Harpers Island! (Disscusion Thread)

[DrunkerThanMoses]

:thumbs: Double Bill... BBC3, 9

[Tom4784]

I'm really looking foward to this, it's a double bill as well. I'll be watching it tnoight definately.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I'm really looking foward to this, it's a double bill as well. I'll be watching it tnoight definately.

:hello: Suppose to be really good..... we should have a disscussion after it to see what we all thought!

[Tom4784]

Ah I loved it, It was a bit slow but I can't wait to see what happens next.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I agree... the first two episodes were oaky... jsut need to get into it a bit more....... ah i cant believe goth girl died, i liked here..... a bit wired!

[Tom4784]

Yeah, I think it'll pick up the pace when the discover the bodies though. I'm very surprised she died really, I expected her to live for longer.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Any suspects yet?

SO far the deaths are :-

1.The Cousin at start
2.Uncle Wats his name
3.The Vicar
4.The Goth woman - Kelly.... but was it suiciced?
5.The lady with the dog!

Main Supspect is the other blonde woman, the one whos boyfriend tried to propose too!

[Tom4784]

Any suspects yet?

SO far the deaths are :-

1.The Cousin at start
2.Uncle Wats his name
3.The Vicar
4.The Goth woman - Kelly.... but was it suiciced?
5.The lady with the dog!

Main Supspect is the other blonde woman, the one whos boyfriend tried to propose too!

The blonde girl's too obvious I think, they've hammered it down our throat that she's obssessed with killers so it won't be her. I've got a feeling it was the groom since they keep mentioning that he's good with boats so he could have set up the boat murder easily and I think he set up the deer thing to put suspicion on the arse-y one.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Any suspects yet?

SO far the deaths are :-

1.The Cousin at start
2.Uncle Wats his name
3.The Vicar
4.The Goth woman - Kelly.... but was it suiciced?
5.The lady with the dog!

Main Supspect is the other blonde woman, the one whos boyfriend tried to propose too!

The blonde girl's too obvious I think, they've hammered it down our throat that she's obssessed with killers so it won't be her. I've got a feeling it was the groom since they keep mentioning that he's good with boats so he could have set up the boat murder easily and I think he set up the deer thing to put suspicion on the arse-y one.

Could be him..... ah they made all the characters to suspicious...... wtf is up with the dad....

[BBUK4LYFE]

I watched the first 3 episode back in April when it was on CBS.

I couldn't watch anymore episodes, it was hella boring. Felt like I watching a soap.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Oh Episode 3 and 4 was brillent, oh the bride nearly dying... oh more please!

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

I thought Hunter Jennings would be the killer but that's not happening now.

I'm intrigued!


The Blonde Girl- I didn't even suspect she'd be the killer and can't see it

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Yeah another watcher....

...... I dont know to suspect now, their all too suspicious.......

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

I'm not suspicious of much at the moment though.

I did Abi's ex BF for a while and what's up with that crazy kid?

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Madeline? ****ed up I know lol...

..... Im still having doubts with that blonde girl.... whos with the english guy..... but no one else seems to think its her..... but will have to see!

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

What made you suspect her.?

[DrunkerThanMoses]

In the first episode she was talking about the murders on the island bu that guy, and she lloked intrested and looked like she did her homework on it?

Also the first murder was the cousin in under the boat, so someone o nthe boat must be the killer, not someone o nthe island and people wh oarrived late..... e.g the main girl (sorry i stil ldont know any of the names)

When the Uncle was killed, she was o nher own..... she had a fight with the english dude, and went of alone!

and of course the blonde girl with the dog, i mguessing she was jelious...?


Not good reasons, but at least Im trying to figure it out!

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

I see, Well i suspected the Uncle(dead), Hunter(dead) and then Abi(the main girl) ex boyfriend(the fisherman with the hat) but i forgot the chap under the both so couldn't be him.

Haven't got a clue now, I might watch it on the net because I'm too impatient to wait

[DrunkerThanMoses]

LMAO, i thought of doing that...... but i dont mind waiting.

Cant be Abi the main girl as she came late to the boat.... they cousin was under it all ready... unless she did it before, then pretended to be late?

If you do, dont spoil it for me lol...... :nono: :joker:

I wanno keep guessing....... main suspect for me is still the blonde girl!

