x factor results thread (18/10/09)

[Stephanie]

couldn't see one.

[MarkWaldorf]

whitney omfg

[Stephanie]

woo!

[Vicky.]

So, Is cheryl actually singing live now?

Or are we watching the 'music video' that she recorded this afternoon?

[GypsyGoth]

woohooo

[Stephanie]

WOOOO lmfao.

[Vicky.]

I cant believe whitney thought rachel was the best last night though :/

[GypsyGoth]

So, Is cheryl actually singing live now?

Or are we watching the 'music video' that she recorded this afternoon?

I think it was recorded earlier.

[Vicky.]

I think it was recorded earlier.

Ah, still bricking it then...

[Stephanie]

lmfao.

[setanta]

I cant believe whitney thought rachel was the best last night though :/

Course she did cuz she can recognise talent, just like Alexandra did when she met her and Robbie.

[Shaun]

this is so lipsynched :|

[Ninastar]

Why are they all singing?? is there a reason or did they all just feel like singing for no reason?

[Alf]

this is so american idol

[Sam!]

this is so lipsynched :|

Yeah I thought that, it's so cringey.

[Vicky.]

Course she did cuz she can recognise talent, just like Alexandra did when she met her and Robbie.

Yeah, but last night she was out of tune the whole way through :conf:

Though it wasnt her fault, stupid Dannii and stupid choices...

[Stephanie]

ee.

[Nicky.]

Twitter is broke, got nobody to talk to so HELLOOO!

[GypsyGoth]

Why are they all singing?? is there a reason or did they all just feel like singing for no reason?

They probably do it because it looks and sounds good and I think they will do it every sunday.

[Ninastar]

They probably do it because it looks and sounds good and I think they will do it every sunday.

Oh right. I hope so. I kinda like it tbh.

[Stephanie]

they just need to fill up an hours show.

[Princess]

They all looked like they were miming! Love the girl's dresses!

[andyman]

this is so lipsynched :|Yep and the girls did it very bad..

[Stephanie]

:joker:

[setanta]

Yeah, but last night she was out of tune the whole way through :conf:

Though it wasnt her fault, stupid Dannii and stupid choices...

I wouldn't go as far as to say that and sure most of them were appalling last night anyway. There was only one or two acts that were good in any shape or form.

[Vicky.]

I wouldn't go as far as to say that and sure most of them were appalling last night anyway. There was only one or two acts that were good in any shape or form.

In which case, whitney, being so experienced in music, should have known that rachel was far from the best last night.

She just looked silly saying that...she should have said she is the best overall or something, but had a bad night.

Its just stupidness saying she was the best yesterday...when she clearly wasnt

[30stone]

Not very good group song compared to last weeks.

And the blonde one from miss franks belly :yuk:

[MarkWaldorf]

omg so excited

[Brad.]

Watching an XF live show for the first time this year. :)

[setanta]

In which case, whitney, being so experienced in music, should have known that rachel was far from the best last night.

She just looked silly saying that...she should have said she is the best overall or something, but had a bad night.

Its just stupidness saying she was the best yesterday...when she clearly wasnt

I missed the start there.... she said that? Whitneys always had class and she thinks that Rachel deserves to stay in the show, as do I. Far too talented to be exiting right now.

[Stephanie]

olly :love:

[Brad.]

Olly the legend!

[Brad.]

How old is Olly?

[Vicky.]

I missed the start there.... she said that? Whitneys always had class and she thinks that Rachel deserves to stay in the show, as do I. Far too talented to be exiting right now.

Nah, was in the paper.

Chance to be BS anyways to be honest.

But it was a silly thing to say, if she said it.

[MassiveTruck]

Bollocks. I missed like the first 15 minutes.

[Stephanie]

miss frank were bad.

[GypsyGoth]

Bollocks. I missed like the first 15 minutes.

The first 15mins were the best :hugesmile:

[MassiveTruck]

God Rachel was horrendous last night.

[Stephanie]

rachel = wtf ****.

[MassiveTruck]

The first 15mins were the best :hugesmile:

Yeah I know. The group song and everything. I thought it was going to start at 8!

[MarkWaldorf]

joe<3

[30stone]

Rachel was ****ing awful how people can rate her so high is beyond me, never heard her sing well yet.

