**The X Factor** 2nd Live Show Discussion Show (17/10/09)

[arsenalforever]

Olly has been leagues above lucie and Miss frank so far

going to be hard to top his performance

Not really andy he was a great stage performer a decent singer

[Alf]

Joe time
why dont you just give him 10/10 now?
you know your gonna

[King Gizzard]

how shalow some people are ,its just sad..

exactly

[30stone]

Nothing less than id expext from the likes of you andy.

Steve shh.
I changed it because i know its flawed because of the start, and it has to be amazing to be 9 so i put it down to 8.

[Novo]

Not really andy he was a great stage performer a decent singer

He is great at everything he is the full package

[alchemists1]

I'm trying to imagine what the 2 twats can sing tonight?
Whateva it is I think they will get showing up tonight.

[arsenalforever]

Simon's the star tongiht so far

[Princess]

I thought Olly was good but I don't get the fuss about him. He's good,not amazing

Miss Frank did alright,they were quite shaky though.

[Tom]

I'm trying to imagine what the 2 twats can sing tonight?
Whateva it is I think they will get showing up tonight.

oops i did it again

[arsenalforever]

He is great at everything he is the full package

i don't see it but i see why you like him

[30stone]

Dont think anyone has given heir best performance this week..

Thinking of it i prefered lucie olly and miss franks songs last week to this.

[Wildcat!]

Alexandra's Toxic = most overrated performance ever

Completely agree with that. I thought it was awful, all about the visulas. The vocals were horrid. And Imo, hit me baby one more time by JLS was one of the most under rated performances that day.

[King Gizzard]

Olly isnt the best singer but he is the new robbie williams

amazing performer

[Princess]

Olly isnt the best singer but he is the new robbing williams

amazing performer

Maybe that's why I don't see the fuss considering I hate Robbie.

[30stone]

how shalow some people are ,its just sad..

lol.

[lily.]

JLS were immense last year.

[Tom]

I'm getting bored of Olly now

A bit like Diana, at first he was something different but that something different just turns into being a one trick pony

[MarkWaldorf]

omg so excited

[arsenalforever]

i've yet to see a all round great performer
good but not great

[\PJ/]

Yer becase you can hate someone you don't know TUT!

[alchemists1]

oops i did it again

Are you serious? I thou it was a sorta diva's night?

[Tom]

JLS were immense last year.

Last year was all bout Ruth :dance:

Best contestant ever methinks

[King Gizzard]

time for me to switch off for a bit i think.

[30stone]

Olly would have a full package if he could sing slightly better.

Performs well gets the crowd going but his voice, lacks somthing to be desired.

[King Gizzard]

ohh i thought it was going to be joe lol.

[Novo]

Olly would have a full package if he could sing slightly better.

Performs well gets the crowd going but his voice, lacks somthing to be desired.

His Voice is amazing...

Much better singing performance then Lucie tonight

[alchemists1]

Diana Vickers should have won last year,if she was there this year she would walk it.

[Wildcat!]

Are you serious? I thou it was a sorta diva's night?

I know. DOnt see how Britney qualifies for Diva night. DIva's got a big voice, and can actually sing live.

[arsenalforever]

this could be Rachel's night
a diva song and a proper song for her

[30stone]

i've yet to see a all round great performer
good but not great



Agreed.

Though Rachels never going to give more than 8/10 i just dont think shes as good as people make out.

[arsenalforever]

His Voice is amazing...

Much better singing performance then Lucie tonight

Agree Lucie blew it tonight

[lily.]

Mark, why aren't u using yer epic joe banner?

[Locke.]

Rachel singign If I Were a Boy.

This should be great

[Tom]

Rachel falls a lot

[MarkWaldorf]

Mark, why aren't u using yer epic joe banner?

i made it for no real reason :p

omg wtf, i thought joe was next?

[arsenalforever]

Rachel need to blow the roof of it

[Wildcat!]

Rachel falls a lot

:laugh:

[30stone]

His Voice is amazing...

