What Judge should Hit The Road?

[Patrick]

Basically, alot of people have said on Xtra Factor and on Forums..
About how its went to dead lock far too much!
And that the show was better with 3 Judges!


Tbh Next Year I think we will loose a Judge.
As there seems to be alot of Argumets between them.

Cheryl and Simon will deffenatly be here.
Simon`s Last Year on X Factor will be Next Year.
Cheryl will take his job as the 'Head Judge' after that.

So Cheryl will be here for a long time, as her Popularity has massivley grew since judging the show.
Simon has confirmed he`s leaving us after Next Year :(




But Louis And Dannii...

Danii seems to be Ignored quite alot, shes always left out and you can tell that really pisses her off.
Shes still ****ed off that Lucie went over Jedward as she always says..
"This is a Singing Contest"
Hinting that Jedward cant sing.

Louis was fired before but came back, Simon`s hate for Louis has grown alot.
The Public seem to ****ing be pissed at Louis to especially over Jedward.
He left for 2 weeks and that might of made him think how better it is without him.
And hes always treated like **** and made fun off :D



So what Judge would you perfer to Leave next year?
Explain your answer.

[CiaraD]

I think either Louis will get sacked or Danni will quit.

[Jords]

I agree with it being deadlock saturday night, but not last week.
Who cares if it goes to deadlock or not really?
We, the public, are voting anyway...

[Raph]

I voted Cheryl

I hate Simon.
Louis is funny.
and Dannii is the best.
Cheryl is the prettiest, but that's not enough :P

so CHeryl, but pretty much anyone but Dannii <3

[King Gizzard]

Please get of that wanker Louis

[setanta]

I think Simon will step down sooner rather than later. Looks bored to me.

[BB_Eye]

Simon the greedy hypocrite.

Not that him leaving would make any difference to his influence over the show, but at least I wouldn't have to see his face every week.

[MrGaryy]

they better not sack Dannii. get Cheryl or Louis to take a hike they're both **** anyway.

I do fear Dannii may quit though.

[BigSister]

Louis please if i had to choose somebody else prob Danni but shes grown on me this year so yeah prob Louis

[Raph]

omggg who voted Dannii? :(

Dannii is AMAZING <3

[King Gizzard]

BS is the Louis Walsh hate club still around?

[Arneldo]

If we lose anyone it'll be Dannii. Louis won't quit because if he didn't have TXF, he'd have nothing. Cheryl and Simon have no reason to quit. But Dannii, although quite obviously been the best mentor this series, seems to have had enough and I get the feeling she doesn't like what the show has become.

[KKBL]

If somebody should go,it shouls be Cheryl as she is the worst mentor.

[Z]

Louis. I find myself being able to guess which cliché he's going to use next, I know which acts he's going to dislike/not be kind about from the moment the top 12 are finalised, I know which acts he would save in a bottom two scenario the second the bottom two is announced... he's just so biased and predictable, I seriously hope he gets the boot and we're left with Dannii, Cheryl and Simon. Or just Dannii; she's the only one whose opinion I care about anyway.

[Chels]

Louis

[Stacey.]

dannii because she has said awful hurtful things about J&E.
things unneccessary, uncalled for, boring judge and pointless and useless,,
she just sits there waitingg for 1 of HER acts to win.....
um., dannii ,, it aint going to ****ing happen mate!

[Stephanie]

cheryl she's crap as a judge

[King Gizzard]

courtney Danii knows best

everything she saids about those twins is right!

you owe her an apology young madam

[Tom]

Dannii. I like her but shes out of place on the show

[Fom]

I say get rid of Louis I don't get what he adds to the show?

[Tom]

I say get rid of Louis I don't get what he adds to the show?

Banter that was lost first time he was sacked and when he didnt appear at the start of the series

Unless the replacement is spot on the show can't work without him imo

[alc09]

Dannii.

Nice person but why the **** is she a judge, really?!

[Shaun]

well.
it's simon's show so, not him.
dannii's the only judge with an ounce of credibility and fairness.

so either Louis (out of touch fool) or Cheryl (afraid to criticise, not really a position of expertise)

[Fom]

Banter that was lost first time he was sacked and when he didnt appear at the start of the series

Unless the replacement is spot on the show can't work without him imo

But I feel that Cheryl replaces the banter quite well, I quite enjoy watching her tell simon to shut up.

[Tom]

Cheryl (afraid to criticise, not really a position of expertise)

Cheryl is on a loop:

"I thoroughly enjoyed that" (translates as I liked it but have nothing to say)
"You look stunning" (translates as you were ****)
"You keep getting better and better each week" (translates as you were rubbish to start off with but now you're improving)

She doesn't say much else

[alc09]

Very true, not a chance of her being told to **** off though, not a chance.

[kellybsblover]

Louis stop selling the twins as the latest music sensation... Aaron Carter has been in existence for many years now.

[Jords]

Louis<Cheryl=Simon<Dannii

[Captain.Remy]

I don't want Louis to go, I just want him to $hut up once for all. Thanks. lol

[Tom]

If Dannii does quit I reckon they should bring Sharon back, that would be an epic panel

Sharon & Louis have great chemistry, so to Simon and Louis, and Simon & Cheryl are always arguing

[Patrick]

If Dannii does quit I reckon they should bring Sharon back, that would be an epic panel

Sharon & Louis have great chemistry, so to Simon and Louis, and Simon & Cheryl are always arguing

Yeah it would be great to see how Sharron and Cheryl get on.
I miss Sharon the way she use to say "Fabulous!" lol

[Tom4784]

Louis, He's stuck in the 90's and knows nothing of music outside of homo-erotic boybands and stools.

[Tom]

Louis, He's stuck in the 90's and knows nothing of music outside of homo-erotic boybands and stools.

Is that stools as in what bands sit on or stools as in ****?

[Twilight]

Cheryl

[Z]

Louis, He's stuck in the 90's and knows nothing of music outside of homo-erotic boybands and stools.

I applaud you, sir.

[Tom4784]

Is that stools as in what bands sit on or stools as in ****?

*looks at his previous groups*

Both.

[Adamw92]

Louis

[MissChelle]

Louis, or Cheryl, they're both useless imo.

Danni has been the best judge by miles this year, I really hope she doesn't leave.

[Arneldo]

We cannot lose Louis, It just would not be the same. The first two weeks, when he didn't appear - it wasn't he same. If we lose simon or Louis - they'll be replaced by Piers - and nobody wants that!

[LemonJam]

Louis. Relevent in the 90s but he's lost his touch.

Ironically, the least successful seeming (Dannii) is probably the best judge offering constructive criticisms. I would've said Simon before the Live Shows but he's been on the meth.