David shouted "lisa lisa lisa" so he failed?

[luminoussun]

THe rule was they are not allowed to talk.
But he clearly shouted her name 3 times.

Fail the big thick shrek lookalikey :thumbs:

[BlackOrWhite]

No, the rule was that they're only allowed to talk to each other.

[pixee]

Did they talk to them people on the bridge?

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by luminoussun
THe rule was they are not allowed to talk.
But he clearly shouted her name 3 times.

Fail the big thick shrek lookalikey :thumbs:

Not often right, luminoussun, but wrong again!

[luminoussun]

Originally posted by BlackOrWhite
No, the rule was that they're only allowed to talk to each other.
Just read what you typed??
YOu are wrong but if you right they broke the rule anyway they talked the whole time

[luminoussun]

Originally posted by The_Long_Run
Originally posted by luminoussun
THe rule was they are not allowed to talk.
But he clearly shouted her name 3 times.

Fail the big thick shrek lookalikey :thumbs:

Not often right, luminoussun, but wrong again!
The rule was they was they are not allowed to talk in front of anyone.
Go watch the program again but this time remove your fingers from your ears

[BlackOrWhite]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Originally posted by BlackOrWhite
No, the rule was that they're only allowed to talk to each other.
Just read what you typed??
YOu are wrong but if you right they broke the rule anyway they talked the whole time

Err...what? That was the rule. They're only allowed to communicate with each other.

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Originally posted by BlackOrWhite
No, the rule was that they're only allowed to talk to each other.
Just read what you typed??
YOu are wrong but if you right they broke the rule anyway they talked the whole time

Not often right, luminoussun, but wrong again, again!

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by BlackOrWhite
No, the rule was that they're only allowed to talk to each other.

this

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Originally posted by The_Long_Run
Originally posted by luminoussun
THe rule was they are not allowed to talk.
But he clearly shouted her name 3 times.

Fail the big thick shrek lookalikey :thumbs:

Not often right, luminoussun, but wrong again!
The rule was they was they are not allowed to talk in front of anyone.
Go watch the program again but this time remove your fingers from your ears
Not often right, luminoussun, but wrong again, again, again!

[Patricia4]

Yes thats what BB said each other only.

[luminoussun]

I might be wrong but shouting someones name IS communicating

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Originally posted by The_Long_Run
Originally posted by luminoussun
THe rule was they are not allowed to talk.
But he clearly shouted her name 3 times.

Fail the big thick shrek lookalikey :thumbs:

Not often right, luminoussun, but wrong again!
The rule was they was they are not allowed to talk in front of anyone.
Go watch the program again but this time remove your fingers from your ears

you are wrong. they were not allowed to talk to the public or bb staff. they could talk to each other all they wanted

[luminoussun]

Sometimes i think i am posting on a mentally disturbed site...i just watched it 3 bloody times and i am RIGHT so **** right off

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by luminoussun
I might be wrong but shouting someones name IS communicating

So, at whom do you think David was shouting "Lisa"? The one person with whom he was allowed to communicate of course!

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by luminoussun
I might be wrong but shouting someones name IS communicating

yeah it is... when you're shouting the other person's name to get THEIR attention:rolleyes:

they didn't break the rules at all

[Vicky.]

They were not allowed to reveal themselves to the public in any way, which I would expect, if people watch BB and heard david shout that they would know who he was. His voice is very easy to recognise, plus the fact that he was shouting lisa.,..people would click on had they watched the program before.

So I would expect it was a fail...


I doubt they will care much anyway, they had a fun day out, screw the others :laugh:

[Kazanne]

I think David is ok,they were allowed to communicate with each other but no one else.

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Sometimes i think i am posting on a mentally disturbed site...i just watched it 3 bloody times and i am RIGHT so **** right off

I never knew being wrong was something you get addicted to. Still you are the proof of it!

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Sometimes i think i am posting on a mentally disturbed site...i just watched it 3 bloody times and i am RIGHT so **** right off

what's with the bloody attitude?? you are wrong. accept it and move on.

http://www.channel4.com/bigbrother/blog/cd71b3362017c34680320e09f7f5558f/view.c4



This morning it was announced that for the new Shopping Task, housemates had been transported to the Big Brother House of 2209. And in the open-minded 23rd century, even aliens are allowed to enter the House.

And seemingly, they're also allowed to leave it to do a little sight-seeing.

Dressed as aliens, Lisa and David have today been on an open-top bus tour of London. They've been to three landmarks - Tower Bridge, St Paul's Cathedral and the Houses of Parliament.

