Who was the Greatest BBUS Player Ever?

[BBUK4LYFE]

For me its Dr. Will Kirby and its not even close.

Not only did he have a great mind for the game, but he was very entertaining.


http://i31.tinypic.com/1zyd9qx.jpg

[Chri$]

Crazy James, Matty, Dan and Jessie.

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by Chri$
Crazy James, Matty, Dan and Jessie.
James was pretty good, but dude come on, Matty from season 9? :laugh2:

Edit: I agree with Dan, James and Jessie being in the discussion for top ten consideration.

[Captain.Remy]

Obviously Will, no contest. The guy is a genius.

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by Captain.Remy
Obviously Will, no contest. The guy is a genius.
Yep. :cheer:

[BBUK4LYFE]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F2RdQyQ2zrA&feature=related

Will and Boogie. :laugh3::laugh3:

[melanie]

Originally posted by Chri$
and Jessie.

O_O

[ILoveTRW]

of coruse will but dan last year was quite impressive

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by melanie
Originally posted by Chri$
and Jessie.

O_O
Hater. :bored:

[Chilltown]

It's Will by far.

James wasn't the best...he was evicted twice.
Matty? He barely made the jury!
Jessie - ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Sure he was playing a pretty damn good game this season but 10th Place and 9th Place don't equal the best player ever. Are you kidding?
Dan, alright an argument can be made for him but lets see him come back and make final four again like Will did.


I think these are just your favorites. I think the Top 10 Best Strategic Players are:

1. Dr. Will - BB2/BB7
2. Dan - BB10
3. Mike - BB7
4. Danielle - BB3
5. Alison - BB4
6. Adam - BB9
7. Drew - BB5
8. Dick - BB8
9. Jun - BB4
10. Jason - BB3


I wouldn't put Janelle/Kaysar/James in there simply because, they played a more physical game and/or didn't make it far enough to garner respect as the Best BB Player in terms of Strategy. Janelle did very well but that wasn't any manipulation, it was simply because of her challenge wins over and over again.

[Marc]

Will :hello:

[bigbrother10uk]

Will is a legend.
but dick was a very good player too

[BBUK4LYFE]

Dick was ****ing garbage.

His daughter was a better player than him.

He was saved FOUR ****ing times by America's player. If the USA wasn't having his back, he wouldn't have won.

[geoking66]

BB3's Danielle, no contest. By the way, why do BBUS players (and fans) feel this compulsive need to add stupid and pointless adjectives to people's names? Dr Will (yes he's a doctor, I know that), Crazy James, Evil Dick, etc.

[Arneldo]

Best player, by a mile, BB10's Dan. Definitely stole the crown from Will.

[Arneldo]

Adam and Dick - grr, don't get me started.

Adam was a joke. every deal he made was put on the table by another housemate. He never made any moves himself, and whenever he was confronted he would just panic and start to ramble at 1000mph. He was dull and other housemates (Sheila, Ryan, Nat, Matt) brought him through the game.

Dick was just a vile scumbag. He wasn't a game player - but was just a vile person.

[Chri$]

Originally posted by geoking66
Dr Will (yes he's a doctor, I know that), Crazy James, Evil Dick, etc.

Dr Will = Doctor
Crazy James = He came up with that himself
Evil Dick = He was Evil

[LemonJam]

Does anyone else think that if Russell wasn't so aggressive, he'd be a really good player?

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Adam and Dick - grr, don't get me started.

Adam was a joke. every deal he made was put on the table by another housemate. He never made any moves himself, and whenever he was confronted he would just panic and start to ramble at 1000mph. He was dull and other housemates (Sheila, Ryan, Nat, Matt) brought him through the game.

Dick was just a vile scumbag. He wasn't a game player - but was just a vile person.
Adam was the worst player ever to win BB.

He was a complete joke.

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by geoking66
BB3's Danielle, no contest. By the way, why do BBUS players (and fans) feel this compulsive need to add stupid and pointless adjectives to people's names? Dr Will (yes he's a doctor, I know that), Crazy James, Evil Dick, etc.
Its Evel, not Evil, he had that name before he was even in BB.

[Chilltown]

Originally posted by BBUK4LYFE
Dick was ****ing garbage.

His daughter was a better player than him.

He was saved FOUR ****ing times by America's player. If the USA wasn't having his back, he wouldn't have won.

First of all, he was saved once by AP.

Originally posted by geoking66
BB3's Danielle, no contest. By the way, why do BBUS players (and fans) feel this compulsive need to add stupid and pointless adjectives to people's names? Dr Will (yes he's a doctor, I know that), Crazy James, Evil Dick, etc.

It's nicknames of course, people aren't allowed to have nicknames? :conf:


Will Mega
Chicken George
Mike Boogie
Dr. Will
Cowboy
Nakomis
Cappy
Evel Dick
Baller
Crazy James

The list goes on!