Much better singing performance then Lucie tonight

His voice is okay but not great he was being drowned out more than lucie was with the backing, funny you never picked up on that.

And his voice wasn't as good i don't think.

[lily.]

Ye should use it Mark.. it's too good to not use.

[arsenalforever]

if she blows this she could be gone tomorrow

[lily.]

Her haircut is distracting me..

[30stone]

Im not a fan of this song, not a fan of her, and think shes already shakey...

Seems like everyone has been shakey at the start.

Dont like her voice at all. Just doesnt sound... appealing.

[arsenalforever]

Her haircut is distracting me..

only women say these things:joker:

[alchemists1]

I know. DOnt see how Britney qualifies for Diva night. DIva's got a big voice, and can actually sing live.

True.
As much as I like Britney she aint a diva,and to be honest there's millions of tunes they could have picked from a diva,but I suppose those 2 twats cant actually sing so they give them tunes that are more about dancing and a catchy chorus.

[Wildcat!]

I think she is over rated. She is just not very good.

[arsenalforever]

Im not a fan of this song, not a fan of her, and think shes already shakey...

Seems like everyone has been shakey at the start.

Dont like her voice at all. Just doesnt sound... appealing.

damn Ben its only 20 seconds gone:joker:

[lily.]

only women say these things:joker:

Grace Jones much though... damn.

[King Gizzard]

She sounds very very very good

[andyman]

She should be safe this week.

7/10

[LemonJam]

Woahhhhhhhh

[Adamw92]

That was...ouch - 5/10

[arsenalforever]

She should be safe this week.

7/10

agree not mind blowing but safe

[King Gizzard]

8.9/10

[lily.]

I hated that.

[Wildcat!]

She sounds very very very good



What/???
Sh eis gonna get the pity comments, but to me, 5/10

[alchemists1]

Not bad nothing special but not the worst that will be heard tonight.

[Shaun]

looove.
7.5/10.

L GET ONLINE.

[bronaaaa]

I didn't like it =S

[30stone]

Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Rachel 6/10

[Alf]

forgetful
i forgotten already

[lily.]

I am online Shaun!

[Novo]

Rachel 6/10 it was alright

[arsenalforever]

Very average performances tonight so far
Olly was a great perfomer on stage

[Locke.]

Rachel - 8/10 [Was expecting better with this song really but she showed she had a good voice and is the best of the night so far IMO]
Olly - 7/10
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10

[Wildcat!]

Lili, her and Dannii got the same haircut :laugh:

[lily.]

Lili, her and Dannii got the same haircut :laugh:


Yah, it's hideous! LoL

[arsenalforever]

Joe is next isn't he

[MarkWaldorf]

Omfg

[Wildcat!]

She is trying to do an ALex!! I need to get you to love me, just like Alex saifd last year.

[alchemists1]

None of them realize that they aint karoeke singers,they need to sing a song in there own voice and style rather than try and mimic whose song it is.

[King Gizzard]

Ohh heres my cue to switch off for a bit. :)

[30stone]

YEah her haircut is awful lol.

I just am never drawn to her voice, like the other 2 girls.


Hope Danyl is better this week.

[Novo]

Olly 100000000/10
Lucie 6/10
Rachel 6/10
Miss frank 5/10

[Wildcat!]

I am gonna be biased, so I wont comment on Joe.

[arsenalforever]

i hate this guy already:joker:
too much pretyy boy and boring

[Wildcat!]

Omfg

:laugh:

[MassiveTruck]

Rachel was pants.

Bye Bye Rachel!!

[30stone]

LOL at "i was a bit podgy back then"

LOLOL well hes made me laugh.

[arsenalforever]

the teenie's will love him

[30stone]

Rachel was pants.

Bye Bye Rachel!!