To pass their part of the Task they were instructed to get a photo of themselves taken by another tourist on the disposable cameras given to them by Big Brother. However, they were not allowed to talk to anyone except for each other, and they only had 10 minutes at each landmark.

They've had an exciting day out on Planet Earth, but like any good extra-terrestrials, eventually they had to go home.

And when they arrived back this evening the pair looked pleased as punch after their grand day out.

"I can't believe it," Lisa beamed as the pair chuckled together.

Then they burst into the House to tell their fellow housemates all about it. But, instead of the housemates looking pleased for them, they looked ever so slightly miffed. Perhaps because their great escape was being slightly eclipsed, or maybe they just fancied a sight-seeing trip on a bus themselves?

Question is, did David and Lisa get any good holiday snaps?

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by VickyJ
They were not allowed to reveal themselves to the public in any way, which I would expect, if people watch BB and heard david shout that they would know who he was. His voice is very easy to recognise, plus the fact that he was shouting lisa.,..people would click on had they watched the program before.

So I would expect it was a fail...


I doubt they will care much anyway, they had a fun day out, screw the others :laugh:

Oh yes, of course, people will think they might be seeing two people who are locked in the BB House, walking round London! NOT!

[amy-jayne]

Lmao @ david haters, looking for reasons for him to be made to be "dumb" and "stupid"
they were allowed to speak to EACHOTHER, he was speaking to her, and didnt blow their cover, duh

[luminoussun]

THEY WAS NOT ALLOWED TO SPEAK IN FRONT OF ANYONE...THEY HAD TO GET PEOPLE TO TAKE PICTURES OF THEM WITHOUT ANY TALKING.
wow i just am worried about you lot

[luminoussun]

david is dumb and your dumb if you dont think it

[luminoussun]

They was allowed to talk to each other but not in front of anyone

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by luminoussun
THEY WAS NOT ALLOWED TO SPEAK IN FRONT OF ANYONE...THEY HAD TO GET PEOPLE TO TAKE PICTURES OF THEM WITHOUT ANY TALKING.
wow i just am worried about you lot

and AGAIN

read the bb website

http://www.channel4.com/bigbrother/blog/cd71b3362017c34680320e09f7f5558f/view.c4



This morning it was announced that for the new Shopping Task, housemates had been transported to the Big Brother House of 2209. And in the open-minded 23rd century, even aliens are allowed to enter the House.

And seemingly, they're also allowed to leave it to do a little sight-seeing.

Dressed as aliens, Lisa and David have today been on an open-top bus tour of London. They've been to three landmarks - Tower Bridge, St Paul's Cathedral and the Houses of Parliament.

To pass their part of the Task they were instructed to get a photo of themselves taken by another tourist on the disposable cameras given to them by Big Brother. However, they were not allowed to talk to anyone except for each other, and they only had 10 minutes at each landmark.

They've had an exciting day out on Planet Earth, but like any good extra-terrestrials, eventually they had to go home.

And when they arrived back this evening the pair looked pleased as punch after their grand day out.

"I can't believe it," Lisa beamed as the pair chuckled together.

Then they burst into the House to tell their fellow housemates all about it. But, instead of the housemates looking pleased for them, they looked ever so slightly miffed. Perhaps because their great escape was being slightly eclipsed, or maybe they just fancied a sight-seeing trip on a bus themselves?

Question is, did David and Lisa get any good holiday snaps?

[Kazanne]

Originally posted by luminoussun
THEY WAS NOT ALLOWED TO SPEAK IN FRONT OF ANYONE...THEY HAD TO GET PEOPLE TO TAKE PICTURES OF THEM WITHOUT ANY TALKING.
wow i just am worried about you lot
There is no shame in being wrong you know?

[amy-jayne]

David isnt as dumb as sophie.

Plus the other HMs ruined the whole task anyway, so..

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by luminoussun
They was allowed to talk to each other but not in front of anyone

you are just making stuff up now coz you've been proved wrong. really no point correcting you when you won't accept you're wrong

[luminoussun]

I am right!!!!!!!!!!!
In a world full of ******* a genius is seen as the ******...think about it :laugh:

[Beyoncé]

They didn't break the rules. David was *addressing* Lisa. By addressing someone, you are communicating WITH them. David and Lisa were able to communicate with each other, but not with Big Brother staff or members of the public. They also weren't able to reveal their identity, and using the name Lisa is hardly revealing her identity.

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by luminoussun
They was allowed to talk to each other but not in front of anyone
I think the word you are looking for is were. Be careful, you are beginning to sound like David!

