X Factor, week 3 discussion thread (24/10/09)

[Tom]

i cant understand a thing diana sings, let alone that one word!

youtube "diana vickers subtitles"

[Marc]

Am I the only one who liked her old hair?

I did.. was kinda like Grace Jones.. it made her unique

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

I missed it.
What happened?

[andyman]

Am I the only one who liked her old hair?It was pure sex!

[Braden]

Am I the only one who liked her old hair?

i prefered her old hair :hugesmile:

[Shaun]

jaaaaaamie.

[Locke.]

Jamie :D

[Stephanie]

luls i thought michael buble or whatever was an old man, but obviously not.

[Marc]

ugh... Jamie

[MarkWaldorf]

he always does that arm punch! LOL

[GypsyGoth]

rachel just lost my vote after that crazy shite.

:laugh:

[andyman]

Jamie the jimmy jam!

... Very good, 9/10.

[MarkWaldorf]

wtf andyman its been 20 seconds

[Wildcat!]

Jamie the jimmy jam!

... Very good, 9/10.

What? Its been 5 seconds??:conf::conf::conf:

[Wildcat!]

Pretty good as always!

[GypsyGoth]

This is a bit so-so in parts

[Stephanie]

8/10

[Adamw92]

Olly- 8/10
Lloyd- 3/10
Miss Frank- 9/10
Rachel- 8/10
Jamie- 7.5/10

[Shaun]

not such a fan of the song choice. :\
5/10.

[MarkWaldorf]

it's alright, but not my favourite.

[*mazedsalv**]

Bad note there.

Generally good!

[Novo]

9/10

[Braden]

that was good !
8/10

[Wildcat!]

He gets a 7/10 from me. It was OK!

[Tom]

Jamie thinks he's won it already

[LemonJam]

Louie's spot on tonight.

[Stephanie]

olly: 9/10
lloyd: 5/10
miss frank: 6/10
rachel: 7/10
jamie: 8/10

and louis wtf.

[Wildcat!]

LOuis said the same thing to Diana last year, so fair enough!!!

[Braden]

olly-7/10
lloyd-3.5/10
miss frank-8.5/10
rachel-6.5/10
jamie-8/10

[Locke.]

Jamie - 9.5/10 [sounded like an actual real performance from an artist and not an x factor performance]
Rachel - 8.5/10
Olly - 8/10
Miss Frank -7/10
Lloyd - 2.5/10

[Tom]

LOuis said the same thing to Diana last year, so fair enough!!!

He's right though

[Braden]

arguing
just the way i like it :D

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Didn't adapt to big band, so pretty much can't be diverse. He's quite good at what he does though. Was a 7.5/10.

[Wildcat!]

He's right though


Yeah I agree. Thats why I missed Louis last week. He doesnt let Simon get away with murder like the 2 girls.

[Locke.]

Simon!! LOL!!!

[Lewis.]

Lmfao at Simon.
But Louis is right
At least choose a song that can relate to Big Band week./

I hate Jamie... I don't think he can sing that well.

[Braden]

ahahaha
john and edward must be backstage
just knowing the judges hate them

[Adamw92]

Stacey!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Braden]

aww i lve good old stacey !

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

I predict this will be very good.

[Wildcat!]

This chick is mental! :)

[Braden]

her mum looks like a ghost
and as stephanie knows
i normally love all the mums

[MarkWaldorf]

LOL I love her

[Locke.]

Hate this stupid pathetic woman

[LemonJam]

He probably doesn't have any wishes to come true, he's only 1 and a half [/bluntness]

[*mazedsalv**]

Im in love with Stacey. :D

[Wildcat!]

Hate this stupid pathetic woman

Cmon! SHe is funny in a bonkers kind of way! :hugesmile:

[Brad.]

Watching the X Factor now because Strictly's finished. :)

[Braden]

she looks great !

[Brad.]

Not bad at all.

[Braden]

she is fan-dabby-dosey !

[Wildcat!]

Damn!! That girl got pipes!!! Almost as good as Leona. NOt quite, but almost.

[GypsyGoth]

Song is a bit too big for her.

[Stephanie]

Damn!! That girl got pipes!!! Almost as good as Leona. NOt quite, but almost.
never.

[Shaun]

well that was sheer mediocrity.
5/10.

[Lewis.]

That was amazing.

[Novo]

Average

[Wildcat!]

