Cheryl is a cr*p mentor when she has not so good acts

[Tom]

I know sometimes the judges maybe should have put someone else through over someone they did put through, but how the hell did Cheryl get it so so wrong and put completely the wrong 3 through?! Duane could have won, a gap in the UK market for his sound but the other 3 will flop.

[Stephanie]

i like lloyd, but what the hell was she thinking putting rikki through, and as for joe.. i seriously want to smack him.
for me duane and daniel should have been there.

[Harry!]

Cheryl is the worst judge out of them all. She brings nothing to the show.

[30stone]

I thouht 2/3 were good.

Lloyd good desicion.
Joe Good voice one of the best out of them.
Rikki though id of put duane above him...

The daniel boy wasnt really versatile every song he sang the same.
Ethan was okay but for me lloyd was just slightly better.

[Tom]

I thouht 2/3 were good.

Lloyd good desicion.
Joe Good voice one of the best out of them.
Rikki though id of put duane above him...

The daniel boy wasnt really versatile every song he sang the same.
Ethan was okay but for me lloyd was just slightly better.

I genuinely think she could have won the show with Duane

[bronaaaa]

I would have changed Joe with Duane just

[Z]

Duane should have gotten through!

[30stone]

Joe is better than Rikki for sure.
Duane should have been in for him.
But then i think duane is overated anyway so..meh

[Jords]

Nah she brings a lot to the show still,
she just chucked out potential that is Ethan & Duane.
Last year she was my favourite,
but now, loving Dannii.

[Jords]

Joe is better than Rikki for sure.
Duane should have been in for him.
But then i think duane is overated anyway so..meh


In your sig, what about Miss Frank?
They are proper good.

[30stone]

Miss Frank are average for me.
To much attitude and only one of them is a purely good singer.

[Jords]

Miss Frank are average for me.
To much attitude and only one of them is a purely good singer.

Um the middle one has a bit of attitude,
but I think attitude can be quite good in a band.

I just hope the middle one(sorry dont know names lmao),
doesnt set the other 2 back, liek when speaking and that.
But I do find her the best singer, but all 3 good, who do you think is?

[Twilight]

I think the ones she put through should have been
Lloyd
Ethan
Duane
Tbh She sucks:nono:

[setanta]

I think she's on crazy pills or something. She basically chose three acts that are very similar to one another..... no variety whatsoever. Duane and Daniel were something a bit different to the norm. Rikki is terrible and Lloyd's voice isn't the best. Ridiculous stuff.

[KKBL]

It should of been Rikki,Duane and Ethan.

[xDramatick]

Shoulda been Lloyd, Ethan and Daniel F.

[30stone]

Miss Frank are average for me.
To much attitude and only one of them is a purely good singer.

Um the middle one has a bit of attitude,
but I think attitude can be quite good in a band.

I just hope the middle one(sorry dont know names lmao),
doesnt set the other 2 back, liek when speaking and that.
But I do find her the best singer, but all 3 good, who do you think is?

For me the one on the left is a ver very average singer.
The one in the middle is annoying but an okay singer, and i think the one on the right is the best singer.

[setanta]

Is the one on the right the one with the jabs? lol

[30stone]

Jabs ? what lol

but the one on the right has black hair one on the left has blonde-ish

[setanta]

Sorry, Irish expression for breasts lol. Hard to keep your eyes of those bad boys at times.
The one in the middle has the best voice but she'll be a pain in the arse, guaranteed.

[Tom4784]

Ethan should have been there, I think Lloyd and Rikki were terrible choices as they aren't that good, Lloyd will get by on his looks and Rikki will exit early.

[Jords]

It should of been Rikki,Duane and Ethan.

AGREED.

[Jords]

Miss Frank are average for me.
To much attitude and only one of them is a purely good singer.

Um the middle one has a bit of attitude,
but I think attitude can be quite good in a band.

I just hope the middle one(sorry dont know names lmao),
doesnt set the other 2 back, liek when speaking and that.
But I do find her the best singer, but all 3 good, who do you think is?

For me the one on the left is a ver very average singer.
The one in the middle is annoying but an okay singer, and i think the one on the right is the best singer.

Yeah the middle one is more rappy,
and the far right is a good singer,
the one on the left is the weakest but still good in the group.
They all have the same sort of style,
probz will make them go far (y)

[Tom]

Miss Frank = cheap Mis Teeq

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Miss Frank are average for me.
To much attitude and only one of them is a purely good singer.

Um the middle one has a bit of attitude,
but I think attitude can be quite good in a band.

I just hope the middle one(sorry dont know names lmao),
doesnt set the other 2 back, liek when speaking and that.
But I do find her the best singer, but all 3 good, who do you think is?

