who is the best american idol winner?

[staceyxxx]

[Alf]

carrie underwood

[kellybsblover]

Jordin sparks has two votes :conf:.
I love Kelly C, Carrie U, and Cook but voted for Cook...

[staceyxxx]

david cookk,, love him :wink:
x

[xDramatick]

1. Kelly Clarkson.
2. David Cook.
3. Carrie Underwood.
4. Kris Allen.
5. Fantasia Barrino.
6. Jordin Sparks.
7. Ruben Studdard.
8. Taylor Hicks.

I only actually listen to Kelly and David though.

[MR.K!]

Jordin Sparks.

[Tom4784]

I'll go with Kelly, I liked David in the competition but his music something I have to be in the mood for. Jordin Sparks is a guilty pleasure but I wouldn't deem her a good artist. I liked Kris a lot in the competition but I can't judge him yet until I've heard his album.

[Billy]

Carrie.
Best vocalist in the history of Idol

[BBUK4LYFE]

Has to be Kelly Clarkson. With Taylor Hicks being by far the worst.

Jordin Sparks is probably my second favorite because of her song "No air".

That was probably my favourite song of 07.

[Twilight]

Kelly Clarkson