Watching the X Factor now because Strictly's finished. :)

:sleep::sleep::sleep::sleep::sleep:
Stacey 9/10

[LemonJam]

Noice.

[Braden]

9/10
it was amazing !

[MarkWaldorf]

Not her best :(

[Adamw92]

Olly- 8/10
Lloyd- 3/10
Miss Frank- 9/10
Rachel- 8/10
Jamie- 7.5/10
Stacey- 9/10 (biased but haha :lovedup: )

[Brad.]

7/10

[Stephanie]

that was good, 7/10

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Quite good 7/10.

[Braden]

olly-7/10
lloyd-3.5/10
miss frank-8.5/10
rachel-6.5/10
jamie-8/10
stacey-9/10

[Locke.]

Well that was dull...

Jamie - 9.5/10
Rachel - 8.5/10
Olly - 8/10
Miss Frank -7/10
Stacey - 5.5/10
Lloyd - 2.5/10

[andyman]

Would rather see her naked..

[Braden]

i love her !

[Wildcat!]

She is mental!!

[Brad.]

I hate her personality so much, I want her to shut up for a minute because she sounds over-excited ALL the time. :mad:

[Stephanie]

her talking is starting to get abit annoying, she sounds like an idiot.

[LemonJam]

Dermot's really patronizing.

[Brad.]

Would rather see her naked..

Good call andyman :D

[Shaun]

something about her just irks me - she seems nice, and i don't think she's being fake, but I just don't like the whole "i'm stupid and have a motormouth" thing.

[andyman]

MJ!

[*mazedsalv**]

Shes soo lovely!!

MJ movie!!! :) I will be watching that!

[setanta]

She's not a good singer, I'm sorry. 3 weeks with flat notes all over the shop.

[MiuMiu]

I hate Jamie so much.
He's so insipid.
:(

[Brad.]

Phones4u ad LOL! NO, NO! :joker:

[LemonJam]

I hate Jamie so much.
He's so insipid.
:(

What does insipid mean? D: (Sorry, I'm not the brightest torch)

[Stephanie]

for me olly has been the best so far.

[Locke.]

I hate Jamie so much.
He's so insipid.
:(

Don't be so bloody stupid

[andyman]

something about her just irks me - she seems nice, and i don't think she's being fake, but I just don't like the whole "i'm stupid and have a motormouth" thing.
She is a wee bit fake..

[Wildcat!]

MJ!

http://www.507th.net/forums/images/smilies/worship.gifhttp://www.507th.net/forums/images/smilies/worship.gifhttp://www.507th.net/forums/images/smilies/worship.gifhttp://www.507th.net/forums/images/smilies/worship.gif

[setanta]

I hate Jamie so much.
He's so insipid.
:(

I agree. Does absolutely nothing for me. Stacey, Jamie and Olly's support baffles me.

[MarkWaldorf]

Honestly I can't see Stacey winning but I think she'll go far. :(

[Wildcat!]

Don't be so bloody stupid
:joker::joker:

[andyman]

Nintendo ads... VILE!

[Stephanie]

olly: 9/10
lloyd: 5/10
miss frank: 6/10
rachel: 7/10
jamie: 8/10
stacey: 7/10

[MiuMiu]

What does insipid mean? D: (Sorry, I'm not the brightest torch)

It basically means just makes you feel annoyed and sickly inside because of the way they behave.
:)

[LemonJam]

Woooop, Danyl!

and thanks MiuMiu -adds to vocab- :P

[MarkWaldorf]

Ugh Danyl.

[Shaun]

i LOVE the song he's singing, so I hope he doesn't mess it up.

[Adamw92]

Don't like him...

[Brad.]

Danyl seems pretty cool. :)

[Stephanie]

ugh danyl.

[LemonJam]

Danyl seems pretty cool. :)

Holy ****, someone else on here who likes him. :bigsmile:

[MarkWaldorf]

Lets cue the last note!

[Stephanie]

Lets cue the last note!
they might aswell just foward it to the end of his song.

[Adamw92]

Lets cue the last note!

Yes...cue the shouting

[andyman]

Honestly I can't see Stacey winning but I think she'll go far. :(Lucie is the only female that has a chance of winning, but a male will win.

[Wildcat!]

THe dude just doesnt want to PRONOUNCE THE WORDS!!!!!!!
That really annoys me.

[Braden]

everyone looks smart for a change

[Shaun]

this is ****.

[Adamw92]

I didn't like Rachel last year but her version was miles better!