:thumbs:

[Tom]

Joe's teeth need fixing, they annoy me, so does he

[King Gizzard]

OHHH I don't like it

[/ben]


:laugh:

[Novo]

He looks about 11

[30stone]

OHHH I don't like it

[/ben]


:laugh:



I wait until at least the first 5 - 6 lines are sang.

[MarkWaldorf]

Omg

[bronaaaa]

=o he looks so young

[\PJ/]

Oh Joe must be getting help he looks less disabled this week.

[arsenalforever]

:sleep: god its **** to my ears

[Tom]

He's too cheesy and his vibrato is v annoying

[King Gizzard]

He could rival Miley Cyrus for the ''most teeth in mouth'' award lol

[arsenalforever]

But he's playing it safe for me

[Novo]

Oh christ

[GypsyGoth]

Ohh heres my cue to switch off for a bit. :)

:joker:

[Tom]

Is he gay?

[andyman]

Cheesey.. 5/10

[arsenalforever]

Is he gay?

got to be

[alchemists1]

He will be safe even if he stumbles and forgets his words,get the twennies vote and no matter what you do you will survive.

[Alf]

easily the best performer so far by a country mile
there again thats not hard

[Wildcat!]

LIke Mark says!! OMG!! :laugh:

[GypsyGoth]

He is getting cuter as the weeks go by.

[Adamw92]

i'd say about 7/10
Simon was singing along! :O

[Tom]

That was shite. Worst of the night so far, 2/10.

[King Gizzard]

Vibrato Boy!

[andyman]

Feel sick after that.

[Wildcat!]

I give him a 7/10. Not as good as last week, but good.

[Locke.]

Rachel - 8/10
Olly - 7/10
Joe - 6/10 [Was ok... expected more after last week.]
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10

[arsenalforever]

7/10 a mid table contestant who will make it far casue the teenie's will love him

[\PJ/]

Ew he is making me a bit sick.

[Wildcat!]

Simon says, note perfect.

[arsenalforever]

Simon likes him i'm shocked:(

[Novo]

He is up there with Olly now

Olly 1000000/10
Joe 7/10
Lucie 6/10
Rachel 6/10
Miss frank 5/10

[LemonJam]

He was note perfect, he's just nothing special IMO.

[King Gizzard]

too much oOoOooOOoOoOo in his voice

[arsenalforever]

again not blown away by the last two

[Wildcat!]

Yeah, Clive Davis, Whitney houston, SImon says its almost perfect. BUt you lot know better I guess. :laugh:

[arsenalforever]

Yeah, Clive Davis, Whitney houston, SImon says its almost perfect. BUt you lot know better I guess. :laugh:

yep we do

[30stone]

Pretty good vocals.
I liked the song + how he sang it ( that always helps on x factor for me ) if i dont know or dont like the song then generally its not guna get that good a rating from me.

Slightly boring but..

Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Rachel 5.5/10

[Wildcat!]

Barrichello on pole!!! Yes!!!!!

[arsenalforever]

i'm hoping we will get a 10/10 performance tonight

we're a picky lot:joker:

[Chantel]

i'm hoping we will get a 10/10 performance tonight

we're a picky lot:joker:

we will :)

[King Gizzard]

2012 looks scary but absolutely amazing

[Locke.]

i'm hoping we will get a 10/10 performance tonight

we're a picky lot:joker:

Jamie will give you your 10/10 :thumbs:

[arsenalforever]

we will :)

Jamie needs to rock it bad:joker:

[Princess]

Joe was brilliant!!!! LOL at Simon singing along! Rachel was alright too,but it was too similar.

:O At Joe's 16 year old video!

[30stone]

We wont unless stacy Danyl or Jamie really perform and really work the crowd.

[MarkWaldorf]

JOE WAS AMAZING omg

[arsenalforever]

Jamie will give you your 10/10 :thumbs:

I'm hoping David he's the one i like the most

[\PJ/]

Wipe the cum up markus.