[Stephanie]

joe was good.

[Stephanie]

danyl was awful for some parts.

[GypsyGoth]

How old is Olly?

25

[MarkWaldorf]

i love how they always show danyl's big notes because its the only good part of it.

[Brad.]

Oh right, thanks Claudia.

[setanta]

Nah, was in the paper.

Chance to be BS anyways to be honest.

But it was a silly thing to say, if she said it.

Sure we'll find out soon enough what she thought about it all. Anyway, I think Rachel is class so well done Whitney.

[Stephanie]

i love how they always show danyl's big notes because its the only good part of it.
yes LOL.

[GypsyGoth]

Yeah I know. The group song and everything. I thought it was going to start at 8!

The song wasn't as good as last week. You didn't miss too mutch.

[Stephanie]

lmfao j & e.

[Brad.]

Want to smash my TV when these two idiots are on.

[Stephanie]

rikki makes my ears hurt.

[lolipop2005]

I was on the ph for the beginning of the show, what was the group song?

[GypsyGoth]

Jamie rocked!

[Stephanie]

jamie was good.

[Brad.]

The afro isn't a great singer I don't think.

[Locke.]

Jamie was amazing as usual

[lolipop2005]

Sorry for the double post

[30stone]

Stacy has an amazing voice.

[Vicky.]

Stacey grates on me for some reason

[Stephanie]

cheryl time.

[Vicky.]

Why are they making out cheryl is live?!

PMSL

Is she ashamed of her pre-recording?!

[setanta]

Stacey had alot of dud notes last night.

[30stone]

How much of it will she mime..

[Brad.]

The legend, Ashley Cole is in the audience tonight. We all love a bit of Cheryl as well.

[Chantel]

The legend, Ashley Cole is in the audience tonight. We all love a bit of Cheryl as well.

Yay Ashley :love:

[Locke.]

Cashley Cole can go and **** himself

[alchemists1]

Is she miming?

[Brad.]

I don't think a judge should be allowed to perform though :nono:

Even if she is hot...

[King Gizzard]

2-1 TO THE VILLA BOYS

Suck on that Ashley Cole you cockhead

[Stephanie]

it sounds kinda live lmfao.

[30stone]

Dont see why not?

Shes singing live isnt she?

[Brad.]

Yeah, definitely miming.

[Ninastar]

Bloody hell shes really good! I didnt expect that!

[GypsyGoth]

I love what she is wearing.

[Locke.]

She's clearly not miming lol

[King Gizzard]

Shes not miming, cause her voice sounds ****

[Shaun]

must be miming. :\

[Brad.]

2-1 TO THE VILLA BOYS

Suck on that Ashley Cole you cockhead

Bad attitude Nate. Ashley Cole is a great man.

[Stephanie]

i don't think she is.

[alchemists1]

She is dire!

[GypsyGoth]

Bloody hell shes really good! I didnt expect that!

She here, I like it a lot.

[Adamw92]

She's definetly not miming

[Vicky.]

Dont see why not?

Shes singing live isnt she?

No, its pre-recorded.

And by the looks of it, some of it is mimed.

[Novo]

She Ain't Miming LOL!

[bronaaaa]

Sounds pretty live to me..:D

[Brad.]

In some places it looks like she is and some not, what is this lol?!

[Shaun]

pretty good performance either way. :]

[King Gizzard]

She sounds amazingly awful

[Stephanie]

i think it sounds alright.

[alchemists1]

lol the mic covering her mouth is a dead giveaway.

[MarkWaldorf]

I love her

[Ninastar]

She here, I like it a lot.

hehe yeah. and I agree with what you said about the outfit. its really cute on her.

[30stone]

Yeah i think the majority is live..

and im impressed with her, as i know shes pretty poor.. so i think shes done well.

[Brad.]

A lot of the contestants are better than her! :p

[GypsyGoth]

Wow

[Shaun]

well that was hot.

[Stephanie]

she was good.

[alchemists1]

A lot of the contestants are better than her! :p

Agreed.
She wouldnt even make it to bootcamp.

[Brad.]

Love her generally. <3

[Vicky.]