[Brad.]

How wide does his mouth go LOL?

[Wildcat!]

Until I can understand his words, I am never gonna like his performance.

6/10

[LemonJam]

That was great!

[Braden]

i think he sings through his nose

[Novo]

7/10

[Shaun]

total balls. mess. 3/10.

[Chantel]

That was great!

It was :thumbs:

[Jordan.]

He was alright..

[Brad.]

7/10

[Adamw92]

that note was just shouted...

[Wildcat!]

SImon, yeah, you dont patronize people. Thats why you give a standing ovationg to all your acts!! :rolleyes:

[andyman]

He is good, better than good.. Fantastic!

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

One trick pony with holding a long note at the end of every song. 7/10 though.

[Braden]

olly-7/10
lloyd-3.5/10
miss frank-8.5/10
rachel-6.5/10
jamie-8/10
stacey-9/10
danyl-5/10

[Locke.]

Jamie - 9.5/10
Rachel - 8.5/10
Danyl - 8/10
Olly - 8/10
Miss Frank -7/10
Stacey - 5.5/10
Lloyd - 2.5/10

[GypsyGoth]

Dan is a bum.

[Stephanie]

5/10

[MiuMiu]

The Ego shoutes his way through a song again.
Where the **** was this "High note"?

[MarkWaldorf]

ugh simon.

[Brad.]

How old is Danyl?

[Novo]

You tell tell Danyl is Simon's Golden Boy

[Shaun]

1. Rachel
2. Olly
3. Miss Frank
4. Stacey
5. Jamie
6. Danyl
7. Lloyd

[Wildcat!]

SImon is deluded!

[Adamw92]

Yes Simon, because you would have said exactly the same if he wasn't your act

[GypsyGoth]

How old is Danyl?

27

[andyman]

Danyl again gets it note perfect..

But hey X Factor aint about Talent..

[MiuMiu]

This is why I hate the xfactor this year!
:(

[Stephanie]

danyl is shite, he sings completely crap and then adds a big shouted note. simon then thinks it's great so the other judges say it's wonderful.

[Brad.]

Thanks Claudia. :)

The 25 and over's group is the best this year. Olly, Danyl, Rachel and whoever the 4th one is. Good group that is.

[Sam!]

Fucck Simon licks Danyl's arse.

[Shaun]

the guy in the Up Your Viva advert is so ****ing ugly.

[Sam!]

Thanks Claudia. :)

The 25 and over's group is the best this year. Olly, Danyl, Rachel and whoever the 4th one is. Good group that is.

wtf lol theres three not four in each group and Rachel isn't one of them. lool.

[setanta]

What's with the great comments for Danyl on that performance? It was average stuff.

[LemonJam]

Oh ****ing please at Simon licking Danyl ass, all the mentors lick ALL their acts arses, not just them two.

[andyman]

Dan is a bum.And this is why the public vote has many flaws.

[Jordan.]

That cake looked so good

[Brad.]

I don't watch the show most weeks Sam lol. I keep thinking there are 3 judges and WTF? Rachel must be 25+?

[Sam!]

I don't watch the show most weeks Sam lol. I keep thinking there are 3 judges and WTF? Rachel must be 25+?

Rachel is 18 lol.

[Locke.]

I don't watch the show most weeks Sam lol. I keep thinking there are 3 judges and WTF? Rachel must be 25+?

She turned 18 recently :joker:

[Stephanie]

I don't watch the show most weeks Sam lol. I keep thinking there are 3 judges and WTF? Rachel must be 25+?
18.

[LemonJam]

I don't watch the show most weeks Sam lol. I keep thinking there are 3 judges and WTF? Rachel must be 25+?

She's 18. She looked alot younger til they bollocksed her hair up tonight.

[Brad.]

Fkin hell lol she looks 10 years older. :p

[arsenalforever]

its all about sob stories and good looks nothign on X factor is about talent

[MarkWaldorf]

Go Joe poster! :D

[MarkWaldorf]

Omg

[Brad.]

I don't like Joe, he just seems annoying.

[andyman]

danyl is shite, he sings completely crap and then adds a big shouted note. simon then thinks it's great so the other judges say it's wonderful.Another reason why the public voting system has flaws.

[LemonJam]

-gets pillow and duvet-

No need for nytol tonight, perform Joe!

[Wildcat!]

Cmon Joe!

[MarkWaldorf]

I don't like Joe, he just seems annoying.

