posted by Tom
Guilty. His girlfriend has been on BBLB and that is conclusive enough and his friend confirmed it too. He's also a liar and a hypocrite. He can't keep a consistent story. One minute he's had a girlfriend for a few months, the next its only been a month, the next he doesn't have one and made her up to stop anything happening in the house. And he went and told Noirin "don't lie" :rolleyes:

the girl that appeared on BBLB, was there as his friend not girlfriend. and if you mean the girl who has claimed (in sun newspaper) to be his girlfriend and one of his friends has confirmed that they know each other for less than a month, I don't think that is a very good proof either.

even if the girl who claims, is his GF, then how can you call someone that you know for only a month a GF. and on that basis Siavash actually has spent a longer time with Noirin than that girl.

I generally think people who want to label him as a cheater, have problem with his popularity not with what he has done.


oh and I will be grateful if you actually look at the link I posted then answer the question.

[Tom4784]

GUILTY.

He was much worse then Noirin although he won't get pulled up on it because he's a favourite (Hypocrites). Even worse is that he was blatently playing the sympathy card for ages after Isaac arrived. I did like him before this but now to me he's a gameplaying cheat and not a very good one either.

[nellysjade]

[quote]Originally posted by ange7
Not Guilty!!! unless loving is a crime. :P

He rolled the dice and lost. [/quote


loving is not a crime but he had a girlfriend :dance2:

[bettiepage]

I don't get how some poepl can say 'Not Guilty'?

You can still be fans and accept that the man is a tosser.

[JAJ1942]

Guilty due to the fact that he is a man with a mind of his own, he made his choice and should now accept responsibility for his part in the drama, it always takes two.

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by Rice_square
I don't get how some people can say 'Not Guilty'?

You can still be fans and accept that the man is a tosser.

Some fans are blind to their favourite's faults though, they'd support them even if the person in question was a rascist Nazi Serial Killer.

[bettiepage]

Oh, I pressed 'Not Guilty' :sad:

LOL.

[preformat2000]

Originally posted by Rice_square
I don't get how some poepl can say 'Not Guilty'?

You can still be fans and accept that the man is a tosser.

and your Karma rating shows that you have such geart judgment between right and wrong!!!

[ange7]

Originally posted by Dezzy
Originally posted by Rice_square
I don't get how some people can say 'Not Guilty'?

You can still be fans and accept that the man is a tosser.

Some fans are blind to their favourite's faults though, they'd support them even if the person in question was a rascist Nazi Serial Killer.
Nah not Siavash fans. We keep it real. He screwed up but he was always genuine and NEVER evil and vindictive. There's lots of hm that live on hate.... not siavash.
Your thinking of Noirin and Freddie supporters.

[ange7]

Originally posted by nellysjade
Originally posted by ange7
Not Guilty!!! unless loving is a crime. :P

He rolled the dice and lost.
loving is not a crime but he had a girlfriend :dance2:

does he?
and he laid it all on the line for Noirin because he was in love. He genuinely wanted to continue their romance after bb .... does that sound like he has a gf?

[Tom]

Originally posted by preformat2000
Originally posted by Tom
Guilty. His girlfriend has been on BBLB and that is conclusive enough and his friend confirmed it too. He's also a liar and a hypocrite. He can't keep a consistent story. One minute he's had a girlfriend for a few months, the next its only been a month, the next he doesn't have one and made her up to stop anything happening in the house. And he went and told Noirin "don't lie" :rolleyes:

the girl that appeared on BBLB, was there as his friend not girlfriend. and if you mean the girl who has claimed (in sun newspaper) to be his girlfriend and one of his friends has confirmed that they know each other for less than a month, I don't think that is a very good proof either.

even if the girl who claims, is his GF, then how can you call someone that you know for only a month a GF. and on that basis Siavash actually has spent a longer time with Noirin than that girl.

I generally think people who want to label him as a cheater, have problem with his popularity not with what he has done.


oh and I will be grateful if you actually look at the link I posted then answer the question.

I did look at the link but his girlfriend was on BBLB and his friend also said he had been with her for 7 months. George tried arguing and saying only a month but his friend wasn't having it. I don't think a friend would have 'Siavash's Girlfriend' on her name badge. And if you're going to throw accusations around about problems with his popularity, at least try and learn a bit about me. I've said time and time again Siavash is one of my top 3 housemates, and top male.

Siavash changes his story all the time about his girlfriend so I don't trust anything he says about her.

[Norf_London]

Guilty as charged!

[Norf_London]

Guilty as charged!

[shash]

Guilty of what? Falling for Noirin? I certainly think it was genuine on his part, but I can understand how a few weeks in the BB house would alter to an extent one's normal reactions and actions as it becomes their entire world. It is not normal, which does not make it right but perhaps a little more understandable.

[preformat2000]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by preformat2000
Originally posted by Tom
Guilty. His girlfriend has been on BBLB and that is conclusive enough and his friend confirmed it too. He's also a liar and a hypocrite. He can't keep a consistent story. One minute he's had a girlfriend for a few months, the next its only been a month, the next he doesn't have one and made her up to stop anything happening in the house. And he went and told Noirin "don't lie" :rolleyes:

the girl that appeared on BBLB, was there as his friend not girlfriend. and if you mean the girl who has claimed (in sun newspaper) to be his girlfriend and one of his friends has confirmed that they know each other for less than a month, I don't think that is a very good proof either.

even if the girl who claims, is his GF, then how can you call someone that you know for only a month a GF. and on that basis Siavash actually has spent a longer time with Noirin than that girl.

I generally think people who want to label him as a cheater, have problem with his popularity not with what he has done.


oh and I will be grateful if you actually look at the link I posted then answer the question.

I did look at the link but his girlfriend was on BBLB and his friend also said he had been with her for 7 months. George tried arguing and saying only a month but his friend wasn't having it. I don't think a friend would have 'Siavash's Girlfriend' on her name badge. And if you're going to throw accusations around about problems with his popularity, at least try and learn a bit about me. I've said time and time again Siavash is one of my top 3 housemates, and top male.

Siavash changes his story all the time about his girlfriend so I don't trust anything he says about her.

I think there is a bit of misunderstanding, cause on the badge was saying "Siavash's Friend" not siavash's girlfriend. there is also a picture of that TV appearance on one of the threads :

http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/topic-128775-is-this-siavash039s-girlfriend_siavash.htm

and it clearly is readable as "Siavash's Friend".

oh and another thing is my friend, do you think if he actually was in love with a girl would he lie about being in relationship with her?

[Norf_London]

Guilty as charged!

[CaraRawr]

Not guilty!

[Adamw92]

GUILTY

[MissKittyFantastico]

Still not sure tbh, as I said in my post in the other thread about this.