[King Gizzard]

Jamie will no doubt deliver a 5/10

[Chantel]

I'm hoping David he's the one i like the most
Him or Danyl :thumbs:

[arsenalforever]

JOE WAS AMAZING omg

Are you a fan of his?:joker:

[Novo]

Joe is 2nd best to Olly so far he will be safe tomorrow

Miss frank will be in the bottom two from what we have seen so far

[arsenalforever]

Him or Danyl :thumbs:

for you Chantel i will like him:joker:

[andyman]

Yeah, Clive Davis, Whitney houston, SImon says its almost perfect. BUt you lot know better I guess. :laugh:C'mon Frank Butcher and that other skank bint will always say nice things..

Simon is playing mind games with him :thumbs:

[Chantel]

for you Chantel i will like him:joker:

Glad to hear :thumbs:

[30stone]

Miss frank will be in the bottom two from what we have seen so far



Hopefully Rachel too.

[arsenalforever]

Glad to hear :thumbs:

i'm not impressed yet

[lily.]

I like Joe..

He's pretty.. :D

[Wildcat!]

C'mon Frank Butcher and that other skank bint will always say nice things..

Simon is playing mind games with him :thumbs:

:laugh: :laugh:

[arsenalforever]

here we go he should blow the roof of the place
he hasn't to try too hard really

[Wildcat!]

I like Joe..

He's pretty.. :D

:shocked::shocked::hugesmile:

[andyman]

This guy can sing!

[30stone]

I am hoping hes not going to be stupid with the stupid thing he does with his voice i dont understand, he can sing amazingly and he does that stupid thing..

Hope he delivers toinght.

[Chantel]

This guy can sing!

He's amazing :thumbs:

[King Gizzard]

danyl is just not likeable..as one of the judges said

[Novo]

Hopefully Rachel too.

No rachel was alright tonight just heard her song again preffered it the second time i heard it

[30stone]

I find him likeable.

[arsenalforever]

This guy can sing!

Him and Jamis are the only two who've impressed me so far

[lily.]

:shocked::shocked::hugesmile:


What? He's legal.. he's 18.. haha

[Wildcat!]

These people are courageous, they are all doing whitney houston

[Adamw92]

danyl is just not likeable..as one of the judges said

I agree, I just find him...meh, personally I think he shouts, doesnt sing

[lily.]

These people are courageous, they are all doing whitney houston

fnar.

[arsenalforever]

a new song as wel
cheryl is nervous cause she knows he's great

[30stone]

I cant explain what he does with his voice but i dont like it lol.

[Wildcat!]

What? He's legal.. he's 18.. haha

Oh I know, I just didnt think you were like the tweenies!! Oh I like him, he is so cute. :laugh:

[arsenalforever]

I cant explain what he does with his voice but i dont like it lol.

he's not female lol

[MarkWaldorf]

lol vocally Joe is one of the best there, definitely not the worst so far. One of the best tonight.

[Chantel]

I can hardly hear him :(

[Wildcat!]

I cant explain what he does with his voice but i dont like it lol.


ITs what he does with his mouth that irritates me! :laugh:

[Stacey.]

danyls amazinggggggggggggggggggggg

[lily.]

Oh I know, I just didnt think you were like the tweenies!! Oh I like him, he is so cute. :laugh:


ahhhhahahahahahaha... tweenies.. oh god.. I've never been so insulted .. -feigns offence-

[\PJ/]

Dick on stage.

[Wildcat!]

My problem with this guy, is I cant understand what he says!! EVER!!

[arsenalforever]

lol vocally Joe is one of the best there, definitely not the worst so far. One of the best tonight.

that was until Daryl came on Mark:joker:

[Stacey.]

<3 you dan.

[lily.]

My problem with this guy, is I cant understand what he says!! EVER!!

I thought it was just me.. haha.. it's like Diana from last year lol

[alchemists1]

He sorta has an advantage cause nobody has heard the Whitney version of this song so he can make it his own rather than a **** copy of someone elses tune.

[\PJ/]

I love the way everone in here thinks they are Simon Cowell.