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

I wont spoil it for you if i do but before I watch it my prediction is either Abi's ex Boyfriend or Bride's Dad.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I wont spoil it for you if i do but before I watch it my prediction is either Abi's ex Boyfriend or Bride's Dad.

Lol... I was also thinkign the brides dad as well!

Well enjoy, and if you tell me wh othe killer is, well..... that would be bad thing to do :tongue:

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

:joker: Don't worry I wont

[Tom4784]

I've got a feeling it's the groom.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I've got a feeling it's the groom.

Henry.... I know his name, only because its the same name he had i nugly betty :whistle:

Could be him.....

im still finding them all suspicious......

[Tom4784]

It's easier to point out people who I don't think is the murderer.

NOT THE MURDERER:
English man's Girlfriend - The serial killer obsession's too obvious.
Bride's dad - He's an antagonist so it's too obvious for him to be the killer.
Shane? (I think that's his name, the one who tried to hang Henry's brother): Again like with the dad he's way too suspicious.
Anyone on the Fishing Boat (With the possible exception of Henry): This whole subplot will probably be used as a Red herring to make us think that one of Henry's friends is the Killer.
Henry's Brother: They've shoved it down our throat that he's not all together in the head, thus making it too obvious that he's the killer.
Abi: She's the protagonist and our 'eyes' of the series. We see most events from her perspective. It'd be hard to make her the killer as her character is the fundamntal 'truth' of the series.

That's it basically.

The only thing annoying me about this series is that it's been like 3 days in the Show and nobody's wondered where the uncle, Cousin or any of the other victims have disappeared to.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

It's easier to point out people who I don't think is the murderer.

NOT THE MURDERER:
English man's Girlfriend - The serial killer obsession's too obvious.
Bride's dad - He's an antagonist so it's too obvious for him to be the killer.
Shane? (I think that's his name, the one who tried to hang Henry's brother): Again like with the dad he's way too suspicious.
Anyone on the Fishing Boat (With the possible exception of Henry): This whole subplot will probably be used as a Red herring to make us think that one of Henry's friends is the Killer.
Henry's Brother: They've shoved it down our throat that he's not all together in the head, thus making it too obvious that he's the killer.
Abi: She's the protagonist and our 'eyes' of the series. We see most events from her perspective. It'd be hard to make her the killer as her character is the fundamntal 'truth' of the series.

That's it basically.

The only thing annoying me about this series is that it's been like 3 days in the Show and nobody's wondered where the uncle, Cousin or any of the other victims have disappeared to.



That annoyed me too, I mean the uncle did leave a message, and I think they jsut thoguth teh cousin was not coming in the end....

... but the blonde woman with the dog is another story... you think at least maybe her husband.... she has one I think woudl me worred, but nothing, however she might be disscussed in later episodes.

And waht about the English guy himself?

I find your reasons for who might not be the killer intresting, Its intresting that we have different theorys, Im still putting the money on english guys girlfriend.... she was very quiet in the last two episodes.....

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

I Thought about the groom but can't understand why he'd kill the uncle

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I Thought about the groom but can't understand why he'd kill the uncle

Maybe the uncle was having it off with the bride?

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

Ye they did have a little look. I rewatched the first episode and seen the blonde girl talking about the killings. Doubt it's her now as they made it kind of suspicious

[Tom4784]

I've got a theory, there's more then one killer. I rewatched all four episodes with my sister and since nearly all the characters are in a group most of the time there must be 2 or so killers. I'm not sure if Cal (English dude) or Chloe (serial killer lover) are the killers because in one of the credit sequences you see them running away from someone. Unless one of them is acting.

I'm starting to think it's not Henry either, I just can't think of a motive. The only way it'll be him is if they really wanna put a twist in at the end and make hism otive some obscure reason.

[Tom4784]

I've got a theory, there's more then one killer. I rewatched all four episodes with my sister and since nearly all the characters are in a group most of the time there must be 2 or so killers. I'm not sure if Cal (English dude) or Chloe (serial killer lover) are the killers because in one of the credit sequences you see them running away from someone. Unless one of them is acting.

I'm starting to think it's not Henry either, I just can't think of a motive. The only way it'll be him is if they really wanna put a twist in at the end and make hism otive some obscure reason.

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

Interesting, I still want to know what the crack is with the kid madelaine, bit too weird!