Secondly, Evel Dick wasn't really all that vile when you take a look at the people he was cooped up in that house with. I would go off on them like he did too if I had to live with Jen, Amber, Jameka, Dustin, etc! He was a strategic player, just because you don't like him, doesn't mean he didn't play a good game. Same goes with Adam. In a house full of loonies, he kept his composure and sailed under the radar without really being under the radar. Not once was he the target for eviction. NOT ONCE. The only other winner who can say that is Drew from Season 5.

But, like I said before, without doubt is Dr. Will the best player in BB history. If Dan can make it to the final four when All-Stars 2 rolls around, then maybe someone can put it up for debate but until then, he's just a less interesting Dr. Will knockoff who played an amazing game.

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Chilltown

But, like I said before, without doubt is Dr. Will the best player in BB history. If Dan can make it to the final four when All-Stars 2 rolls around, then maybe someone can put it up for debate but until then, he's just a less interesting Dr. Will knockoff who played an amazing game.

I don't even think Dan was that good to be honest. H ejust made a deal with Keesha, Renny and Memphis until the end and evicted the group of 8 and that's it. He got lucky when he was America's Player.

[ziltan]

BB10 Dan, think I've never seen people been played like that ever before.

[Firewire]

Dan BB10

No contest

[MarkWaldorf]

The only thing I liked about Dan last year was that epic veto ceremony where he made everyone confront each other about nominations. It was brilliant. Other than that, I don't see him as the greatest Big Brother player ever but that's just my opinion.

I'd say someone like Janelle. I loved her skill and game. I never watched BB2 so I can't comment on Will, but I'm guessing his game in BB7 was below par if he couldn't match winning. :tongue:

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by MarkWaldorf
The only thing I liked about Dan last year was that epic veto ceremony where he made everyone confront each other about nominations. It was brilliant. Other than that, I don't see him as the greatest Big Brother player ever but that's just my opinion.

I'd say someone like Janelle. I loved her skill and game. I never watched BB2 so I can't comment on Will, but I'm guessing his game in BB7 was below par if he couldn't match winning. :tongue:
I think his game was alot better in BB7 than it was in BB2 actually.

The girls figured that they had no shot at wining the grand prize at the end, so they backdoored (I think it was) Will in the final weeks. After the game was finished all the house guest even agreed that he was by far the greatest player for that season.

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by Chilltown
Originally posted by BBUK4LYFE
Dick was ****ing garbage.

His daughter was a better player than him.

He was saved FOUR ****ing times by America's player. If the USA wasn't having his back, he wouldn't have won.

No he wasn't.

It was more than once.

Also if it wasn't for America's Player in the end, he wouldn't have won the show. All the house guest were leaning towards his daughter to be the winner of the show, but America's Player convinced them that Dick was the better player.

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : BBUK4LYFE
I think his game was alot better in BB7 than it was in BB2 actually.

The girls figured that they had no shot at wining the grand prize at the end, so they backdoored (I think it was) Will in the final weeks. After the game was finished all the house guest even agreed that he was by far the greatest player for that season.

I agree, Janelle and Erika fell for the showmance thing but Mike and Will didn't care about these 2.
I still remember the Ninja thing in the store room and also when Janelle and Erika realized how stupid they came accross.

[BBUK4LYFE]

Originally posted by Captain.Remy
Message original : BBUK4LYFE
I think his game was alot better in BB7 than it was in BB2 actually.

The girls figured that they had no shot at wining the grand prize at the end, so they backdoored (I think it was) Will in the final weeks. After the game was finished all the house guest even agreed that he was by far the greatest player for that season.

I agree, Janelle and Erika fell for the showmance thing but Mike and Will didn't care about these 2.
I still remember the Ninja thing in the store room and also when Janelle and Erika realized how stupid they came accross.
Erika especially, fell hard for it. She got played big time.

[Captain.Remy]

Yeah I kinda felt sorry for her because she got that played. But then it's a game so I hope she didn't take it too personally.

[ILoveTRW]

Originally posted by MarkWaldorf
I'd say someone like Janelle. I loved her skill and game. I never watched BB2 so I can't comment on Will, but I'm guessing his game in BB7 was below par if he couldn't match winning. :tongue:

he got to 4th but considering the huge target on his back when going into the BB7 house, i think he played it better in BB7

best moments in bbus history
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2xUw5uxYQA&feature=related

[ILoveTRW]

Originally posted by Captain.Remy
Yeah I kinda felt sorry for her because she got that played. But then it's a game so I hope she didn't take it too personally.

she got $50000, she should be grateful

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : ILoveMoney
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2xUw5uxYQA&feature=related

I agree with what Nakomis said at the end, Janelle and Will should have been final 2, it would have been the best final 2 ever.

[CaPPa]

Dr Will by a long way. Chilltown FTW!

[BB4LIFE_SD]

I'd have to say Dan from BB10.

[iRyan]

Goddess Janelle

http://asapblogs.typepad.com/theslug/images/070506janelle_2.jpg