X Factor Live Show 5 Results (8/11, 8pm ITV1) Discussion Thread

[Shaun]

Yes.
Yes!
Yes yes y esy esyn e! <3

lucie ftw.

[LemonJam]

J&Es out.

[Marc]

There going!!!!!

[MassiveTruck]

****!

[Twilight]

Nooooooooooo

[King Gizzard]

**** yes!!!!!!!!

[Brad.]

YEAH, THAT'S RIGHT, FK OFF J&E!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Lucie is far too good for them fking twats.

[30stone]

That is ****ign ridiculous!

[Christina]

They're gone.

[bronaaaa]

=O
YAY
:dance2:

[teabag.]

YESSSS LUCIE IN THE BOTTOM TWO but nooo she wont go

[Marc]

Bye bye boys!!!!!!

[MarkWaldorf]

Please get them out!!

[LemonJam]

i just came

[Adamw92]

Yes! Bye bye jedward!!!!!!!!!!!!

[King Gizzard]

Yes yes yesessys

[MassiveTruck]

YEAH, THAT's RIGHT, FK OFF J&E!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Lucie is far too good for them fking twats.

Don't speak too soon dude.

If these cock suckers take it to dead lock they may use a Lucie elimination for publicity.

[30stone]

If lucie leaves my god </3

[Christina]

I think after this song.. i'll decide if Lucie is my fave or not.

[King Gizzard]

Lol at the advert about john and edward!!

[30stone]

Lucie sings her best performance and she goes bottom 2.

[Braden]

thank god,
john and edward are gone !

[*mazedsalv**]

Shitt Lucie :0

But YESSS J&E in the bottom 2!!!!

[Novo]

Jamie olly stacey and Joe

the only four who haven't been in the bottom two

[Loukas]

FINALLY!!!!!!! Jesus!!

[King Gizzard]

Now courtney123 will FINALLY shutup


so happy.

[lolipop2005]

They have to go..... Lucie is sooooo much better than them!!!

[Princess]

Awwwwwwww no I'm gonna miss Jedward! I was just starting to love them!

[bronaaaa]

i just came

=O

[Jords]

Winnn! Stacey & Jamie got through! :D

Thank God J+E are in bottom 2, they are gone right!?!?

[30stone]

Dont say john and edward are gone!!!

otherwise lucie will probably go!

[setanta]

Yeah, they're gone.... Cheryl and Simon wont vote for them

[Adamw92]

Lucie must stay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! bye bye Jedward!!!!! FINALLY

[Brad.]

Now courtney123 will FINALLY shutup


so happy.

YESSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!

What a result!

[MassiveTruck]

Worst bottom 2 ever. Don't mind John and Edward but Lucie is far better overall.

[King Gizzard]

FINALLY it will become a singing competition

[Jords]

Lucie must stay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! bye bye Jedward!!!!! FINALLY

Stacey got through!!!!!

[MarkWaldorf]

I wouldn't be surprised if Lucie goes.

[30stone]

FINALLY it will become a singing competition

Not if lucie goes.

[30stone]

Argh this is ridiculous!

[Wildcat!]

HOLLY Craap1!!!!! :D D :D
This is very unexpected.

Who will survive!!

[Christina]

Yeah pity you didn't do that last week Simon :\

[Adamw92]

Stacey got through!!!!!

I know, my heart was pounding!!!

[Brad.]

If J&E stay then I won't be watching the X Factor again. :nono:

[Braden]

If J&E stay then I won't be watching the X Factor again. :nono:

same.

[30stone]

If J&E stay then I won't be watching the X Factor again. :nono:


This.

[Christina]

Come on Lucieee!

[Wildcat!]

This shows just how biased Simon is! Tonight, apparently, they are going to vote, based on the poerformances. NOt the other weeks though.

[Christina]

This shows just how biased Simon is! Tonight, apparently, they are going to vote, based on the poerformances. NOt the other weeks though.

Exactly!

[MarkWaldorf]

I called it. Lucie will probably go.

[30stone]

Her being in the bottom two.

Best singer in the competition :(

[Novo]

Win Win Situation here

John and edward go = Thank god don't have to put up with them anymore

Lucie goes = One of Olly's threats have gone

[andyman]

Still BS with that dk head Lloyd staying..

[King Gizzard]

LOL aston villa defender james collins just said on twitter


''get the twins out...please!''

[Loukas]

Lucie.. this is not great, PLEASE BABE SING UP!