I'm starting to think it's Henry now(the groom)

[DrunkerThanMoses]

2 killers is possible, and well done for spotting that....

we will have to see as the show goes on, role on episode 5 and 6

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

It should be on Wednesdays and Sundays. I hate having to wait a week

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Lol I know... im soo tempted to go on wikipedia or watch them lol, but I cant.... I am gonig to get the killer right lmao.....:hello:

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

My guess for the killer before I watch is Abi's ex Boyfriend(the Fisherman with the Hat) and he has an accomplice who came on the boat

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Half way through and Im still clueless lol

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

Hmm It's confusing indeed. Is the guy with the burned faced wakefield?

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Hmm It's confusing indeed. Is the guy with the burned faced wakefield?

Could be..... would be intresting if he is.

Im starting to think he might off not killed people seven years ago. Im very certain at the moment the ex-boyfriend (the fisher guy) is the killer. Seems to spend time alone.......

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

Hmm It's confusing indeed. Is the guy with the burned faced wakefield?



Im starting to think he might off not killed people seven years ago. Im very certain at the moment the ex-boyfriend (the fisher guy) is the killer. Seems to spend time alone.......
Woo, My guess:joker:

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Hmm It's confusing indeed. Is the guy with the burned faced wakefield?



Im starting to think he might off not killed people seven years ago. Im very certain at the moment the ex-boyfriend (the fisher guy) is the killer. Seems to spend time alone.......
Woo, My guess:joker:


:joker: Im thinking him because he spends alot of time alone, and is never around that much.

But he couldnt have killed the cousin at the start, so Im thinking he has a partner, and for some odd reason I think him and the groom are gay lovers, and him and Henry are the killers?

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

:joker: Dount gay lovers but maybe partners

[DrunkerThanMoses]

:joker: and big :hello: for Chole this week, love her even more!

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

Chloe is quite hot aswell. The Bride is really hot!

[Tom4784]

Sunday's episodes were really good I think things are gonna kick into high gear now. I definately think there's more then one killer since once again most people were in groups or accouted for in those episodes so they couldn't have operated alone. At the moment my main suspects are the Fisherman, Henry (not sure on the motive but one of the killers I think was at the rehearsal), Abi's dad (They're trying to lure us into a false sense of security I think with him) and I'm starting to think Chloe or Cal COULD have something to do with it (only like a 5% chance though).

It's interesting because we've been provided with so many possible motives such as the money, the supernatural (remember the psychic and Madison's 'friends'), the possibility of Wakefield being alive (or possibly having a relative). Here's a question, who do you think's gonna survive?

The only one that I'm certain's gonna survive is Madison as kids are rarely killed off. Abi will probably survive and I think Henry COULD possibly live too (or die near the end). I think they're gonna kill of the bride soon, her name escapes me again.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Um I think Madison will survive because like you said shes a child, however they might have a twist and shock us... I mean Im shocked the brides father died.. .so you never know.

I hope Chole survives.... I like her... .Im stil lhoping shes killer know.

I think ABi will survive.

and Im considering the coloured friend as maybe a suspect.... hes quiet and alot in the beack ground..... should of been killed by now... .but hes still alive?

[Shaun]

I've only watched Episode 3 onwards - so I'm struggling with names.

Abi's the bride and Henry's the groom, right? So therefore I know the main woman's dad is the main policeman [obsessed with those murders]. And Henry's brother is the tattooed isolated one.

Idk the names of the minor characters though.

[Shaun]

Aaaaah I just wikied some of the names and got major spoilers :(

Bit of a shock who one [if there are more than one, idk] of the killers is.

[Shaun]

Well that's this series ruined for me LOL

[Tom4784]

I've only watched Episode 3 onwards - so I'm struggling with names.

Abi's the bride and Henry's the groom, right? So therefore I know the main woman's dad is the main policeman [obsessed with those murders]. And Henry's brother is the tattooed isolated one.

Idk the names of the minor characters though.

The bride's Trish and Abi's the main girl who's dad the police officer.

[Shaun]

I know that now LOL, I read the whole of the plot last night because it'd pretty much been spoiled for me accidentally. It looks quite promising, but some of the deaths sound really nasty :|

Particularly the next two.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

:shocked: Will be watching tommorow then lol

[Braden]

wow i can't wait !

