Greatest band of all time +1 -1

[Twilight]

Got the idea from the Greatest Female artist of all time +1 -1 thread:)

Oasis - 10
Muse - 10
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 10
The Rolling Stones - 10
Paramore - 10
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
green day - 10
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 10
Take That - 10
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 10
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10


If you like the band you +1 them
if you dislike them you -1 them
Two at a time btw

Feel Free to add more if you wish:)

[Novo]

Oh for god's sake

[staceyxxx]

+1 the saturdays
-1 the beatles

[Iceman]

That list is well off, not having a fight but you've missed out on at least 4 that i would have had in the list....

[Shaun]

Paramore? Fall Out Boy? Oh sweetie just no.

[Shaun]

+1 the saturdays
-1 the beatles

**** RIGHT off.

[Princess]

WHERE ARE TAKE THAT?????????? And don't say they're not a 'real band' because they all play instruments

Such a random list,I don't like these things at all

[Twilight]

Feel Free to add more if you wish:)

[Shaun]

Well let's kick things off then.

Oasis - 10
Muse - 10
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 10
The Rolling Stones - 11 +
Paramore - 10
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
green day - 10
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 9
The Saturdays [pmsl] - 10 -
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10

[Ninastar]

You should have made it fair by asking everyone first. Why dont you redo it so people can vote thier fave bands? more people would do it then

[Iceman]

Queen
R.E.M.
Nirvana

I would say Arctic Monkeys if the Killers are there then Arctic's should be too....

[King Gizzard]

someones needs to do a list we can all agree on.

[Ramsay]

+1 the saturdays
-1 the beatles

W....T.....F

[Twilight]

+1 the saturdays
-1 the beatles

W....T.....FIKR

[Harry!]

No girl bands. No mixed bands. How odd.

[MiuMiu]

Where are QUEEN????
or Abba?
:hugesmile:

[Twilight]

No girl bands. No mixed bands. How odd.Huh by girls bands you mean?

[Twilight]

Feel Free to add more if you wish:)Read it people!!

[Harry!]

No girl bands. No mixed bands. How odd.Huh by girls bands you mean?

Spice Girls, Bananarama, All Saints...

[MiuMiu]

Destiny's Child!
The Carpenters!
The Temptations!
The Supremes!
The Cranberry's!
REM!
Guns n' Roses!

[Twilight]

No girl bands. No mixed bands. How odd.Huh by girls bands you mean?

Spice Girls, Bananarama, All Saints...They are groups not bands

[Ramsay]

No girl bands. No mixed bands. How odd.Huh by girls bands you mean?

Spice Girls, Bananarama, All Saints...They are groups not bands

true

[arsenalforever]

The beatles nuff said

[Damaris]

What the actually ****? Lol

[ILoveTRW]

paramore????
pisses self

[Nurse57]

This list is funny. :laugh3:

[mrs-big]

Paramore? Fall out boy? for greatest band of all time?

Deary me!

What about Queen?
The Beatles?

[Twilight]

Oasis - 10
Muse - 10
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 10
The Rolling Stones - 10
Paramore - 10
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
green day - 10
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 10
Take That - 10
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 10
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

Forget the old one my minds wasn't working:P

[30stone]

Too many to choose like if we can keep adding them it seems a little pointless we need to decide on 10 or 12...

Then with them 10/12 bands start the game..

[Ramsay]

Grats Twilight on 6000 posts:thumbs:

[Twilight]

Aw thanks i didn't know i was on 6000:dance:

[MiuMiu]

Woop for Twilight!
Congrats!
:thumbs:

:hello:

[Shaun]

Oasis - 10
Muse - 10
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 10
The Rolling Stones - 11 (+)
Paramore - 9 (-)
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
green day - 10
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 10
Take That - 10
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 10
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[Tom4784]

I can't be bothered to play but anyone who minuses Muse are dead to me. :laugh:

EDIT: Screw it.

Oasis - 10
Muse - 11 +
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 10
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 9
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
green day - 9 -
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 10
Take That - 10
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 10
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[Princess]

Oasis - 10
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 10
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 8 -
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
green day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 10
Take That - 11 +
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 10
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[Shaun]

Oasis - 10
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 9 -
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 8
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
green day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 11 +
Take That - 11
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 10
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[Jayson]

Oasis - 10
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 7 [-]
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
Green Day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 12 [+]
Take That - 11
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 10
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[BBUK4LYFE]

- 10 for everyone on that list.

[Twilight]

Oasis - 10
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 8 [+]
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
Green Day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 12
Take That - 11
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9 [-]
Abba - 10
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[Ninastar]

Oasis - 10
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 10
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 7 [-]
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
Green Day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 12
Take That - 11
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9
Abba - 11 [+]
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[Shaun]

Oasis - 11 [+]
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 9 [-]
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 7 [-]
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
Green Day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 12
Take That - 11
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 10
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9
Abba - 11
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

[Ninastar]

Oasis - 11
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 9
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 6 [-]
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
Green Day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 12
Take That - 11
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 11 [+]
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9
Abba - 11
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 10

['Conor]

Oasis - 11
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 9
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 6
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
Green Day - 9
Blur - 10
The Beatles - 12
Take That - 10 (-1)
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 11
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9
Abba - 11
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 11 (+1)

[teabag.]

Oasis - 11
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 9
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 6
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 10
Green Day - 8 (-1)
Blur - 11 (+1)
The Beatles - 12
Take That - 10 (-1)
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 11
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9
Abba - 11
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 11 (+1)

hard between the beatles and blur, the beatles are probably the best just i seen blur and i had to put them!

[setanta]

It'll always be Radiohead for me, as I grew up with them. Having said that I do appreciate the legacy of groups like the Beatles, Velvet Underground, Smiths, Stooges, Talking Heads, Roxy Music, Pink Floyd among others..... many others actually. But yeah, I'd have to go for Radiohead since they're my band, so to speak, and I've been following them ever since they first formed.

[Sophii3x]

Oasis - 11
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 9
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 6
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 9 (-1)
Green Day - 8
Blur - 11
The Beatles - 13 (+1)
Take That - 10
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 11
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9
Abba - 11
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 11

[SurferJay]

Sorry but this list is atrocious. Can I add a few artists instead of just one? Otherwise I cant bring myself to join in..

[Niamh.]

Red Hot Chili Peppers +1
The Saturdays -1

[Twilight]

Sorry but this list is atrocious. Can I add a few artists instead of just one? Otherwise I cant bring myself to join in..Yeah

[SurferJay]

Sorry but this list is atrocious. Can I add a few artists instead of just one? Otherwise I cant bring myself to join in..Yeah

Thanks

[SurferJay]

Oasis - 11
Muse - 11
Red Hot Chili Peppers - 9
Metallica - 9
The Rolling Stones - 11
Paramore - 6
The Killers - 10
Fall Out Boy - 9
Green Day - 8
Blur - 11
The Beatles - 13
Take That - 8 (-1)
Pink Floyd - 10
U2 - 10
Queen - 11
R.E.M - 10
Nirvana - 10
Arctic Monkeys - 9
Abba - 11
The Carpenters - 10
The Temptations - 10
The Supremes - 10
The Cranberry's - 11
Guns n Roses - 10
Led Zeppelin - 10
Pearl Jam - 10
Sublime - 10
Radiohead - 11 (+1)
The Jimi Hendrix Experience - 10
Van Halen - 10
Rush - 10
The Eagles - 10
The Police - 10
The Who - 10
AC/DC - 10
Aerosmith - 10
Sex Pistols - 10
Coldplay - 10

Sorry if i added too many.