[Novo]

she sounds awful!

[Smithy]

This shows just how biased Simon is! Tonight, apparently, they are going to vote, based on the poerformances. NOt the other weeks though.

why didnt he do that with rachael last week rather than putting loyd through hes such a DKHD

[Braden]

i think this is the first time
i don't really give a **** about the bottom two.

[GypsyGoth]

http://i32.tinypic.com/24orfx0.jpg she is great

[30stone]

If the judges dont put her through...

I will headbutt the wall right next to me, so hard.

[Stephanie]

she doesn't sound that good

[King Gizzard]

At high notes she nearly always holds her ear

[Novo]

If the judges dont put her through...

I will headbutt the wall right next to me, so hard.

Calm down Sir

[Christina]

If the judges dont put her through...

I will headbutt the wall right next to me, so hard. LOL! Raging bull :P

She was amazing.. now my fave!!

[Loukas]

S***. She was not that great. :|

[Damaris]

Bye john and edward hahahahahaha

[King Gizzard]

wtf rock DJ? this isnt a survival song, this is a piss take

[30stone]

I am going mad here so pissed off.

[Adamw92]

They're dancing...Lucie has to stay!!!!

[30stone]

Wdf, they cant sing, they cannot dance toegther

[Damaris]

Win Win Situation here

John and edward go = Thank god don't have to put up with them anymore

Lucie goes = One of Olly's threats have gone

Agreed

[King Gizzard]

**** simon might actually take it to deadlock

lucie going - one of his rivals goes

jedward - money

[Shaun]

they HAVE to go.

[30stone]

Backing music :nono:

[Adamw92]

If Simon takes it to deadlock, i'll scream

[MassiveTruck]

This is the funniest sing off ever.

A decent singer and these nutters! :D

[Christina]

Loool!

[Loukas]

Im scared that Lucie will be leaving!!
On a plus.. their singing is good?!?! :o

[Wildcat!]

If the judges dont put her through...

I will headbutt the wall right next to me, so hard.

:D :D
Good man!

[King Gizzard]

They look like they work at Harvester

[Christina]

Haha, this is actually their best performance :P

[Stephanie]

they sounded alright

[30stone]

Haha, this is actually their best performance :P



That was horrible..

Backing track sang more than them.

[Wildcat!]

Im scared that Lucie will be leaving!!
On a plus.. their singing is good?!?! :o

:conf::conf::shocked::shocked:
Where? How? What??:conf:

[Damaris]

Lucie better stay

[Loukas]

Who saw Louis swearing at the crowd!!

[GypsyGoth]

Please, please, please put Lucie through.

[LemonJam]

Who saw Louis swearing at the crowd!!

Me LOL

[Christina]

That was horrible..

Backing track sang more than them.

Haha, they were alright. No comparison to Lucie though!

[30stone]

Who saw Louis swearing at the crowd!!

we thought that but he was saying up the noise sorta thing.

[Wildcat!]

Haha, this is actually their best performance :P

SSSHHHHTT1!!! :mad:

[Smithy]

wheres lucies shoes?
lol

[Stephanie]

deadlockkk xD

[King Gizzard]

Why do I feel bad that theyre being booed? :\

[30stone]

Come on ****ign hell.

Hearts pounding.

[Christina]

Why do I feel bad that theyre being booed? :\

They're nice lads.. just shame about the singing :(

[Christina]

Oh nooo!

[bronaaaa]

:|
omg no simon

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Didn't he just say the decision was going to be based on that performance only?

[GypsyGoth]

Fook Simon!

[Stephanie]

LMAOOO ahaha simon

[Shaun]

You ****ing ****

[King Gizzard]

You twat simon

[30stone]

****ign prick i lose all respect for you

[Smithy]

what a prick

[MassiveTruck]

Fecking Hell - I thought it would be this!

[Wildcat!]

Omg!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Adamw92]

Lucie :bawling:

[MarkWaldorf]

Called it. Bye Lucie.

[Brad.]

Simon you fking wanker, fk off.

[Christina]

Nooo!

[30stone]

**** you simon you ****!!!

[Stephanie]

oh my god

[Novo]

Lol!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wtf!!!!

[Braden]

that is ****ing ridiculous !

[bronaaaa]

NOOOOOOOOOO! :@
Simon Cowel you asshole

[Damaris]

Omfg

[King Gizzard]

That is so ****ing wrong

what a twat

[Lewis.]

