Did anyone else feel bad for Rachel?

[sweety_samy9]

I was likee-- poor rachel.
she was one of the best yesterday.
but, she was unfortunately put first, so people forgot her.
i love her though!
rachel ftw

:)

[30stone]

Not really.

I think.

John & Edward - Rikki - Lloyd - Rachel
Were the worst 4.

[Twilight]

Nope she was bad

[setanta]

I felt really sorry for her. No way she should have been in the bottom 2. Crazy stuff but at least she survived, no thanks to Simon and his gameplaying. She'll be great next week.

[King Gizzard]

Very sorry for her

On first, and a difficult song

She ll do bettter next week

[Stacey.]

no way did i feel sorry for her!
john and edward are by far the best!
anyone can see that! :)

[arsenalforever]

Bad Song for her

i doubt she can get back after that

[Patrick]

No Way!

I loved all of them, but now I want Rachel out!

No one gets rid of KR And gets away with it!

[Christina]

Yes! Omg she should of been given a better song choice.. something more soulful to fit her voice!

[Z]

Such a shame, she was not worthy of being in the bottom two, I think it was just down to being on first. She'll be fine for next week, but everyone knows if you've been in the bottom two, you're not going to win...

[arsenalforever]

Yes! Omg she should of been given a better song choice.. something more soulful to fit her voice!

I agree a old Rnb or soul number for her would have beengreat

[MiuMiu]

She's such a dissapointment.
I thought she'd be much better.
I was like, Oh, a new edgier Alexandra or a Rihann type who can sing AND dance.
But nah....
She deserved to be in the bottom in my head because she was the one who disappointed my most.

[setanta]

She's such a dissapointment.
I thought she'd be much better.
I was like, Oh, a new edgier Alexandra or a Rihann type who can sing AND dance.
But nah....
She deserved to be in the bottom in my head because she was the one who disappointed my most.

Wrong baby, wrong. lol. She was given a difficult song which required more work than just singing and she was well outside of her comfort zone with it. Think she deserves more credit because I doubt any of the other girls could have pulled it off, particularly on the opening night and the first song of the series.

There were 5 or 6 acts that were far inferior to her performance which although flawed was at least something different and outside of the norm for the girls. Wait until next week when it's Diva night... have a feeling she'll blow them all out of the water.

[MiuMiu]

Wrong baby, wrong. lol. She was given a difficult song which required more work than just singing and she was well outside of her comfort zone with it. Think she deserves more credit because I doubt any of the other girls could have pulled it off, particularly on the opening night and the first song of the series.

There were 5 or 6 acts that were far inferior to her performance which although flawed was at least something different and outside of the norm for the girls. Wait until next week when it's Diva night... have a feeling she'll blow them all out of the water.

Don't get me wrong.
I like her.
But when Dannii put her through I said "That's my favourite, that's the winner!"
And then she came out and did ****.
Yes I know she was the 1st one and that it was the 1st night of the live shows, but she placed it all on herself I rekon. Tried to do too much.
Brian siad that that young Welsh fella's preformance had to be considerably simplified and scaled down on the xtra factor on saturday night because he wasn't able for it on the first night.
Why didn't they do that with Rachael?
It could've been more simple and less gimicky and way more successful.
Like Alexandra the way she had a load of guys just dancing around her with her in the front looking stunnig and dancing away too.

I don't know. Her voice wasn't that strong when she sang for survival tonight either.
I just thought he was better.
But I hope you're right and she proves me wrong cuz I know she's got the fierce in her, and she's completley stunning too.
:spin:

[setanta]

Don't get me wrong.
I like her.
But when Dannii put her through I said "That's my favourite, that's the winner!"
And then she came out and did ****.
Yes I know she was the 1st one and that it was the 1st night of the live shows, but she placed it all on herself I rekon. Tried to do too much.
Brian siad that that young Welsh fella's preformance had to be considerably simplified and scaled down on the xtra factor on saturday night because he wasn't able for it on the first night.
Why didn't they do that with Rachael?
It could've been more simple and less gimicky and way more successful.
Like Alexandra the way she had a load of guys just dancing around her with her in the front looking stunnig and dancing away too.

I don't know. Her voice wasn't that strong when she sang for survival tonight either.
I just thought he was better.
But I hope you're right and she proves me wrong cuz I know she's got the fierce in her, and she's completley stunning too.
:spin:

Her voice was great in her survival song, just a little wobbly because, like me, she was probably in shock that she was in the bottom two. There were at least 5 other acts who deserved to be down there with Kandy Rain and I honestly thought she did rather well with Robbie's song, considering how bad a choice it was for her. She didn't play it safe like the other two girls.

As for the singing and dancing, Alexandra was miming and Rachel obviously wasn't allowed to this.

[MiuMiu]

Her voice was great in her survival song, just a little wobbly because, like me, she was probably in shock that she was in the bottom two. There were at least 5 other acts who deserved to be down there with Kandy Rain and I honestly thought she did rather well with Robbie's song, considering how bad a choice it was for her. She didn't play it safe like the other two girls.