You said you don't even watch it much, wtf.

[Shaun]

*worries at agreeing with Louis*

[MassiveTruck]

Sexy
Sexy

SEXY


SEXY!!!!


YEAH WE GET IT!!! SEXY!!!!! :mad:

[Wildcat!]

Cheryls smug face annoys me11

[Braden]

who was just on ?

[Novo]

He sounds nervous

[Brad.]

You said you don't even watch it much, wtf.

From what I have seen, obviously. :rolleyes:

[Shaun]

ooooh.
this is actually pretty good.

[Wildcat!]

LOL! :laugh:

[MassiveTruck]

who was just on ?

Rachel, Jamie, Stacey, Danyl and now Cheryls incestual brother.

[Stephanie]

oh god, sexy?
LOL!

[Marc]

really like this performance!!

[andyman]

When Joe smiles i want to punch walls and break stuff!

[Callum]

He was really good tonight.

[Tom]

His voice is awful and hes too camp for my liking

[Novo]

5/10

This week

much better the first two weeks

[arsenalforever]

So Rachel has been the only one who's been excellent tonight then?

[Locke.]

Jamie - 9.5/10
Rachel - 8.5/10
Danyl - 8/10
Olly - 8/10
Miss Frank -7/10
Joe - 7/10 [Vocally good, didn't like the way he kept smiling creepily at me or the dancing.]
Stacey - 5.5/10
Lloyd - 2.5/10

[Shaun]

goood. :) 7/10.

[MassiveTruck]

When Joe smiles i want to punch walls and break stuff!

You and me both.

[Jordan.]

replace sexy with cheesy xD
still thought he was good though :)

[Wildcat!]

Nice one I think!
8/10

[Stephanie]

7/10
not sexy though LOL.

[Brad.]

3/10

I didn't like that, it just seemed underwhelming to me.

[LemonJam]

I don't think he could actually be any more cheesey.

[Sam!]

His best performance so far but he's wayy too smiley for my liking.

[MassiveTruck]

3/10

I didn't like that, it just seemed underwhelming to me.

They are cack aren't they.

[Wildcat!]

J
Joe - 7/10 [Vocally good, didn't like the way he kept smiling creepily at me or the dancing.]

:joker: :laugh:

[Braden]

Rachel, Jamie, Stacey, Danyl and now Cheryls incestual brother.

oh thank you :)..

olly-7/10
lloyd-3.5/10
miss frank-8.5/10
rachel-6.5/10
jamie-8/10
stacey-9/10
danyl-5/10
joe-7.5/10

[Tom]

I don't think he could actually be any more cheesey.

Hes very 'cruise ship'

[Stephanie]

as a dolphin PMSL.

[arsenalforever]

you always have one Cheesy singer its always been apart of X factor

[Wildcat!]

I actually agree with simon. I was thinking the same, when he was trying to Salsa and failing! :laugh:

[Brad.]

This guy should be in the bottom 2 tonight.

[andyman]

This show about who is cute or real talent?

[arsenalforever]

This show about who is cute or real talent?

Looks first

[MassiveTruck]

Yeah! Finally some talent!

[Sam!]

Wahey Lucie <3

[GypsyGoth]

Luciehttp://i16.tinypic.com/89tqpzd.jpg

[Shaun]

I don't think he's cute or sexy, he's actually quite creepy and I'd rather tap Stacey - but he sung well and did a good performance, much better than Lloyd, Danyl and Jamie's.

[Stephanie]

olly: 9/10
lloyd: 5/10
miss frank: 6/10
rachel: 7/10
jamie: 8/10
stacey: 7/10
danyl: 5/10
joe: 7/10

[LemonJam]

I love her song. <3

[Wildcat!]

This chick is just CUTE!!! I cant help but like her.:blush2::blush2:

[Stephanie]

lucie annoys me.

[Shaun]

wow. she looks incredible.

[MassiveTruck]

Oh man if she nails this later on this is going to be awesome!

[Callum]

Love Lucie. I've seen her in loads of shows in Cardiff. She actually thanked me once when I saw her coming out of the stage door and I said to her "you were great!" lol.

[Sam!]

she looks fiiine.

[LemonJam]

I take back her being bottom 2.

[Brad.]

wow. she looks incredible.

I think she looks worse tonight than she did last week.

[*mazedsalv**]

Wow, this is brilliant!

[GypsyGoth]

Wow, this is brilliant!

