If you could change the Judging pannel... ?

[MR.K!]

Who would yours be?
---------------------------------------------------

Mine would be:

Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Shakira
Gary Barlow

[Nicky.]

Tom Fletcher
Danny Jones
Harry Judd
Dougie Poynter

:')

They would make it amusing!

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Nicky.
Tom Fletcher
Danny Jones
Harry Judd
Dougie Poynter

:')

They would make it amusing!

No.

[Marc]

Originally posted by MarkWaldorf
Originally posted by Nicky.
Tom Fletcher
Danny Jones
Harry Judd
Dougie Poynter

:')

They would make it amusing!

No.

LOL.

[Jayson]

Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Beyoncé
Leona Lewis

And a 5th judge to make the numbers better, as 4 doesn't work as well as an odd number.

[Harry!]

Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Amanda Holden/Dannii Minogue
Louie Walsh/Perce Morgan

[Jayson]

Originally posted by Harry.
Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Amanda Holden/Dannii Minogue
Louie Walsh/Perce Morgan Nah, it's a completely different show to BGT, doubt it would ever work.

[jkp44]

simon cowell
Dannii Minogue
Beyonce, Kelly Rowland or Janet Jackson
will young or lemar (as they have both been through the whole reality show thing and also they can sing and have been very succesful)

[Brad.]

I would just swap dannii for sharon.

[Jack_]

Ideally I'd have:

Cheryl Cole
Sharon Osbourne
Louis Walsh
Simon Cowell

But seeing as Sharon probably won't come back I'd get rid of Danni and swap her for someone like Will Young as he was really good when he mentored the acts.

[Brad.]

Originally posted by Jack_
Ideally I'd have:

Cheryl Cole
Sharon Osbourne
Louis Walsh
Simon Cowell

But seeing as Sharon probably won't come back I'd get rid of Danni and swap her for someone like Will Young as he was really good when he mentored the acts.

HAHA same as me ;)

[Jack_]

Originally posted by Bradley.
Originally posted by Jack_
Ideally I'd have:

Cheryl Cole
Sharon Osbourne
Louis Walsh
Simon Cowell

But seeing as Sharon probably won't come back I'd get rid of Danni and swap her for someone like Will Young as he was really good when he mentored the acts.

HAHA same as me ;)

:thumbs:

I loved Sharon and Danni's just got no personality whatsoever. Sharon was legendary. :bigsmile:

[Billy]

Simon Cowell
Dannii Minogue
Charlotte Church
Kimberley Walsh

[Marc]

Lemar would be good! Or Will young :thumbs:

And someone that isn't Dannii - maybe Churchy or Sharon

[Brad.]

Originally posted by Billy
Simon Cowell
Dannii Minogue
Charlotte Church
Kimberley Walsh

you would get rid of Cheryl:shocked:

[Harry!]

Originally posted by Jayson
Originally posted by Harry.
Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Amanda Holden/Dannii Minogue
Louie Walsh/Perce Morgan Nah, it's a completely different show to BGT, doubt it would ever work.

As a whole I like the BGT panel better then the X Factor panel, That is why I chose them.

[Beastie]

keep the same judges for BGT!!

but for x factor change danni minogue for lily allen!

[bronaaaa]

Simon Cowel
Cheryl Cole
Danii Minogue
Gary Barlow

[Harry!]

I would actully swap Cheryl Cole for Victoria Beckham. That would be my wish.

[LemonJam]

Simon Cowell
Sharon Osbourne
Dannii Minogue
Louie Walsh

Cheryl gives basically NO criticism and just sits there looking hot. Bring back Sharon!

[Princess]

Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Gary Barlow/Mark Owen(I'd actually rather have Mark,hah!)
And then some other girl singer,not Dannii!

[Zac]

Simon Cowell, Kimberley Walsh, Gary Barlow and Myleene Klass would be good I reckon. Get Cheryl out I say, she dosen't add anything to the panel but her hotness, even though I like it, she's a total bore. I would've preffered Sharon back actually but she'll never return so I threw Myleene in there instead.

[Tom]

Go back to three judges and just have Simon, Sharon and Louis again :dance2: The judges were epic when it was those 3, now its not so good

[KS2007]

Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Kim Wilde
Gary Barlow

I picked Kim because I think we need more age variety. Because I think Dannii and Cheryl are quite similar.

[Benjamin]

I'd have:


Simon Cowell
Alanis Morissette
Gary Barlow
Chery Cole

[Dom:D]

Simon Cowell
Cheryl Cole
Dannii Minogue
Beyonce Knowles

[bigbrother10uk]

David Hasselhoff
Cheryl Cole
Simon Cowell
Paula Abdul

[Stephanie]

Lemar
Cheryl
Louis
Simon

[Tom4784]

I'd get rid of Louis but I don't know who I'd replace him with.

[Adamw92]

Originally posted by Dezzy
I'd get rid of Louis but I don't know who I'd replace him with.

[candy24]

Originally posted by LemonJam
Simon Cowell
Sharon Osbourne
Dannii Minogue
Louie Walsh

Cheryl gives basically NO criticism and just sits there looking hot. Bring back Sharon!

I THINK IF VICTORIA BORINGHAM WAS ON THERE ID NEVER WATCH IT AGAIN SHE IS DEPRESSING.

I WOULD ONLY CHANGE DANNI FOR SHARON OSBOURNE OR LILY ALLEN IF SHE DIDN'T FLASH :hello:

[CaraRawr]

Simon Cowell
Lily Allen
Cheryl Cole
Gabe Saporta for the lulz

[xDramatick]

realistically;;
Simon Cowell.
Sharon Osbourne.
Paula Abdul.
Will Young.

dream;;
Simon Cowell.
Linda Perry.
Kelly Clarkson.
Gary Barlow.

[pete_bennet]

Simon Cowell
Sharon Osbourne
Cheryl Cole
Louis Walsh

[hannahfinal]

they should put brian from big brother in it LOL:eureka:

[Indierock&roll]

simon cowell, lois walsh, sharon osbourne!

but i dont mind it as it is now just miss sharon a bit and as much as i hate louis it wouldnt be the same without him on it