As for the singing and dancing, Alexandra was miming and Rachel obviously wasn't allowed to this.

She was when it came time for the group preformnce lol!:xyxwave:
And I don't think Alexandra was miming.
It sounded real to me.
Maybe she pre-recorded it live beforehand tho?
:conf:

[setanta]

Nah, she was miming. Can't have a flawless sound like that when you're running around all over the place and hardly able to breath afterwards.

[MiuMiu]

^Beyonce does it.....
:conf2:

[bettiepage]

No Way!

I loved all of them, but now I want Rachel out!

No one gets rid of KR And gets away with it!

....Rachel didn't get rid of Kandy Rain, the public did :conf:

[setanta]

^Beyonce does it.....
:conf2:

What are you talking about?

[xDramatick]

I warmed to Rachel, I thought both her performances at the weekend were really good.

Unfortunately, me being the petty person I am, and her being in the bottom with Kandy Rain, has made me dislike her a tad. KR should've stayed <3
Rachel reminds me a lot of Rihanna though.

[MattBlake]

....Rachel didn't get rid of Kandy Rain, the public did :conf:

that's what i've been saying!
silly KR fans think rachel got rid of them =S

RACHEL OR RIKKI FTW

[NettoSuperstar!]

Yeh, what a **** song for her to be given, didnt suit her at all and didnt show off her talent in anyway! I thought she might be up though

[Beastie]

I didnt feel bad for her.. but Lloyd and Joe deserved to be in the bottom 2 rather than Rachel.

[arsenalforever]

Thebeast hello

she was given a bad song to sing which i felt for her when she was singing

[Beastie]

Thebeast hello

she was given a bad song to sing which i felt for her when she was singing

hey arsenal! I have not been messaging here a lot the past few days. Yeah Rachel was given a bad song for her. When she sung the song for fighting for her survival she sounded amazing! Well it is the public to blame! I only voted once... for john and edward lol

[arsenalforever]

hey arsenal! I have not been messaging here a lot the past few days. Yeah Rachel was given a bad song for her. When she sung the song for fighting for her survival she sounded amazing! Well it is the public to blame! I only voted once... for john and edward lol

those two deserve shooting:joker:

she's a soul singer don't give her a shitty Robbie song:joker:

missed you on here hope you get on here more often

[Beastie]

those two deserve shooting:joker:

she's a soul singer don't give her a shitty Robbie song:joker:

missed you on here hope you get on here more often


shooting? that is too bloody cruel arsenal!! Well you need to blame danni minogue for the **** song choice for her (not a **** song, but just a **** choice for her) lol.

yeah I have been at work all week and well, I dont know, I miss the old forum!

Who do you want to win the x factor?

[MarkWaldorf]

It's like Simon said before, in this final 12 you need to be someone who can stand out (especially above big favourites like Stacey, Danyl, Lucie etc) and unfortunately she doesn't. I honestly can't see her lasting much longer. She'll probably be safe this week because she was in the bottom two last week.

[arsenalforever]

shooting? that is too bloody cruel arsenal!! Well you need to blame danni minogue for the **** song choice for her (not a **** song, but just a **** choice for her) lol.

yeah I have been at work all week and well, I dont know, I miss the old forum!

Who do you want to win the x factor?


i love to see Jaime win it
but it be someone who's a guy and who's good looking

[Beastie]

i love to see Jaime win it
but it be someone who's a guy and who's good looking

Lol yeah Jamie is in my top 3! He would be great!

I think it is going to be a close call.

[arsenalforever]

Lol yeah Jamie is in my top 3! He would be great!

I think it is going to be a close call.

at the end of the day sadly it comes down to the sob story and looks
talent comes third in the x factor

[Braden]

she was quite bad
but she did look genuinly upset

[arsenalforever]

she was quite bad
but she did look genuinly upset

cause she was given a awful song which wasn't the type of song for her to sing:joker:

[setanta]

she was quite bad
but she did look genuinly upset

She wasn't that bad in comparison to some of the others who performed last weekend; the only problem for her was that the song didn't suit her. Still gave it a fair old go and I doubt that any of the other girls could have matched her with it.

[Beastie]

I think.. well no I dont think Rachel thinks she will win.. but no one has ever won whos been in the bottom 2.. JLS came 2nd.. suppose it could possibly happen!

[Beastie]

at the end of the day sadly it comes down to the sob story and looks
talent comes third in the x factor

I dont think there was many sob stories last year.. well a bit with daniel evans but no COMIC act wins.. although I hope John and Edward pull it out of the bag :D they are getting better with singing!

[setanta]

I dont think there was many sob stories last year.. well a bit with daniel evans but no COMIC act wins.. although I hope John and Edward pull it out of the bag :D they are getting better with singing!

You're having a laugh right? Did you hear that they were going to the other contestants during the week and asking them how you harmonise lol. They don't know how to sing and haven't got a note in their head between them.