who is your favourite judge?

[Stacey.]

cheryl, louis, simon or dannii?
and reasons please! :)

[Harry!]

Dannii.

[Stacey.]

Dannii.

reasons and poll please!

[Harry!]

reasons and poll please!

Because I just do. None of the other judges :dazzler: me.

[Braden]

Dannii because she is kind
and never gets into the boring arguments between the judges

[Brad.]

Simon, because he doesn't talk bullshit. And Cheryl is hot, so she is great too.

[Vicky.]

Simon as he criticises EVERYONE, not just other judges acts. He is the fairest judge by far.

No sugar coating or anything, just truth.

[atieah2009]

Simon.

[Chantel]

Simon as he criticises EVERYONE, not just other judges acts. He is the fairest judge by far.

No sugar coating or anything, just truth.

This.
He's also quite sexy ;)

[atieah2009]

This.
He's also quite sexy ;)

He is very sexy.

[Jords]

In order:

Dannii - means well and gives good + bad points fairly (except with Danyl that time, but that kinda was a private joke between the 2).

(Simon + Cheryl are equal)

Simon - judges well, but I tend to find he licks his own acts' butts and puts down other good acts slightly when not needed in order to look the best (e.g. the whole Lucie not seeming right, when admitingly her performance was best that night).

Cheryl - love her as a person + singer, but gets into too many of these silly arguements with Simon.

Louis - still a valuable judge whom brings something, but sends through + praises ridiculous acts, and tends to say the same things. ''Look like a popstar, sound like a popstar'' blah blah.

[MattBlake]

Dannii :)

[Kazanne]

Simon as he tells it like it is,he doesn't try and curry favour with the public,plus he knows what's good and what's not.

[Kazanne]

Dannii because she is kind
and never gets into the boring arguments between the judges

She wasn't very 'kind' to Danyl when she was pretending to joke about his sexuality,and then apologising for it,the damage was already done!

[teabag.]

danni/simon

[Stacey.]

She wasn't very 'kind' to Danyl when she was pretending to joke about his sexuality,and then apologising for it,the damage was already done!

yes, but i think we just have to move on now...
its sorted,, so theres no problem.

[Stacey.]

my order is:
1. dannii - kind, nice, fair
2. louis - funny, cool, truthful
3. simon - truthful, smart, funny
4. cheryl - beautiful, kind, fair

they are all great judges! <3 cheryl too!

[Jords]

yes, but i think we just have to move on now...
its sorted,, so theres no problem.

It was a joke they had between them,
no harm done at all.

Plus I found it reasonable, if hes comfortable being bi, he didnt have to change the lyrics, no harm there at all.

[Vicky.]

Plus I found it reasonable, if hes comfortable being bi, he didnt have to change the lyrics, no harm there at all.

Hmm...is that the same way celebs like Elton john and will young still sing about 'she' 'her' etc in love songs?

[Jords]

Hmm...is that the same way celebs like Elton john and will young still sing about 'she' 'her' etc in love songs?

Im not saying it was appropriate, but there was no harm in it.

[Stephanie]

louis, because he is cool.

[Princess]

Simon,because he says what is true. If someone is rubbish he'll tell them,usually give them some advice. If they're amazing,he'll say so.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Danni or Simon as their the only ones who tell the truth.

But danni more, as I jsut like her more!

[Patrick]

FFS!

I accidently picked Cheryl but I ment Simon!

Cheryl has been abit annoying this year, what with sending Kandy Rain home an all that..
And shes abit of a hyprocrite!

Simon speaks the Truth!

I like both though!

Cant stand Dani!
WTF Is the point in her?

[Shaun]

Dannii for me. Simon normally but he seems deluded this year.

[Patrick]

How the **** is Danni Winning?

*Shoots Self*

[Christina]

Simon - He's great! Speaks scence [although sometimes harsh he is right] and without him X Factor wouldn't even be on our TV sets :P

[WOMBAI]

Not really any of them anymore - as I feel the competition is now about their egos and beating each other - and making lots of money at the same time. I don't think they give a damn about any of the contestants.

That said - I probably value Simon's opinion the most - as he says what he thinks - and isn't worried about how unpopular that makes him. If I were a contestant - I would be most concerned with his opinion.

[Niamh.]

Louis cos he's funny and he does Limericks!! Dannii second

[MarkWaldorf]

It's interesting to see the change. On the poll last year, Cheryl was at the top by a landslide!

Mine is still Cheryl.

[Beastie]

Louis is my fave! He has John and Edward :D

[arsenalforever]

simon makes the show with his great put downs:joker:

[Dr.Gonzo]

Louis is my fave! He has John and Edward :D

It's like you just can't help yourself. See how you feel by making a post without them in it. Go on, just try it lol :joker:

---

Mine's Simon. I pretty much never disagree with what he says, and I think he's more entertaining than the acts.

[Dom:)]

Danni,gives good criticism and picks good songs

[arsenalforever]

Danni,gives good criticism and picks good songs

no she doesn't:joker:

[Beastie]

It's like you just can't help yourself. See how you feel by making a post without them in it. Go on, just try it lol :joker:

---

Mine's Simon. I pretty much never disagree with what he says, and I think he's more entertaining than the acts.

I cant help myself. lol

[Callum]

Dannii.

[alc09]

Patrick is talking sense.

:joker: at people choosing Danni, shes just pointless.

I voted Simon, the bloke is brilliant.

[Stacey.]

Patrick is talking sense.

:joker: at people choosing Danni, shes just pointless.

I voted Simon, the bloke is brilliant.

simons cool...
dannii is nice though,, and kind... always.

[alc09]

Yes, being nice and kind makes you a good judge then does it?

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Dannii. Least false, least scripts, just gets on with her job really.

[grinds pole]

dannii
just seems like the nicest judge and she gives good criticism/praise too

[robb]

dannii....even though she does make some fashion faux pas with her girls!!!

[Stacey.]

Yes, being nice and kind makes you a good judge then does it?

well... she always gives good praise...
and criticism.