What the actual hell

[Christina]

OMFG 3rd week in a row.. arghhh!

[Stephanie]

LMAO i'm actually in shock

[30stone]

Such a ****ing bell end

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Hahahahahahahhahaha.

There's a plus to all this. Hopefully J+E will win and then they can finally cancel this terrible show.

[Shaun]

UTTER. ****ING PRICK.

there's going to be a shitstorm over this.

[Adamw92]

What a ******ing joke!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :mad:

[King Gizzard]

I just lost all my like for simon

[Damaris]

Wth

[Loukas]

I knew that was gonna happen :@

[Brad.]

You just lost a lot of viewers there Simon, nice one.

[Wildcat!]

OMGGGGG!!!!!!

Xfactor, ByeBye!!! They offiially killed one of my fav shows!!!

[Christina]

That's just utterly ridiculous!

[30stone]

Same nate i had so much respect for simon...

Now **** that none at all what so ever.

[Lewis.]

Simon you fecking wanker.

[30stone]

Man doesnt deserve to be where he is.

[bronaaaa]

Lmao Dani

[Marc]

oh dear.. thats all I say

[andyman]

Muhahahahaha knew it!

End of the day the media love and hate J&E.. Lucie is a non-story, deadwood..

J&E keep the show in the spotlight..

But Lloyd has some vile dk head brat fans that need shooting!

[King Gizzard]

better be fcking aftermath

[Brad.]

He has killed his own show, it's a talent search and he has voted off the talent.

[Ross]

****ing ****

[Jords]

Hahahahahaha, what a joke!

But Stacey is the last girl - eat your words Louis & Simon!

[Princess]

**** SAKE!!!!! She was my favourite!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And she went over John and Edward!!!!!!!!!! Simon Cowell is a ****ing prick!!!!

[King Gizzard]

simon = hypocritical twat

[Brad.]

Hahahahahaha, what a joke!

But Stacey is the last girl - eat your words Louis & Simon!

Can you shup about Stacey for one minute please?

[Damaris]

Simon you ******

[Rory]

I love how Simon praises "real talent" but lets Lucie go after a performance like that.

[King Gizzard]

Id rather have Lucie there then Stacey 10000%

[Smithy]

simon = hypocritical twat

agree

[InOne]

St John and Edward have done it again. Well done boys, true kings.

[Damaris]

*Dies on floor

[King Gizzard]

REALLY hope Jamie or Danyl go next week now, just to piss simon off

[LemonJam]

If my favourites are anything to go by ffs. =\

[Brad.]

I'm pretty sure I won't be watching the X Factor again now, at least not for this series anyway.

[King Gizzard]

And none of my hate is directed to John and edward anymore, just simon.

[Nicky.]

This is sh*t!

[Jords]

I cant believe it though, worst thing what can happen now is next week they arnt even in the bottom 2 and cant go!

What a wanker Simon is!

[King Gizzard]

Dermot - get your cock out of Jedwards arses. thanks.

[Rory]

Simon is cocky and arrogant who praises "real talent" after letting Lucie go after a performance like that. Hypocrite. I really hope one of his three acts goes next week.

[andyman]

He has killed his own show, it's a talent search and he has voted off the talent.Wrong! J&E keep the show in the papers and Lucie never gave the media anything to print.. Thats showbiz.

[King Gizzard]

What id love - Jedward in the bottom 2 with jamie, and cheryl dani and louis sending home Jamie

[Wildcat!]

Well, all Ive got to say is thank god for Hollys Butt!

[Jords]

Wrong! J&E keep the show in the papers and Lucie never gave the media anything to print.. Thats showbiz.

This.

[30stone]

If someone was sitting next to me right now laughing at how lucie went.
I would not think twice of putting them through a ****ing window.

[andyman]

Lloyd needs to go next week!

[30stone]

X factor bringing my need for anger management back...

[MassiveTruck]

X factor bringing my need for anger management back...

Go and lift some weights or - you're not far from the studios, so go and lift up Simon. Throw him off a bridge - twice.

[Christina]

My Mum is annoying me so much!! Saying how they deserved to stay over Lucie.. flippin hell.

[CrashDavis]

If someone was sitting next to me right now laughing at how lucie went.
I would not think twice of putting them through a ****ing window.

HAHAHA you'd start on someone over x factor you saddo?

[Brad.]

HAHAHA you'd start on someone over x factor you saddo?

Shut the fk up.

[MassiveTruck]

HAHAHA you'd start on someone over x factor you saddo?

