Who will flop if they win?

[Tom]

Multipoll so vote for as many as you want

[Jack_]

John & Edward, Rachel, Jamie definitely.

Lloyd would be 50/50, haven't made my mind up yet.

[Wildcat!]

Lloyd, JE, Danyl, probably Joe as well. I like him xfactor wise, but in the real world, errrm, NO!

[Tom4784]

I clicked all but 3. Chances are we're in for a flop year.

[Tom]

I clicked all but 3. Chances are we're in for a flop year.

Thats what I felt like. I think Stacey could be a good little popstar (Pixie Lott etc) and Olly has a unique sound .... but I can't really see the rest doing that well

Rachel and Lucie would be pointless winning, we already have the much superior Alexandra and Leona to fit their particular styles

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

In reality I honestly don't think any X-Factor winner can become a properly big popstar. Steve, Shayne and Leon have disappeared; and I don't hear much about Leona these days (has she released any new single?), and Alexandra will dissapear by next year. This year, the same will probably happen as always, regardless of who wins they get the X-Mas no.1 from hype off the back of the show, release a single and dissapear.

[Novo]

Everyone but olly :)

[Tom]

In reality I honestly don't think any X-Factor winner can become a properly big popstar. Steve, Shayne and Leon have disappeared; and I don't hear much about Leona these days (has she released any new single?), and Alexandra will dissapear by next year. This year, the same will probably happen as always, regardless of who wins they get the X-Mas no.1 from hype off the back of the show, release a single and dissapear.

Leona has a new single/album coming out, she'll be on X Factor in a few weeks

[Stephanie]

i voted everyone except olly.

[KKBL]

I actually think Stacey and Lucie would flop.Not so sure about the others.
Jamie might flop on the singles chart but I can imagine his songs would get alot of radio play on adult contemporary stations(Radio 2?) which would lead to big album and ticket sales.

[MrGaryy]

Lloyd definitely. He's proved in the live shows he has zero artist potential, he;s nothing more than a pretty face with a very average voice.

[Tom4784]

In reality I honestly don't think any X-Factor winner can become a properly big popstar. Steve, Shayne and Leon have disappeared; and I don't hear much about Leona these days (has she released any new single?), and Alexandra will dissapear by next year. This year, the same will probably happen as always, regardless of who wins they get the X-Mas no.1 from hype off the back of the show, release a single and dissapear.

I'm not a fan of either but Leona's basically steamrolled the earth and Alexandra's got Clive Davis on her side for her assault on the american charts.

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Leona has a new single/album coming out, she'll be on X Factor in a few weeks

Ah, well Leona is definitely the best of the winners in terms of staying power. Still don't think she can hold it long enough to compete with like Mariah, Madonna, Whitney etc.

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

I'm not a fan of either but Leona's basically steamrolled the earth and Alexandra's got Clive Davis on her side for her assault on the american charts.

I'm sure she'll have a good run in the U.S, but for how long will be a wonder.

[Arneldo]

Olly/Jamie.

[Shaun]

clicked all of them :|

[ILoveTRW]

lets face it, all

this is a repeat of series 4