:thumbs:

[Stephanie]

it's actually hurting my ears.

[arsenalforever]

its all about the legs

[Wildcat!]

DAmn! That song choice is perfect for her!!1
Well done Dannii

[LemonJam]

I'm not a Lucie fan but this is actually amazing.

[andyman]

Very good.. This girl will be in the final.

[Shaun]

wow.
wow.
wow.
wow.

brilliant.
9/10.

[Brad.]

9/10

[MassiveTruck]

Amazing!

[Stephanie]

7/10

[Wildcat!]

OK, she was the best tonight.
9/10

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Wow. Usually think she's very overrated but hands down best tonight.

9, maybe 9.5/10

[Locke.]

Jamie - 9.5/10
Rachel - 8.5/10
Danyl - 8/10
Olly - 8/10
Miss Frank -7/10
Joe - 7/10
Lucie - 6/10
Stacey - 5.5/10
Lloyd - 2.5/10

[Jordan.]

very good! :)

[Chantel]

9/10

[Callum]

Great as always, never fails to disappoint.

[Adamw92]

Olly- 8/10
Lloyd- 3/10
Miss Frank- 9/10
Rachel- 8/10
Jamie- 7.5/10
Stacey- 9/10
Danyl- 7/10
Joe- 7.5/10
Lucie- 8.5/10
John & Edward- 1/10 (just gonna guess)

[Sam!]

she enchants me <3

1. Lucie
2. Olly
3. Rachel
4. Miss Frank
5. Stacey
6. Joe
7. Jamie
8. Danyl
9. Lloyd

[Jordan.]

Lol

[Tom]

I agree with Cheryl and imo best performance of the series

[Sam!]

Simon go fucck Danyl.

[Jordan.]

how can you sing like an actress :|

[Shaun]

wtf Simon?

[Braden]

olly-7/10
lloyd-3.5/10
miss frank-8.5/10
rachel-6.5/10
jamie-8/10
stacey-9/10
danyl-5/10
joe-7.5/10
lucie-8/10

[Locke.]

Very well said Simon

[LemonJam]

Loving Louie tonight.

[Adamw92]

It's just because she isn't his own act

[MassiveTruck]

That was a bastard comment by Simon.

[Wildcat!]

Seriously, Simon is full of SHiit this year.
He doednt even know what the hell he is talking about

[Sam!]

I usually hate Louis but he's been right all evening tonight.

[Tom]

how can you sing like an actress :|

I get what he means, very hard to explain, but I don't think she did sing it like an actress

[Braden]

dermot sticking up for people as usual

[Brad.]

Simon speaks sense.

[MassiveTruck]

3/10

I didn't like that, it just seemed underwhelming to me.

I get what he means, very hard to explain, but I don't think she did sing it like an actress

I don't think there is much to get other than

a) He is saving his own
b) He may be fishing for sympathy votes for her from the viewers.

[arsenalforever]

Simon act is to play the bad guy he's been great at it for years

[Stephanie]

she obviously thinks she's amazing and she looked abit like meh when simon said that.

[Tom]

Louis saying "its not big band" is going to spectacularly backfire when John and Edward sing She Bangs

[andyman]

Simon just playing the war of words just like them two witches have done..

[*mazedsalv**]

Olly- 8/10
Lloyd- 3/10
Miss Frank- 7.5/10
Rachel- 8/10
Jamie- 6.5/10
Stacey- 8.5/10
Danyl- 7.5/10
Joe- 7/10
Lucie- 9/10 (just WOW)

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Okay so

Lucie: 9/10
Olly: 8/10
Jamie: 7/10
Stacey: 6.5/10
Danyl: 6/10
Rachel: 5.5/10
Frankenstein: 4/10
Joe: 3.5/10
Lloyd: 1/10
J+E: 0.5/10

[Braden]

oh my lord louie
shup about not singing big band !

[MassiveTruck]

how can you sing like an actress :|

He means that she cloned it from something and didn't bring herself into it.

I think he either does it save his bunch of adolescent old men or he wants the viewers to vote for her by giving sympathy for her.

[Brad.]

John and Edward on after the break, that's going to be ****.

[Wildcat!]

I get what he means, very hard to explain, but I don't think she did sing it like an actress


I know what he means, its kind of like the cabaret lounge singers from the 50''s movies.
BUt Big band is supposed to be a little bit theatrical. SO he is full od SHiit trying to criticize her for it.