Rachel is one of the worst contestants ever..

[Billy]

All four live performances have been DIRE. She can't sing in tune atall, she just can't do it in front of a crowd! Her bootcamp auditions were good, but seriously if she doesn't go next week then it's just crap.

Saying that, she's not quite as bad as the twins, but at least they're entertaining.

[MarkWaldorf]

I agree. I love her style and her performances, but she isn't THAT strong as a singer as she should be. Her voice is quite soft and she's being made to be some edgy diva which she isn't.

[LemonJam]

Her last 3 performances IMO have been great!

Her voice won't be to everyones taste I can understand but it has an interesting quality to it which I find endearing.

[Billy]

If I Were A Boy was horrific IMO :( She didn't stay in tune at all throughout the performance and it was annoying! Her bottom two performance tonight was her best but even then it was really bad in most places.

[30stone]

Finally someone that agree's.

I think shes been awful.

[Tom]

And to think she didn't get through over Stacey McLean :(

[Patrick]

Rikki and Kandy Rain went home because of that Dick?


The annoying thing is, Xtra Factor complete lick up her arse

[Patrick]

And to think she didn't get through over Stacey McLean :(

Omg!
Remember how fit she was!
:shocked:


I loved that girl, I hate Rachel even more now!

[setanta]

Stacey was cute but the girl didn't have a strong enough voice for a live show.

[30stone]

Omg!
Remember how fit she was!
:shocked:


I loved that girl, I hate Rachel even more now!


Despina was just as fit too!



and stacy is a good singer for this show.

[Vicky.]

I loved that girl, I hate Rachel even more now!
Its not rachels fault cheryl picked her :rolleyes:

[Z]

Despina should have gotten through over Rachel in my opinion, but I still don't think Rachel is bad. She's not amazing, but she's so not deserving of two bottom two appearances in a row.

[Shaun]

All four live performances have been DIRE. She can't sing in tune atall, she just can't do it in front of a crowd! Her bootcamp auditions were good, but seriously if she doesn't go next week then it's just crap.

Saying that, she's not quite as bad as the twins, but at least they're entertaining.

coming from a Diana fan.

[Tom]

http://img.thesun.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00662/Diana-Vickers_682_662260a.jpg

[Shaun]

*cringe*

[Z]

HAHAHAHAHA Tom you legend

[setanta]

You're going to give me nightmares now Tom. Thanks hee hee.

[30stone]

Diana was fit.

[Vicky.]

I LOVED Diana. My fave contestant ever :D

[MiuMiu]

I agree with this thread.
Rachael was my winner before the finals started and then she came out, did "Let me entertain you" and "If I were a boy" and I nearly died both times.
And I wanted to personally escort her off off the stage because she shouldn't be there at all.
She is horrendous.
:(

[Stacey.]

yes completely...
its so wrong.
get rachel outt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Arneldo]

coming from a Diana fan.

And he supported Alisha. ALISHA.


Rachel can sing, and has a nice voice. But she just hasn't come across yet on the live shows for whatever reason. She was one of the strongest in the bootcamp/judges houses stage.

I do think she could still pull it back and get through maybe one or two more weeks, but she won't win.

[arsenalforever]

sadly to say its a bad year this year for great singers in the X factor half of this lot wouldn't have made most years.

really over four people are even in the race for the main prize right now the rest are cannon fodder

[setanta]

This attack on Rachel is ridiculous when you actually take an objective look on all of the performances last night and realise that there were so many others who performed far worse than her and don't have the set of lungs that she possesses. I just think song choice and styling has let her down big time with the public.

[Niamh.]

This attack on Rachel is ridiculous when you actually take an objective look on all of the performances last night and realise that there were so many others who performed far worse than her and don't have the set of lungs that she possesses. I just think song choice and styling has let her down big time with the public.

I liked her this week actually. I thought the week before she was brutal but that was more to do with the song choice than her to be fair. She does have a good & different voice. She does remind me a great deal of Grace Jones though...............

[setanta]

The Grace Jones look has to go cuz it's too cold a look for her. They need to soften her look for the public to accept her more easily. Honestly don't understand the venom of the attack here. She has more star quality than the rest of them- just have to package her properly.

[Chels]

and to think that rikki would have been good in big band week :/
simon's a plonker.

[setanta]

and to think that rikki would have been good in big band week :/
simon's a plonker.

Rikki's rubbish and sure you support Lloyd. Nuff said.

[Niamh.]

and to think that rikki would have been good in big band week :/
simon's a plonker.


rachel 100% deserved to stay over Ricki

[Niamh.]

The Grace Jones look has to go cuz it's too cold a look for her. They need to soften her look for the public to accept her more easily. Honestly don't understand the venom of the attack here. She has more star quality than the rest of them- just have to package her properly.

Well Danni is going to have to do something to make her more appealing to the public. She has the talent but she's not coming across properly

[setanta]

Well Danni is going to have to do something to make her more appealing to the public. She has the talent but she's not coming across properly

I'm not sure about Danni as a mentor to be honest with you. She nearly ballsed up Rhydians chances after all. She made him too campy and than too boring in response to the backlash. I don't think she has a clue.

[Chels]

Rikki's rubbish and sure you support Lloyd. Nuff said.

So what?
My opinion isn't it :xyxwave:

[Niamh.]

I'm not sure about Danni as a mentor to be honest with you. She nearly ballsed up Rhydians chances after all. She made him too campy and than too boring in response to the backlash. I don't think she has a clue.

Well, to be quite honest, I think If I were in the competition (If I could sing haha) I'd rather have Loius or Simon cos they make a living out of marketing people, Danni & Cheryl aren't really qualified to do that job

[setanta]

Well, to be quite honest, I think If I were in the competition (If I could sing haha) I'd rather have Loius or Simon cos they make a living out of marketing people, Danni & Cheryl aren't really qualified to do that job

They've made very silly mistakes over the last 2 weeks, that's for sure. Simon hasn't missed a beat.

[Niamh.]

They've made very silly mistakes over the last 2 weeks, that's for sure. Simon hasn't missed a beat.

and even Louis, how he's marketing the Twins is genius, they're crap but people want to watch them!

[setanta]

The twins had me in stiches. You just have to forget the fact they should never have made the live shows and just sit back and enjoy the ride. Crazy stuff but hilarious.

[sweety_samy9]

coming from a Diana fan.

aww I love you now! :)
Rachel is FAB.
Rachel to win... <3

[sweety_samy9]

Rikki and Kandy Rain went home because of that Dick?


The annoying thing is, Xtra Factor complete lick up her arse

NOT because of Rachel...for the hundreth time.
get over it...you're so annoying.
I loved Rikki.
Both him and Rach didn't deserve to be in the bottom.
so PLEASE stop with your nasty comments.
Rachel is great...<3

[alc09]

You are hardly in a position to comment seeing as you have that useless twat in your avatar, Billy.

[Twilight]

if someone actually thinks she can sing they have gotta be mad:/

[NettoSuperstar!]

Shes been given **** songs

[LemonJam]

if someone actually thinks she can sing they have gotta be mad:/

-looks at favourites-

lol.

[Beastie]

Rachel will be gone this week. Such a waste saving her. Simon should have sent her home! NOT rikki :(

[Braden]

she is better than rachel,daniel,chico etc so i think it's abit far fetched to say she is the worst contestant ever.

[Beastie]

Wait.. I want lloyd out this week, Rachel and Joe can wait the next 2 weeks.