cheryl - out of order?

[Stacey.]

what she said about john and edward!! omg!!
soooo out of order... what do you think?

[Ninastar]

No

[Vicky.]

Was a bit harsh, but it was true.

[Christina]

Harsh but true. What on earth are they doing there. People who can actually sing are being put into the bottom 2 because of them.

[CaraRawr]

um no it wasn't.

[Mrluvaluva]

She only said what most of us think.

[laurenheh]

i think it was a bit harsh the twins do have feelings even if they are irish hehe

[Gemmer-x]

LOL no they're rubbish.

[Jordan.]

She only said what most of us think.

:thumbs:

[CaraRawr]

She only said what most of us think.

:thumbs:

[Patrick]

Courtney I already made a thread on this like half an hour ago lol

But Anyway I voted 'No' :D

[Stacey.]

Courtney I already made a thread on this like half an hour ago lol

But Anyway I voted 'No' :D

oops sorry.

[Iceman]

i think it was a bit harsh the twins do have feelings even if they are irish hehe

What exactly is your problem with the Irish???

[Adamw92]

No she wasn't, it was 100% the truth

[bronaaaa]

Harsh but true. What on earth are they doing there. People who can actually sing are being put into the bottom 2 because of them.

This :thumbs:

[setanta]

No she wasn't, it was 100% the truth

What's 100% true? That she looks forward to watching J%E every week or that she doesn't like them? She's full of sh%te.

[Adamw92]

What's 100% true? That she looks forward to watching J%E every week or that she doesn't like them? She's full of sh%te.

That they shouldn't still be there

[setanta]

That they shouldn't still be there

Yes, coming from a girl who said that they're the act she looks forward to most. She's just a sore loser, that's all.

[Sarah.]

Yes she was.
I don't like her.

John and Edward to win :)

[laurenheh]

What exactly is your problem with the Irish???

nothing i like the irish :)

[Twilight]

Yeah she was

[Novo]

They deserved it Smug twats need there heads banging together

[Marc]

No. They should have gone, and it'll be said every week until they do go

[LemonJam]

Absolutley not. If Simon had said it it wouldn't have been questioned once.

[Shaun]

No. I thought they were hilarious yesterday but really? they shouldn't be there.

[Stacey.]

No. They should have gone, and it'll be said every week until they do go

it will be said for a very longg time then :joker:

[Niamh.]

Yes most of us think that but I think it was unprofessional of her to say it all the same

[teabag.]

its a bit stupid that they will be here for a long time and good acts will go but its not there fault there still in its just because there entertaining

[King Gizzard]

The poll results says it all really

Get them bastard twins out.

[King Gizzard]

http://www.freebettingonline.co.uk/betting-blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/john-sergeant.jpg

instantly springs to mind in regards to J&E

theres a difference though, the twins are twats

[Patrick]

The thing is though,

If Davina McCall or George Lamb were to say this about Rodrigo or Freddie or any HM for that matter,

You lot would all be yapping away and making threads demanding both of them to be excecuted or somthing.

Calling Them Biased and stuff,

But Cheryl says it and everyone supports her?

[Twilight]

I kinda agree with patrick

[Vicky.]

Yeah, BB is a bit different to TXF though...

BB is not about talent...

[Niamh.]

Yeah, BB is a bit different to TXF though...

BB is not about talent...

Yes but yesterday she was praising them and then today she says that. It came across as a bitchy snipe cos one of her acts was knocked out. I just think it was unecessery for her to say it and unprofessional when she wasn't judging them at the time

[Vicky.]

Well to be fair, all of the judges have been unprofessional this year. All making silly little snipes for no reason. Possibly with the exception of Simon.

As I said, it was harsh, but it was also true.

Why people would vote to save them is beyond me...I think its just to p*** people off...

[setanta]

Do you remember she had a hissy fit when Laura White was given the boot? Wasn't it against Ruth who sang her off the stage? She's just a sore loser, that's all.

[Niamh.]

Well to be fair, all of the judges have been unprofessional this year. All making silly little snipes for no reason. Possibly with the exception of Simon.

As I said, it was harsh, but it was also true.

Why people would vote to save them is beyond me...I think its just to p*** people off...

Don't get me wrong, I think they're **** but I did feel sorry for them, It's not their fault that Ricki went and lets be honest Ricki isn't great anyway, he was never going to win. Yeah, the other judges have made bitchy comments but I think that was the worst so far when she wasn't even judging them at the time and It was wrong of her imo

[Vicky.]

Do you remember she had a hissy fit when Laura White was given the boot? Wasn't it against Ruth who sang her off the stage? She's just a sore loser, that's all.

Ah Ruth...loved her.

She was absolutely amazing in her singoffs...

[lolipop2005]

It was harsh but true. However, i do think she was a little out of order considering her comments too the twins on Sat show! If she thinks they are that bad then she should say so at panel!!

[setanta]

Ah Ruth...loved her.

She was absolutely amazing in her singoffs...

Yep but Cheryl wouldn't accept it. She's just thinks she's "little-miss-showbiz", as Louis would say.

[Niamh.]

It was harsh but true. However, i do think she was a little out of order considering her comments too the twins on Sat show! If she thinks they are that bad then she should say so at panel!!

Yes, exactly! Spot on, there's a time & a place and that was neither!

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

http://www.freebettingonline.co.uk/betting-blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/john-sergeant.jpg

instantly springs to mind in regards to J&E

theres a difference though, the twins are twats

I was going to mention this^^

Despite agree'ing with Cheryl, last year during SCD I really disliked the Judges treatment of John Seargent, which is pretty much the same as what she said.

Although John was likeable and Bozo Bros aren't so theres that..

[Beastie]

yes. They deserve to be there. They have not been in the bottom 2 yet. The public are voring for them :D well the people who feel strongly passionate for them.

[Braden]

it was harsh
but she should be fustrated if one of her acts go home
and those two numpties arn't even in the bottom two !

[Z]

Yeah but when people are saying she 'supported' them the day before; she didn't really; she said that she looked forward to their performance (or words to that effect) - but that doesn't mean she thinks they're talented. It is a joke that they're even in the final twelve, let alone in the top ten and counting down. How many more actually talented singers are we going to lose before John and Edward get the boot? Kandy Rain and Rikki were never going to do particularly well, don't get me wrong, but it's still rough justice for Rachel that she's been in the bottom two twice ahead of that pair of prime muppets.

All of the judges have made pathetic snipes so far: three of them at Danyl in week 1, Simon calling two of Miss Frank's members bookends, Cheryl's remark about John and Edward, Dannii saying that 'Simon would have loved it if you were in his category'... that's what makes the X Factor UK so fun to watch; it's just as much about the judges as it is about the contestants, whether or not that's a good thing I change my mind on quite a lot, but that's the fact of the matter!