Agreed.
She wouldnt even make it to bootcamp.

Agreed...

[30stone]

Dermot getting his chance to hug one of the sexiest women alive infront of 13million people.

[Ninastar]

AAWWWW at the dancing at the end!!

[and this is coming from someone who absolutley hates her]

[Locke.]

It was ok, much better than I thought it would be.

Wasn't as bad as Britney last year...

[Vicky.]

Simon talking BS now...

[King Gizzard]

That was no where near incredible

She wouldnt make it through bootcamp

[Brad.]

Dermot must have a semi...

[MarkWaldorf]

that was amazing!<3

[King Gizzard]

F off Cheryl ; )

[Vicky.]

Was nowhere near amazing.

Sounded pretty **** tbh.

Can see why blokes would like it though...

[Barbie]

that was good considering she was really nervous and it was definately live

[30stone]

Yeah her singing wasn't that great but she put on a great performance, i think most people didnt liek the performance because they dont like her.

[setanta]

How could Simon say that was incredible with a straight face?!!

[Vicky.]

I like her.

But it was still pretty crap.

The dancing was good though.

The singing wasnt up to much

[alchemists1]

I actually like her as a person but she cant sing simple.

[Sam!]

I thought Cheryl was brilliant, looked hot also :)

[Brad.]

I thought she sounded out of breath for most of that...

[Novo]

She Did an Amazing Job

[setanta]

It was pants lol. Good dancing but nothing else.

[alchemists1]

Its **** like that what gives British music a bad rep.

[Gemmer-x]

I thought Cheryl did a great job, really enjoyed it :)

[MassiveTruck]

The song wasn't as good as last week. You didn't miss too mutch.

LOL Make your mind up :joker:

I would have still enjoyed watching it :(

[30stone]

Yeah am definately impressed with that.

Not just better singing than i expected. But an amazing performance, best performance on the show so far this year.

[LemonJam]

That was reeeally good

[Braden]

well tonight's been mime-tastic so far !

[Princess]

That was such a good performance! She's not the greatest singer but she did brilliant! Well done Cheryl! :) Her lil speech and her hugs with everyone were so cute as well.

[Tom]

She did REALLY well, her voice was actually quite good :shocked:

Shes a good dancer

She should keep the outfit though, maybe take her jacket off

[Vicky.]

It was pants lol. Good dancing but nothing else.

Wow a male that will tell the truth about cheryl, instead of being blinded by lust ;)

[alchemists1]

Who really cares how good she danced when she is trying to sell albums,if she is good at dancing become a dancer dont try and sell music when you cant sing.

[setanta]

Yep, and even with the miming there was flat notes all over the shop.

[bronaaaa]

That was reeeally good

This
:lovedup:

[King Gizzard]

Terrible

[Sam!]

well tonight's been mime-tastic so far !

Cheryl didn't lip-sync :| The group did but she didn't.

[Tom]

Yep, and even with the miming there was flat notes all over the shop.

Its not even open for dispute, she was definitely singing live

[setanta]

Its not even open for dispute, she was definitely singing live

Pre-recorded baby.

[Vicky.]

Its not even open for dispute, she was definitely singing live

Some parts were definitely live...others questionable

[Stephanie]

that was live singing.

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Singing = lalalala

Dancing = Good

Overall = Too much trying to be like Kylie and that outfit from the music video itself is like Gwen Stefani's one.

[alchemists1]

Its not even open for dispute, she was definitely singing live

Dude you on drugs?

[Ross]

Absolutely amazing!!

[MassiveTruck]

If Louis loses another group it would be so funny. He could return and there will be no one to mentor.

[Brad.]

I don't like Dannii's hair at all tonight, it's just annoying.

[alchemists1]

Its gotta be miss frank and the 2 twats.

[Stephanie]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO whitney.

[30stone]

Wow a male that will tell the truth about cheryl, instead of being blinded by lust ;)



Nothing to do with that for me, i wasnt expecting much and she delivered. She also put on a great performance.

[MarkWaldorf]

OMG this is like a dream!!

[Scarlett.]

Get ready to see a real artist people

[Vicky.]

Its gotta be miss frank and the 2 twats.

I hope to god it is...