For me the one on the left is a ver very average singer.
The one in the middle is annoying but an okay singer, and i think the one on the right is the best singer.

Agree with this. The one on the right is the only semi decent singer, and the rappy one ruins everything by blurting out some rap in the middle. And together they sound average to me. I'm guessing since the judges put them together, people are buying the hype.

[Jords]

Miss Frank are average for me.
To much attitude and only one of them is a purely good singer.

Um the middle one has a bit of attitude,
but I think attitude can be quite good in a band.

I just hope the middle one(sorry dont know names lmao),
doesnt set the other 2 back, liek when speaking and that.
But I do find her the best singer, but all 3 good, who do you think is?

For me the one on the left is a ver very average singer.
The one in the middle is annoying but an okay singer, and i think the one on the right is the best singer.

Agree with this. The one on the right is the only semi decent singer, and the rappy one ruins everything by blurting out some rap in the middle. And together they sound average to me. I'm guessing since the judges put them together, people are buying the hype.

They are very good, just listen to them,
its not about buying the hype, thats igorance,
we can hear if something is good or not,
and they sound really good together.

[Beastie]

Joe and Lloyd are similar but Joe has the better and stronger voice. Lloyd should have not got through. I know Rikki is not that strong a vocalist but I do like him. Hes really likeable and I do hope he pulls it out of the bag on the live shows. Yeah Duane sounded really good. He could do more with his voice than just singing R and B songs!

[Chels]

I think Joe's cr*p.
Duane should have gone through instead of him.
I don't like Ethan or Rikki, and Daniel was too different for the show so i don't really care who the other one should be.

IMO - Lloyd, Duane & Whoever.

[setanta]

Should have been Joseph, Duane and Daniel... most variety there.

[Niamh.]

Ethan should have gotten through and Duane as well. that Lloyd only got through cos Cheryl fancies him :nono:

[setanta]

Ethan doesn't have a good enough voice really and the American accent wouldn't do him any favours with the vote. I can accept her putting one pretty boy in but dear lord, what is Rikki there for? Duane should be in his place.

[Niamh.]

I really liked Ethans voice actually. I liked the sound of his voice most out of all that groups, thats just down to personnal taste though I suppose!

[setanta]

I really liked Ethans voice actually. I liked the sound of his voice most out of all that groups, thats just down to personnal taste though I suppose!

Nah, he has no range honey and very weak on high notes. You're just oogling, admit it. lol.

And that face he makes on certain notes is nearly as maddening as Danyls facial tics. ha ha. God, I need help.

[Niamh.]

lol, alright, alright, I'll admit he was a nice bit of eye candy haha but I do like his voice!! And yeah Danyls facial expressions are just terrible!! I don't think he should have gotten through at all. His only good performance was his first one

[setanta]

He has potential though. I still think he's a prat, who turns on the tics and the waterworks at will - in love with himself but sure we'll see how he does next weekend. It'll be interesting anyway.

[Niamh.]

So, who's your favorite then Setanta?

[setanta]

Rachel. She's a natural and doesn't rely on any sob story to appeal to me. But I loved Rachel from last year so what do I know lol.

[Niamh.]

Oh God I hated Rachel from last year gggrrrr

I like Lucie, I think she's got a great voice. Me and my hubby were having an argument last night about Stacy, he reckons that there's something wrong with her but I just think she's thick lol!!

[setanta]

I think Stacey and Lucie have technically great voices, just like Alexandra and Laura last year, but if I were a producer and wanted someone with a raw energy and a unique tone to their voice I'd go for the two Rachels in a heartbeat.

They just have something that the others don't possess: unique, natural voices with character and energy. Close your eyes next time you hear them all sing and you'll hear it. Lucie is probably the more technically flawless of the two, but she doesn't have what Rachel has in her voice.

[Niamh.]

I like Rachel as well. I need to see them all on the live shows before I really decide on a favorite though.

[setanta]

Ah yeah, it's too early to pick one right now and the proof of their star qualities will really be in their live performances and in how the judges choose to market them.

I just think Rachel is a natural and I hope that Danni gives her the right song and doesn't balls it up like she did with the other Rachel last year. She's not as refined as the other two girls but she's got the tone and the coolness that they don't have. She could be amazing.

[Niamh.]

I really don't think it was Dannis' fault last year with Rachel. Rachel could really only sing Amy Winehouse. She was brutal at everything else even that week when she picked her own song- Dirty Diana -terrible!

[setanta]

That's true. Horrendous performance on that one. She doesn't have the range in her voice that you need for a show like X Factor but I'm telling you, she's a recording artist. Give her the right song and she'll own it.