[Adamw92]

I just didn't like that... but i'll give him 6.5/10

[arsenalforever]

Best performance tonight by far 9/10 for me

[Wildcat!]

Who can honestly tell me, they understood a word of that perormance????

[Alf]

a different class all together

[30stone]

he's not female lol



I like olly jamie and danyl.
I just dont like how he sings sometimes.

As for his performance .. i wasn't listening to much.. i must have got a bit bored.. lol

[Novo]

Simons acts are pissing over the rest of them so far

[arsenalforever]

I just didn't like that... but i'll give him 6.5/10

From a lucie and miss frank supporter:joker:

[lily.]

I love the way everone in here thinks they are Simon Cowell.


I'm better than Simon.. :P

[MarkWaldorf]

I hate his tone.

[Wildcat!]

I thought it was just me.. haha.. it's like Diana from last year lol

Exactly.

[Adamw92]

From a lucie and miss frank supporter:joker:


Yeah...so?

[Locke.]

Danyl - 9/10 [Haven't liked him at all all the way through but that really was a amazing performance]
Rachel - 8/10
Olly - 7/10
Joe - 6/10
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10

[King Gizzard]

I don't see what was so special about that?

[30stone]

Danyl 8/10
Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Rachel 5.5

[arsenalforever]

Yeah...so?

well he pissed over them with that performance:joker:

[Chantel]

9/10
he would have got 10 but i couldnt hear him at the begining :(

[GypsyGoth]

Didn't like the song but he sang well.

[LemonJam]

WinWinWin.com

[\PJ/]

Im going of thw show tonight it's so boring.

[King Gizzard]

I'd give that 6.9 personally..just missed out on getting a 7.

[Wildcat!]

Lloyd:sleep::sleep::sleep::sleep::sleep:

[arsenalforever]

I hate his tone.

thats the X factor Mark your joe will never reach that greatness

[30stone]

Lloyd doing leona?!?!?!?

If its not forgive me... then hes a fail already from me..

As his voice isnt that good and he wont be able to do a big powerful song.

[Novo]

Olly 1000000/10
Danyl 8/10
Joe 7/10
Lucie 6/10
Rachel 6/10
Miss frank 5/10

[Chantel]

Lloyd:sleep::sleep::sleep::sleep::sleep:

First thing we agree on tonight :joker:

[Adamw92]

Lloyd next...the joy! :sleep:

[\PJ/]

LOL Nathan.

[Tom]

Noone has been that good so far, just holding out for Stacey now :(

Maybe a bit of comedy value in Lloyd doing Leona?

[arsenalforever]

was that the guy given ten tries in the audition?

[Adamw92]

well he pissed over them with that performance:joker:

In your opinion yes, I'm not critising yours, I have my opinion, you have yours

[alchemists1]

To be honest there hasnt been a real good performence yet tonight,I liked Lucie but still nothing real special.

[arsenalforever]

one great perfromance, one good one and a lot of average hopefully it get better

[Wildcat!]

Lucie 7/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Olly 6/10
Rachel 5/10
Joe 7/10
Danyl 6/10

[Princess]

I don't think he should have sang a song no one has heard,how are we supposed to know if it's any good,lol! I think he did brill for what he had though!

[GypsyGoth]

was that the guy given ten tries in the audition?

Yea I think he was allowed a second go after he messed his first song.

[Stephanie]

lloyd is gonna be so crap doing leona.

[MiuMiu]

I must be on a different planet because I thought Danyl was AWFUL!

And that Miss Frank were really good, big improvement.

Hope Rachael goes, she's such a personal dissapointment because I thought she was good enough to win.
:(

[Chantel]

Lucie 6/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Olly 9/10
Rachel 5/10
Joe 7/10
Danyl 9/10

[arsenalforever]

In your opinion yes, I'm not critising yours, I have my opinion, you have yours

Adam you know its the truth but i'm joking with you:joker:

[Tom]

Danyl wasn't even that good

[GypsyGoth]

I don't think he should have sang a song no one has heard,how are we supposed to know if it's any good,lol! I think he did brill for what he had though!

