The new 'group song' element

[Z]

I.e. ripping off American Idol.

What do you think of it?

Personally, not a fan of it purely because it's an American Idol thing; but I did like Queen of the Night, I thought Miss Frank absolutely dominated the female vocals, there's a part of it when you watch it on YouTube where they sing, and then immediately after Lucie, Rachel and Stacey are singing, they sound so weak in comparison. In general though, I dislike it and I think it should be left to the American audiences, it's not for us.

[King Gizzard]

I think its a good idea, I just don't like how nearly everyones miming in it

[30stone]

I like it a lot.

Think the frst week was amazing.

[Iceman]

First week was brilliant....not so much a fan of last weeks...

[Tom4784]

I don't think it detracts from anything, it's okay but the results show would probably be a bit boring without it.

[Iceman]

I don't think it detracts from anything, it's okay but the results show would probably be a bit boring without it.

Yeah, I'm liking the 2 guests on each week but other than that and the group song, the results is way too long drawn out...

[GypsyGoth]

I like the group song.

[Arneldo]

Really it's just a way of filling in time now they have the Sunday time slot. I'd much rather this time was spent talking to the finalists though.

[teabag.]

its silly that they were miming last week
i didnt like queen of the night but i got a feeling was good

[xDramatick]

Eh, I think it's alright.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Its pants, it makes me feel ill

[Jords]

I think its a great idea (:

[LemonJam]

I like it, I think it'll be more effective when it gets down to the final 7.

[Princess]

I like it! It's nice to see them all sing together.

[Tom]

On paper its really good but its actually awful

[Lewis.]

It's not that bad, I quite like seeing how they will sound as one big group. I'm surprised they are not doing another charity single this year, it really raised the reputation of the X factor last year when they did it.

[LemonJam]

but I did like Queen of the Night, I thought Miss Frank absolutely dominated the female vocals, there's a part of it when you watch it on YouTube where they sing, and then immediately after Lucie, Rachel and Stacey are singing, they sound so weak in comparison.

In all fairness though, the girls bit was alot more difficult to sing.

But Miss Frank are better singers, no doubt.

[MiuMiu]

It's always a mime fest.
Therefore, it's a massive fail.
:(

[Z]

In all fairness though, the girls bit was alot more difficult to sing.

But Miss Frank are better singers, no doubt.

Yeah I agree, and therefore it failed spectacularly as they all tried to hit, and they all missed :hugesmile:.

[Niamh.]

I don't think it detracts from anything, it's okay but the results show would probably be a bit boring without it.


True, they have to fill that hour up some way!

[Beastie]

I love the group song! It proves who are the better performers though! (eg John and Edward :D)