I cant see the twins being in the bottom 2 though...people are voting for them purely to annoy the sane among us...

[Stephanie]

If Louis loses another group it would be so funny. He could return and there will be no one to mentor.
LOL! it would.

[30stone]

I don't like Dannii's hair at all tonight, it's just annoying.



Same.

Im also not a massive whitney fan either...

[alchemists1]

Now this is what you call a singer!

[Shaun]

oh my.

[Mrluvaluva]

I wonder if Cheryl pre recorded the vocal and then mimed to it to try and make it look authentic?

[alchemists1]

I wish she would sing the tune 'Fine'

[GypsyGoth]

I was on the ph for the beginning of the show, what was the group song?


It was Free Your Mind, I think, an En Vogue song.

[Vicky.]

Now this is what you call a singer!

Indeed.

[King Gizzard]

She looks preggers

[MassiveTruck]

I like this. ! :laugh:

[Locke.]

Whitney should have sang I Look to You or Salute

[alchemists1]

Indeed.

lol I love Whitney but gotta hide her albums in case any of my mates see them.

[GypsyGoth]

Cheryl > Whitney

[Stephanie]

this song is shite.

[MassiveTruck]

Cheryl > Whitney

LOL

I loved them both but I'm really loving this.

[Brad.]

I don't think this is great to be honest. Better singer than Cheryl but Cheryl can perform much better IMO.

[King Gizzard]

Don't like this at all

and shes just standing there lol

[Tom]

LMAO @ her dress breaking

she is **** live

[alchemists1]

lol I love how people can praise Cheryl and rip Whitney Housten lol its mental.

[Shaun]

her top's fallen off. oh dear :\

[Mrluvaluva]

she' losing her dress!

[Stephanie]

her vocals are amazing but the song is rubbish.

[Barbie]

boys it looks like she may lose control of things!

[GypsyGoth]

her vocals are amazing but the song is rubbish.

Yep

[Ninastar]

LMAO he bra is like undone!

[Tom]

is she pissed?

[Brad.]

She generally just looks so grumpy and dull.

[Stephanie]

LMAO at dermot.

[Brad.]

is she pissed?

Yeah, it strangely sounds/looks like it.

[Mrluvaluva]

Is she on something?

[alchemists1]

She has been a crack head for the last 10 20 years or so,so I think that explains the look.

[30stone]

Good vocals, poor song, not one id ever sing along or even hum to.

I enjoyed Cheryls more.

[Scarlett.]

I wonder if the crapapers will say owt about her eyes?

[King Gizzard]

First robbie, now whitney

who else is on crack we can have next week?

[Brad.]

Who is that old guy, I missed what they were talking about?

[Stephanie]

we will probably have kerry crack katona doing a belly dance.

[Vicky.]

i dont get the people ripping whitney and praising cheryl at all...whitney wiped the floor with her...vocally anyway

[MassiveTruck]

I thought she was brilliant. Real superstar.

[Shaun]

Clive Davis.

[Barbie]

she's a really good singer but as a performance its not as good

[Scarlett.]

i dont get the people ripping whitney and praising cheryl at all...whitney wiped the floor with her...vocally anyway
I thought Whitney was great :dance:

[Alf]

what a stuck up misrable old haggard bitch

[MarkWaldorf]

for the record, whitney doesn't take crack. crack is whack.

[Barbie]

she is a really good singer but her performance was not so good

[King Gizzard]

Well both performances were quite poor..

Oh well, come on Olly!

[Brad.]

Thanks Shaun.

The prize you get from the winning the competition is amazing! £50,000, a camera, a laptop, an XBOX 360, a portable DVD player and an iPod Touch - not bad!

[alchemists1]

i dont get the people ripping whitney and praising cheryl at all...whitney wiped the floor with her...vocally anyway

Definatley agree and any1 who says different must be on more crack than Whitneys done lol.

[30stone]

i dont get the people ripping whitney and praising cheryl at all...whitney wiped the floor with her...vocally anyway



Cheryl's performance was far better. Cheryls song was for me better as its more catchy.

I found whitneys song a little boring, performance was okay, singing was great.

Prefered cheryls.

[GypsyGoth]

Definatley agree and any1 who says different must be on more crack than Whitneys done lol.