[luminoussun]

Originally posted by Beyoncé
They didn't break the rules. Davis was *addressing* Lisa. By addressing someone, you are communicating WITH them. David and Lisa were able to communicate with each other, but not with Big Brother staff or members of the public. They also weren't able to reveal their identity, and using the name Lisa is hardly revealing her identity.
BY saying her name in davids accent is clearly revealing her...i would know it was david 100%

[luminoussun]

Originally posted by The_Long_Run
Originally posted by luminoussun
They was allowed to talk to each other but not in front of anyone
I think the word you are looking for is were. Be careful, you are beginning to sound like David!
So you admit he is dumb then :thumbs:

[Vicky.]

Originally posted by The_Long_Run
Originally posted by VickyJ
They were not allowed to reveal themselves to the public in any way, which I would expect, if people watch BB and heard david shout that they would know who he was. His voice is very easy to recognise, plus the fact that he was shouting lisa.,..people would click on had they watched the program before.

So I would expect it was a fail...


I doubt they will care much anyway, they had a fun day out, screw the others :laugh:

Oh yes, of course, people will think they might be seeing two people who are locked in the BB House, walking round London! NOT!

Did I say that?

Davids voice is very distinctive. I watch BB a lot, if he was out round newcastle dressed up as anything and he shouted lisa, I would reckonise his voice. Being a BB fan and all...

I may well think I was imagining it, but I would be very suspicious.

I would notice his voice anywhere...

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Originally posted by The_Long_Run
Originally posted by luminoussun
They was allowed to talk to each other but not in front of anyone
I think the word you are looking for is were. Be careful, you are beginning to sound like David!
So you admit he is dumb then :thumbs:
Well he's not the brightest button in the box, no, but at least he can understand BB's instructions. Unlike someone not a million miles from this thread!

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by luminoussun
Originally posted by Beyoncé
They didn't break the rules. Davis was *addressing* Lisa. By addressing someone, you are communicating WITH them. David and Lisa were able to communicate with each other, but not with Big Brother staff or members of the public. They also weren't able to reveal their identity, and using the name Lisa is hardly revealing her identity.
BY saying her name in davids accent is clearly revealing her...i would know it was david 100%

think about it. 2m viewers this series, approx 60/61m people in the uk, about 7/8m in london. what are the chances that the people that were around them (mostly tourists from other countries) watched bb? so what are the REAL chances that they would be found out by a male northern voice shouting "lisa"??

and you think you're a genius?? :pat:

[WAYNEEBRUM]

Dave spoke a lot during that task,watch it now on plus1,he cant shut up

[The_Long_Run]

Originally posted by VickyJ
Originally posted by The_Long_Run
Originally posted by VickyJ
They were not allowed to reveal themselves to the public in any way, which I would expect, if people watch BB and heard david shout that they would know who he was. His voice is very easy to recognise, plus the fact that he was shouting lisa.,..people would click on had they watched the program before.

So I would expect it was a fail...


I doubt they will care much anyway, they had a fun day out, screw the others :laugh:

Oh yes, of course, people will think they might be seeing two people who are locked in the BB House, walking round London! NOT!

Did I say that?

Davids voice is very distinctive. I watch BB a lot, if he was out round newcastle dressed up as anything and he shouted lisa, I would reckonise his voice. Being a BB fan and all...

I may well think I was imagining it, but I would be very suspicious.

I would notice his voice anywhere...

(a) The brain automatically filters out dissonance that contradicts what we 'know' to be impossible.
(b) Tourists wandering around London have better things to do than be part of the 2 Million saddos like us, that watch this garbage!

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by WAYNEEBRUM
Dave spoke a lot during that task,watch it now on plus1,he cant shut up

they were allowed to talk to each other

[delta]

I haven't seen the task, only the narrative of the day out posted by kisywisy.

In it, it clearly states that they were allowed to talk to each other ( I presume at all times) meaning alone and in front of members of the public.

What they weren't allowed to do was to talk to any members of the production team or members of the public on their task.

I would presume the latter meaning that they would have to use some sort of sign or body language to get the passers by to take their pictures at the London landmarks.

[WOMBAI]

Originally posted by luminoussun
I might be wrong but shouting someones name IS communicating

Yes - to each other! :sad:

[Vicky.]

Watched it on plus one and he actually spoke TO a guy who wouldnt take the picture...


He only said NO, but its speaking to other people...

I would imagine roddy and sophie would fail theirs anyway, what were the others tasks? I think they have failed it anyway, with or without a fail from lisa and david...

[BBmassive]

Originally posted by luminoussun
THe rule was they are not allowed to talk.
But he clearly shouted her name 3 times.