Good point.

[30stone]

Jamie and Stacy need to perform..

[arsenalforever]

Lucie 6/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Olly 9/10
Rachel 5/10
Joe 7/10
Danyl 9/10

Agree :)

[Alf]

I must be on a different planet because I thought Danyl was AWFUL!

And that Miss Frank were really good, big improvement.

Hope Rachael goes, she's such a personal dissapointment because I thought she was good enough to win.
:(
yeah i think you must be, or tone deaf

[arsenalforever]

Jamie and Stacy need to perform..

Jamie will need a rocky strong i think

[MiuMiu]

We had no basis for comparison with that Danyl song.
I couldn't even understand what he was singing.
Once again, I though it was ****!

[andyman]

lol vocally Joe is one of the best there, definitely not the worst so far. One of the best tonight.Good Vocally? Well below Danyl but Joe needs a song to truely test him otherwise he is just another male stage act like 1000s of others in the biz.

His songs have been safe and that will keep him in the show.

[*mazedsalv**]

So far:

Lucie- 8/10
Olly- 7/10
Miss Frank- 6/10
Rachel- 7/10
Joe- 8/10
Danyl- 6.5/10

[arsenalforever]

Lois loved him no surprise he loves the young boys

[alchemists1]

I thou he was poor last week.

[30stone]

Good point.



I havent heard a lot of songs they sing, well last year i didnt.


But you still judge on how they sang it and how good their voice was you just dont have another version to compare it to.


Lloyd will have to do forgive me otherwise it will be so meh.

[Chantel]

I thou he was poor last week.
Me 2

[Adamw92]

Car crash entering the room any second now....

[Tom]

The Welsh accent is shocking

[arsenalforever]

we could Have Marvin gaye on stage and you lot would hate him:joker:

[Tom]

Car crash or motorway pile up? Place your bets now.

[Wildcat!]

Whitney "you know what am sayin'"

[GypsyGoth]

I havent heard a lot of songs they sing, well last year i didnt.


But you still judge on how they sang it and how good their voice was you just dont have another version to compare it to.


Lloyd will have to do forgive me otherwise it will be so meh.

I feel sorry for Lloyd, he can't sing but at least he looks good :hugesmile:

[30stone]

Whats he doing?

[Wildcat!]

Car crash or motorway pile up? Place your bets now.

:joker:

[arsenalforever]

I feel sorry for Lloyd, he can't sing but at least he looks good :hugesmile:

that speaks a lot in why x factor fails most years

[30stone]

Started surprisingly okay... :shocked:

[Novo]

****

[andyman]

We had no basis for comparison with that Danyl song.
I couldn't even understand what he was singing.
Once again, I though it was ****!Tip.. Get the ear wax sorted.

[arsenalforever]

****

agree

[GypsyGoth]

that speaks a lot in why x factor fails most years

Ooo there should be a cute factor show :laugh:

[Adamw92]

awful. awful. awful!

[30stone]

Hes adapted it so he doesnt have to sing the big notes, smart move, i think hes okayy

[lily.]

-goes for a shower-

[Wildcat!]

OK, I am actually liking this a bit1!

[Novo]

Simon is going to get him :joker:

[Chantel]

awful. awful. awful!
this.

[Tom]

Simon's face says it all

[Stephanie]

cheryl is so stupid.

[Novo]

0.5/10

[Chantel]

Simon is going to get him :joker:

My mum just said that :joker:

[arsenalforever]

Lucie has been saved from the worst performance this week but sadly this guy will get the teenis votes

[alchemists1]

He is not bad better than I expected from him.

[30stone]

Backing singers doing the high notes...

[Tom]

0.5/10

thats being generous

[Adamw92]

1/10

[Wildcat!]

DONT be biased guys, really!!! Listen and give an honest opinion. It was mainly OK!
6/10