[Niamh.]

Yeah, I mean if she just sang Amy Winehouse type songs she would have been brilliant. But I like when people can sing anything at all like Adam Lambert from American Idol. He was fantastic, I have no idea how he didn't win!

[setanta]

That's what the show is about I suppose but I always look for something unique or that blows my skirt up. Rachel did that with her raw talent. The show isn't designed for those kinda singers. I mean, I doubt somebody like Nina Simone would do well on it.... it's not that kinda show.

[Jords]

I agree with Setana with Rachel being unique,
she reminds me very much of Keri Hilson,
and I like her, and I think this is why Dannii picked her over Despina,
as Despina is very much your pop sweet girl, which we've had before.

I also agree with people who are saying Ethan and Duane should have got thro.
Duane's voice is so much better that Joe, cant stand Joe's voice 1 bit,
and I think Ethan has style, Llyod is too much like Oeghan, Jonas Brothers blah blah.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Shes a bloody fool! she could have won with Ethan, How could she choose that blonde boy? He cant sing!! she has no chance now!

[arsenalforever]

Shes a bloody fool! she could have won with Ethan, How could she choose that blonde boy? He cant sing!! she has no chance now!

she cares more about the attention she gets to sell her book and new solo career rather then her acts

[NettoSuperstar!]

Shes a bloody fool! she could have won with Ethan, How could she choose that blonde boy? He cant sing!! she has no chance now!

she cares more about the attention she gets to sell her book and new solo career rather then her acts

shes made a massive error! That blonde lad wont even make it to the halfway stage! I dont mind Cheryl as a person, theres far worse! She's just picked **** acts. I think Joseph and Rikky will do ok, they can sing for a start but shes a fool not to pick the American and Duane was different too

[setanta]

Ethan can't sing and he's American. Wouldn't garner as many votes as a little Welsh boy who actually has a better voice than him - that's not saying much though.

[arsenalforever]

Ethan can't sing and he's American. Wouldn't garner as many votes as a little Welsh boy who actually has a better voice than him - that's not saying much though.

who's got the best group of talent?

[setanta]

Danni by a country mile.

[Niamh.]

Ethan is lovely and he can sing!!:tongue:

[setanta]

Don't you start again. ha ha

[Niamh.]

hehehehehe

[arsenalforever]

Ethan is lovely and he can sing!!:tongue:

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?

[Niamh.]

Ethan is lovely and he can sing!!:tongue:

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick

[arsenalforever]

Ethan is lovely and he can sing!!:tongue:

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick

the yank wouldn't have won

[Niamh.]

Ethan is lovely and he can sing!!:tongue:

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick

the yank wouldn't have won

probably not but he was nice to look at and I liked his voice

[arsenalforever]

Ethan is lovely and he can sing!!:tongue:

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick

the yank wouldn't have won

probably not but he was nice to look at and I liked his voice

i would have won i have a fair pair of lungs on me Niamh:joker:

[Niamh.]

You should have entered so Steve!!

[arsenalforever]

You should have entered so Steve!!

i wouldn't be able to handle the female attention

i would have been ripped to shreds

[Shaun]

I only really liked Dannii's decisions, so I'm on her team this year :\

Ethan, Duane and my dead grandmother > Joe and Rikki.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Ethan can't sing and he's American. Wouldn't garner as many votes as a little Welsh boy who actually has a better voice than him - that's not saying much though.

are you kidding? The Welsh boy cant sing, he'll be shown up big time when it comes to the live shows, hes like bloody eggy from last year! Ethan could sing...and could have been top 5 at the very least. Blondie going nowhere trust meh

[setanta]

No I agree, they're both terrible. But at least Blondie could actually get some votes so I understand the reasoning behind it, even if I don't agree with the decision.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter:hugesmile:

[Fom]

I swear I am the only one who likes Joe? I reckon he will shock people.

[setanta]

I swear I am the only one who likes Joe? I reckon he will shock people.

I like Joe too.

[setanta]

Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter:hugesmile:

Honestly, he can't. Has no range and people wont warm to him like the other chap.

[Arneldo]

I disagree. I think she chose the right 3. Daniel was never gonna win, and I don't think Duane had the personality. The only other option was maybe Ethan over Joseph, but neither would have one anyway.

[setanta]

The three of them are just far too similar in style, that's my prob. And I'm not mad keen on Rikki or Lloyd's voice.

[Niamh.]

Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter:hugesmile:

I'll second that Netto :thumbs:

[Tom4784]

I'm not a huge fan of the 3 she chose, I fully believe there was a winner in Ethan as he was quite contemporary and I think he would have clicked with the audience. I don't think Lloyd or Rikki would have got through with any of the other judges (except perhaps with Louis).

[Tom]

I swear I am the only one who likes Joe? I reckon he will shock people.

He's too cheesy to be a pop star imo

[MarkWaldorf]

Joe<3

[LemonJam]

Duane is the best vocally and IMO there's a good gap in the market for someone like him.

Rikki I guess after studio work will sound good but this year he hasn't been great (last year I loved him) Joe uses too much vibrato and Lloyd is like Leon2.0

[Marc]

Cheryl has messed up big time this year. She should have put Duane through and maybe Ethan just for the looks - its a popularity contest at the end of the day anyway

[Niamh.]

Cheryl has messed up big time this year. She should have put Duane through and maybe Ethan just for the looks - its a popularity contest at the end of the day anyway

I liked Ethans voice as well though! I'm glad Cheryl won't win this year though.

[setanta]

I can't wait to see the head on her when they eventually get voted out. She's not as nice as some people believe.... has a scowldy look to her.

[Niamh.]

I can't wait to see the head on her when they eventually get voted out. She's not as nice as some people believe.... has a scowldy look to her.

I haven't forgotten that incident where she beat up that lady in the club! Atleast when Danni cries you can actually believe it cos she rarely does unlike Cheryl

[setanta]

I can't wait to see the head on her when they eventually get voted out. She's not as nice as some people believe.... has a scowldy look to her.

I haven't forgotten that incident where she beat up that lady in the club! Atleast when Danni cries you can actually believe it cos she rarely does unlike Cheryl

Yeah, Cheryl's behaviour on the show just seems forced to me at this stage. I woudn't trust her as far as I could throw her. Wouldn't throw her outta bed though!

[Niamh.]

lol, no, she's a gorgeous girl alright but I find her very false

[setanta]

Yep, same. She just has that look about her. I'd say Danni isn't so bad to be fair to her.

[Jords]

Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter:hugesmile:

Honestly, he can't. Has no range and people wont warm to him like the other chap.

Who are you to say he cant sing?
And aload of my friends who are girls are gutted Ethan aint through, only some care about LLyod - they kinda started liking him now Ethan is out. So yes, girls warmed to him, and as a lad, I thought his voice was decent, prefer his over Llyod and Joe anyway.

[Niamh.]

I quite like Danni actually, I think she seems pretty genuine. Just because she doesn't blub every 2 seconds people think she's cold!

[setanta]

Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter:hugesmile:

Honestly, he can't. Has no range and people wont warm to him like the other chap.

Who are you to say he cant sing?
And aload of my friends who are girls are gutted Ethan aint through, only some care about LLyod - they kinda started liking him now Ethan is out. So yes, girls warmed to him, and as a lad, I thought his voice was decent, prefer his over Llyod and Joe anyway.

It's decent but it's nothing special really. My brothers a singer and he said it himself. Plus he looks like he has a bit of an attitude and I guarantee you that the very fact he's American would have lost him votes.

[Jords]

Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter:hugesmile:

Honestly, he can't. Has no range and people wont warm to him like the other chap.

Who are you to say he cant sing?
And aload of my friends who are girls are gutted Ethan aint through, only some care about LLyod - they kinda started liking him now Ethan is out. So yes, girls warmed to him, and as a lad, I thought his voice was decent, prefer his over Llyod and Joe anyway.

It's decent but it's nothing special really. My brothers a singer and he said it himself. Plus he looks like he has a bit of an attitude and I guarantee you that the very fact he's American would have lost him votes.

At the end of the day, its not about if your English, Scottish, Welsh, Irish or in this case American. I disagree when a judge says, ahh hell have wales supporting him. No! You support the best, not where ya from. If he wasnt put thro becuz hes american, and he 'might' not get votes becuz of that, I still think he should be put on, it can still kick start a career for him.

And good luck with your brother in singing (:
But he can sing, he might not be the best,
but better than Joe and Llyod,
he has more passion n personality.

Anyway, Stacey, Miss Frank, Lucie, Jamie, Rikki Rachel, ftw!

[setanta]

Thanks, he's fairly good and writes his own stuff. Show's promise.
I honestly don't think Ethan's voice was good enough.... he reminds me of the fella a few years back that Simon said was like a little puppy dog, remember? Has the looks but not a strong enough voice. And yes, nationality plays a huge part in their decisions.

Lloyd and Rikki aren't great in my opinion.... I would have opted for Duane and Daniel for a bit of variety. Joseph will surprise alot of people, guarantee you that.