Fail the big thick shrek lookalikey :thumbs: FFS Lighten up ....whats wrong did they overshadowed your boring hero ? .BY FAR the best moment of bb10 :laugh3::laugh3::laugh3:

[luminoussun]

Thanks vicky for bringing the sanity level up on this thread :thumbs:

[luminoussun]

Originally posted by BBmassive
Originally posted by luminoussun
THe rule was they are not allowed to talk.
But he clearly shouted her name 3 times.

Fail the big thick shrek lookalikey :thumbs: FFS Lighten up ....whats wrong did they overshadowed your boring hero ? .BY FAR the best moment of bb10 :laugh3::laugh3::laugh3:
ok your right i admit it was funny i am just saying they failed...it's no biggie

[muchadoaboutnothing]

They were allowed to talk to each other and even use their own names as long as no member of the public cottoned on as to who they were and no member of the public did realise who they were. So they would have passed the task. And they were brilliant.

[Shasown]

There is a minor problem.

They did fail

On the second location where David took the camera back from the little coloured girl he did say"Thank You".

The production team cover this up by turning up the background noise and turning the input from their mic's down but if you watch it and listen carefully he does say "thank you" And that is communicating verbally to the public.


from http://www.channel4.com/bigbrother/blog/cd71b3362017c34680320e09f7f5558f/view.c4

To pass their part of the Task they were instructed to get a photo of themselves taken by another tourist on the disposable cameras given to them by Big Brother. However, they were not allowed to talk to anyone except for each other, and they only had 10 minutes at each landmark.

[luminoussun]

they failed la la la :elephant::elephant::elephant:
Big brother will not fail them as they are on operation kiss lisa and davids ass of late

[luminoussun]

I just watched it again and he clearly says that you are not allowed to reveal your name or who you are verbally or in any way....i am so right and it slightly worries me that people can watch the same show and not hear the facts??
Goldfish memories me thinks :tongue:

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Regardless of whether he was allowed to talk to Lisa while near people or not. David said "No, this one" (about the camera) to somebody.

[MissKittyFantastico]

I do remember thinking to myself when David shouted 'Lisa Lisa Lisa' several times, that they could incur a fail for that, because yes they were allowed to speak to each other, but they were also told that they weren't allowed to reveal their identity in ANY way.

Him shouting her name could, if BB wanted to be really strict about it, mean that he's failed.

Not big enough of a deal for people on here to be arguing about it so much though surely? :tongue:

[setanta]

I agree Kitty and sure I found the whole thing so funny. Lisa walking exactly like she normally does took the buscuit for me.... still knew it was her in the costume lol.

[Beyoncé]

I will not dispute the fact that they may have failed the task but the fail would be nothing to do with him saying "Lisa Lisa Lisa." It doesn't MATTER that we knew it was David because of his accent, he did not intentionally reveal who he was verbally. That's like saying he revealed who he was because you could tell there was a big bloke under the costume - OH NOEZ THAT MUST BE DAVID FROM BB!!!111one - uh, no. Doesn't work like that.

Saying thank you to a girl, saying "no, this one" about the camera to someone would be against the task rules, but not addressing Lisa in his normal accent around people. He didn't communicate who he was to the general public then.

[Shasown]

Originally posted by Beyoncé

Saying thank you to a girl, saying "no, this one" about the camera to someone would be against the task rules, but not addressing Lisa in his normal accent around people. He didn't communicate who he was to the general public then.

I never said they should have failed because people recognised him from his accent etc, please read this it is a quote directly from the official ch4 bb website

To pass their part of the Task they were instructed to get a photo of themselves taken by another tourist on the disposable cameras given to them by Big Brother. However, they were not allowed to talk to anyone except for each other, and they only had 10 minutes at each landmark.

Now tell me did they pass if he said thank you or anything else to a member of the public?

[Beyoncé]

Originally posted by Shasown
Originally posted by Beyoncé

Saying thank you to a girl, saying "no, this one" about the camera to someone would be against the task rules, but not addressing Lisa in his normal accent around people. He didn't communicate who he was to the general public then.

I never said they should have failed because people recognised him from his accent etc, please read this it is a quote directly from the official ch4 bb website

To pass their part of the Task they were instructed to get a photo of themselves taken by another tourist on the disposable cameras given to them by Big Brother. However, they were not allowed to talk to anyone except for each other, and they only had 10 minutes at each landmark.

Now tell me did they pass if he said thank you or anything else to a member of the public?

I wasn't replying to you :thumbs:

[Beyoncé]

Oh and with regards to whether they passed/failed? I don't know. All I know is if they had it had nothing to do with the "Lisa Lisa Lisa" - I was AGREEING with you, if anything, that it would be the thank you/etc. to the girl/public.