I'd start on somebody over X Factor too.

[setanta]

If someone was sitting next to me right now laughing at how lucie went.
I would not think twice of putting them through a ****ing window.

Different now that Lucie is out... what about Rachel? You weren't too bothered when she was kicked out. Can't have it both ways.

[30stone]

HAHAHA you'd start on someone over x factor you saddo?

Yes.
And well done insulting a mod.

Intellegent work.

[Stephanie]

these callers are lairy LMAOOO

[CrashDavis]

Yes.
And well done insulting a mod.

Intellegent work.

Well i have something to tell you, im laughing over lucie leaving

[andyman]

J&E are pulling in the viewers, love them or hate them the media writes about them, good news for Simon.

Lucie had no chance of winning and was rather dull..

[Christina]

Simon has actually gone from being my fave to my least fave. Not just because of this he's now annoyed me last week and this week. Danni ftw!!

[Brad.]

Good Ben, good call there, banning that cnt.

[King Gizzard]

Simon has actually gone from being my fave to my least fave. Not just because of this he's now annoyed me last week and this week. Danni ftw!!


i actually agree

Danii is my new favourite, simon is my least

[Novo]

Simon made the right decision tonight

these things must be done in order for olly to win

[Brad.]

Simon made the right decision tonight

Don't start Andy. :nono:

Edit: Good edit, you're point is now valid.

[andyman]

Christina! Your mum is right so hush! :-p

Focus your hate towards Lloyd.

[Christina]

i actually agree

Danii is my new favourite, simon is my least

:D loving her this year! Both her acts should have stayed.

Simon has become nothing more than a cocky, hypocritical idiot :nono:

[Z]

The injustice of this show being felt by more and more people each week... for me it was when Miss Frank and Danyl were the bottom two; Miss Frank were the only act I genuinely enjoyed watching, I know that people thought they were one trick ponies, but I loved their style and the performances they gave. Rachel being voted off over Lloyd purely because she'd been in the bottom two so many times completely negates the need for the sing off and the judges' vote, and then Simon has the nerve to do that to Lucie and get rid of her over JOHN AND EDWARD!?

This show is messed up!

[30stone]

Well i have something to tell you, im laughing over lucie leaving


Getting yourself a ban. Smart lad...

[Brad.]

Christina! Your mum is right so hush! :-p

Focus your hate towards Lloyd.

I'm liking this Lloyd hate. :)

[Christina]

Christina! Your mum is right so hush! :-p

Focus your hate towards Lloyd.

LOOL! She's been going on about how great J&E are.. would love to see her actually go out there and buy their album like she has done the others.

[Brad.]

My hate for J&E is at a fairly low level now, but I hate Simon more than ever.

[andyman]

LOOL! She's been going on about how great J&E are.. would love to see her actually go out there and buy their album like she has done the others.Yeah next Christmas John & Edward Christmas album.. Good times.

[Christina]

I don't hate Jedward.. i hate Simon!

[Novo]

http://www.oliver-murs-music.com/wp-content/uploads/Simon_902010a1.jpg

What a great picture

I need large and i'll put it in a frame above my bed like my own little shrine

[Christina]

Yeah next Christmas John & Edward Christmas album.. Good times.

She just said to me 'I wouldn't buy their album i'd watch their show though' does it look like a friggin presenting show!! And lmao no thanks Andy i'll pass :P

[Princess]

I'm soooooo pissed off! Simon is just trying to get rid of the competetion. I love Jedward,but no should they have stayed. I just hope the public keep loving them,it's Simon's fault Lucie is gone,not theirs.

[30stone]

They have to win it now, they have knocked out the best.

Spite simon to.

[*mazedsalv**]

best Xtra Factor episode ever!

Everone riping Simon to shreds, they are NOT happy!
They are proper going for him.

And the Kim and Lious convo!

[Christina]

Publics fault not Simon's anyway.

He said he would base his vote on the last performance. He didn't.. again.

[MassiveTruck]

best Xtra Factor episode ever!

Everone riping Simon to shreds, they are NOT happy!
They are proper going for him.

And the Kim and Lious convo!

Yeah mate but that's what Simon wants. That's why he went to deadlock. Simon getting ripped to shreds is what makes Simon millions.

[Novo]

They have to win it now, they have knocked out the best.

Spite simon to.


They knocked out lucie not olly

:wavey:

[30stone]

Yeah lucie was the best.