I don't take drugs and I like Cheryl's performance more.

[Ninastar]

Thanks Shaun.

The prize you get from the winning the competition is amazing! £50,000, a camera, a laptop, an XBOX 360, a portable DVD player and an iPod Touch - not bad!

wa this the thing harry hill was on about last night?

[alchemists1]

I think its 1 of the 1st performances she's done in years.

[setanta]

Whitney's performance was far better. Her voice might not be as good as before but she was engaging the crowd and really up for it. Cheryl was hiding under a hat. Leagues apart.

[Princess]

I thought Whitney was brilliant! What is with people wanting drama? Cheryl was miming,Robbie was stoned,Whitney was drunk,leave it be!

Btw is she pregnant? Cos I thought I read she was but can't remember.

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

SCD's guest professional performances > False Factors.

Spandau Ballet were beyond awesome last night, and Andy Williams was marvellous the week before. X factor mostly brings singers who need promoting for a new tour/comeback or whatever though.

[teabag.]

olly olly olly olly olly olly olly
im scared!

[Scarlett.]

I thought Whitney was brilliant! What is with people wanting drama? Cheryl was miming,Robbie was stoned,Whitney was drunk,leave it be!

Btw is she pregnant? Cos I thought I read she was but can't remember.
I know, I can see the press going on about Whitney tommorow already :rolleyes:

[Stephanie]

OLLY OLLY OLLLY OLLY OLLY! go olly.

[lily.]

Whitney Houston = Legend.

Fact.

[Adamw92]

Come on Stacey!!!! I hope Miss Frank go through!

[Stephanie]

GET RIKKI OUT! ha.

[MarkWaldorf]

Did Dermot say housemates? LOL

[Brad.]

Olly will go through, that much is obvious.

[Stephanie]

OLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLY!!! woo.

[30stone]

Rachel Miss Frank John and Edward any of them and im happy.

[alchemists1]

The 2 twats must be in the bottom 2 or this show has no credibality atall.
Who stops in the middle of there tune and start speaking when its a singing comp.

[30stone]

The 2 twats must be in the bottom 2 or this show has no credibality atall.
Who stops in the middle of there tune and start speaking when its a singing comp.


Thats how the song goes though? lol

[Stephanie]

OLLY OLLY OLLY oi oi oi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[teabag.]

Yessss

[Shaun]

bleh.

[Novo]

Get in!!!!!

[Brad.]

Nice one Olly!!!!!!

[MarkWaldorf]

olly!

[Stephanie]

OH MY ****ING GOD NO!! noo

[Shaun]

Yay! <3

[Adamw92]

Come on Miss Frank!!!!!

[King Gizzard]

Bye rikki

[alchemists1]

Its gotta be 1 of the guys then probable Ricki and the 2 twats.

[30stone]

****k off miss frank.

[Stephanie]

woo, joe!

[teabag.]

ooo it will be rachel and rikki i think

[bronaaaa]

Yay Danyle <3

[GypsyGoth]

:bouncy: Yay Lucie!

[Vicky.]

Rikki/Rachel bottom 2...I think

[MassiveTruck]

aaaww YEAH!

[30stone]

Rachel and Rikki would be perfect with rachel leaving.

[alchemists1]

The only downside to the 2 twats being up is we have to listen to them again,.

[MarkWaldorf]

Yay for joe

[Stephanie]

Rachel and Rikki would be perfect with rachel leaving.
yeh that would be good.

[Shaun]

come on rachel :'(

[30stone]

YESS LUCIE shes throught

[Vicky.]

Woo Jamie :D

[teabag.]

yeyyy

[bronaaaa]

ooo it will be rachel and rikki i think

Yupp that's what I'm thinking

[Stephanie]

yay jamie and stacey!

[King Gizzard]

Come on rachel

[teabag.]

i bet john ad edward get through here haha

[Shaun]

AAAAH RACHEL *screams*

[alchemists1]

I thou Rachel was better than whats left.

[Vicky.]

Please dont say J&E are safe...PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE

[Stephanie]

yay!!

[30stone]

Stacy, Lucie, Jamie, Olly, Danyl.

All my favourites through, i dont care now (=