[DrunkerThanMoses]

:shocked: Did is that the death of madison..... oh good ending!

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

Hmm... I have know idea who the suspect is now

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Henry is deff one.

Heres why, when the guy with the burnt face and Abbys dad were in the cabin, someone was shotting at them.

Now, the one group were in the house, while group 2 were running for the boat.

Abby and Jimmy were together (They might be killers together)

while Henry was alone.. .the only one alone!

However that fat woman was also alone (the weddign palnner), she might be killer as well... Im guessing she was That murders from 7 years ago, wife or even his daughter?

So many theories and question!

[Shaun]

It was so obvious Malcolm would end up dead, LOL

[Tom4784]

The last two episodes were great, it's getting better each episode.

I'm thinking that Henry might not be the killer since the ending to the last episode made it too obvious but then it could be a red herring to make us believe that it's too obvious for Henry to be the killer. Give me one more episode and I'll have more solid theories. I've also got a feeling that either Chloe or Cal or perhaps both will die soon (:bawling:) but I think Beth will probably die next as she just seems like cannonfodder really.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Well Beth died lol.

Im still confussed :conf: Too many suspects

[Jessica.]

http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=148519

[Tom4784]

What a great pair of episodes, I'm thoroughly convinced that Jimmy's the second killer and he's a plant to kill the others.

I can't wait for next Sunday.

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

I think Jimmy is the Killer aswell.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Oh Jimmy seems to be a big suspect!

Im suspicous of the bar maid?

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo my dear Chole died! :sad:

[Shaun]

The Sheriff and Chloe's deaths were so sad :(

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

Poor Chloe. A few of us were right on Jimmy aswell.

[Ninastar]

That man that killed the other man last night, is he a ghost?
When they were on the bridge and the woman was screaming then jumped.
(Sorry I only saw the one episode, and its scary!! :( )

[DrunkerThanMoses]

That man that killed the other man last night, is he a ghost?
When they were on the bridge and the woman was screaming then jumped.
(Sorry I only saw the one episode, and its scary!! :( )

Dont think so, hes a the one killer... and Im thinking Jimmy is his son.

Watch more ninastar their great!

[Tom4784]

Not Chloe and Cal! They were my favourite characters :sad: I thought it was the last episode but I was wrong, there's two more. Who's gonna die?

I'm thinking Henry or Trish as well as possibly Shay. Madison won't die, Jimmy will and either Daniel or Sully. Has anybody else noticed that all the characters have appaling aims and reaction times? :laugh: Nikki coulda easily shot Wakefield in the face from behind the bar and how hard is it really to miss with a SHOTGUN?

:joker:

[Adamw92]

I watched this show on the internet during its airing for america, The last two episodes are so good and I'm with you's on this 1- Chloe's death was so sad, I didn't want her to die!!!!!

You's are gonna love the next two episodes

[Ninastar]

watching it now. its really good. I wish that i watched the whole series.

[Ninastar]

omg she needs to stab him! or he will kill her!

[Ninastar]

Omfg!!!

[Ninastar]

omg x 100

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Oh good show all together!

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Hiya Nina c u going to watch that show now on bbc3!

[Ninastar]

yeah i am lol. I am still scared of seeing something scary lol.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Well that was a good show!

I knew Henry was the killer all along (Btw im talking bull ****)

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

I liked the series but didn't really like the ending and the whole Henry plot.

[Tom4784]

Ha ha! My first guess was right! The penultimate episode was very good but I wasn't a huge fan of the final one. I think they needed to save a few more mysteries for the final episode as it was more about reasons then answers. Trish's death was very well done (although me and my sister guessed she'd die as soon as she put on the wedding dress).

I think Sully was killed off too quickly really to say that he was a main presence throughout the series. He shoulda died saving Abbie and Jimmy at the church or something. Overall it was an very good series and I'll get it on DVD when it comes out.

[Jords]

This show was amazing, thoroughly enjoyed it!
Loved Cal & Chloe, my favourite characters,
their death scene was the best,
but I wanted them to survive! Lol.

I for one ruled out Henry, Abbie & Trish,
can't be believe it was actually Henry though!

[Shaun]

i wish i hadn't had this spoiled :( it was a good story.

['Conor]

its out February 8th on dvd :):):) i still think lucys death was most painfull