I voted for lucie to -.-

[30stone]

Voted for diana last y ear n she went..

[Brad.]

Wtf was Lucie doing in the bottom two anyway?

[Jords]

Wtf was Lucie doing in the bottom two anyway?

And wtf why was Llyod not?

[Christina]

Lucie was just her usual self in the last performance, J+E were better than usual. He sees improvement there.

So she's consistant every week and gets the boot and they do a slightly better performance and get kicked off. It isn't fair.. she still sung better than them this week as did Rachel last week with Lloyd. He's being unfair.

[30stone]

Wtf was Lucie doing in the bottom two anyway?
No idea she out performed everyone last night.

And in general lloyd j&e and jamiewere poor..

[Christina]

No idea she out performed everyone last night.

And in general lloyd j&e and jamiewere poor..

Agreed!

[andyman]

Lloyd is vile.. His fans must be evil brats!

Simon did a great job tonight, he needs to keep J&E in.. Plus Luice had the least votes!

[Fom]

What I don't get is... what is the POINT of the judges vote if it isn't used?

[Adamw92]

BTW, she had the least votes out of everyone and that was probably her best performance last night = she would have more than likely been bottom 2 again next week.

But at least the TALENT would be being saved

[Smithy]

BTW, she had the least votes out of everyone and that was probably her best performance last night = she would have more than likely been bottom 2 again next week.

it was the song choice how many people over 18 like/have heard of camp rock

[Sam!]

I really hope Danyl & jamie are bottom two next week. I don't mind that Jedward have stayed but that they were kept over Lucie and Simon apparently went on about how shiit Jedward are then he smugly kicks Lucie out. He knew taking it to deadlock would get rid of Lucie. He was like all laughing and joking bout it. But yeh if Danyl or Jamie aint out next week I soo aint watching anymore.

[30stone]

it was the song choice how many people over 18 like/have heard of camp rock

I havent seen it im 18
My brothers 20
and my parents are older obviously

None of us have seen it

yet we all agreed..

Lucie was the best...

Then Joe or olly or stacy or danyl

and jamie j&e and lloyd were all so average.

[Christina]

Blame Danni then :thumbs:

She said she wanted that song.

[Adamw92]

Until next week, yes.

And what if Jedward are in the bottom 2 next week?

[Novo]

A song for Lucie fan's

pudOFG5X6uA

[MassiveTruck]

BTW, she had the least votes out of everyone and that was probably her best performance last night = she would have more than likely been bottom 2 again next week.

I don't think so. I think a lot of the reasons behind her being bottom 2 are down to the song choice and also the representation she gets and publicity too.

There is no doubt (considering the shock and surprise) that she was popular and recognised for her talent. It's just they made her fall.

[*mazedsalv**]

Yeah mate but that's what Simon wants. That's why he went to deadlock. Simon getting ripped to shreds is what makes Simon millions.

Yes but will he like the fact that people will turn off? Petitions have already opened for people to stop voting and for switching off.

Also the press he will get tomorrow... will he be happy?
People not voting and people switching off= Less revenue= Simon sad

[5ara]

OMFG im so happy
Edward & John re still in xD

[MassiveTruck]

Yes but will he like the fact that people will turn off? Petitions have already opened for people to stop voting and for switching off.

Also the press he will get tomorrow... will he be happy?
People not voting and people switching off= Less revenue= Simon sad

There is a possibility it will cock up but there are two roads here.

It was pre-planned so they have an exit strategy to give the show credibility again.

It was unexpected so they have a number of ways to work from this. For example, last year they blamed the public for letting Laura leave.

They may use the same excuse again.

[Devinski]

Cowell is seriously a slavish prick. From the beggining he has been saying that Jedward have nothing to do in the competition. The only reason Louis put them through was that they are Irish. Every live show he kept critizing them. Now when he got chance to get rid of them, he doesnt. Instead of that he lets out one of the best talents in the competition. And his argument - she wouldn't have won anyway since she went to bottom two. What a rubbish...Danyl was in bottom two aswell and Simon still believes he could win and supports him for dear life. And yeah...there is always a chance that people can realize their mistake and they can start to vote for his favorite who they though have had enough of support so far. I believe she could have won. I was so sorry for her and for Dannii...she was blaming herself :/. And appart from that - the last save singing is losing its point since that ****ing prick doesnt care about it at all (or maybe he is just ****ing coward). They should have made just bottom one and it would be without any discussion who should go...BULLSHIT.