The BIG problem with Joe...

[biglover]

I like Joe and I want him in the final, however he cannot win for the sake of the show. He will have a one hit wonder and never sell records again, this is becuase he has no broad appeal like Stacey, Danyl and Olly do, he is not a 'popstar' and is definately a west end star, his voice sounds amazing but it is theatre. Anyone share my views?

[Tom4784]

Nobody will be huge but I can only really see Stacey having a modest success really.

[Twilight]

No Joe will be sell well imo<3 Stacey, Danyl and Olly wouldn't do well.
And if Lloyd won he would like Shayne Ward a album or two then nothing much sadly.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I agree, great voice, but his performances are so forgetful

[biglover]

He is too stage school

[LemonJam]

I like Joe and I want him in the final, however he cannot win for the sake of the show. He will have a one hit wonder and never sell records again, this is becuase he has no broad appeal like Stacey, Danyl and Olly do, he is not a 'popstar' and is definately a west end star, his voice sounds amazing but it is theatre. Anyone share my views?

100% You can see many of him at the west end.

[MarkWaldorf]

Considering he's 18 years old and has JUST been taken straight out of a stage school? If anything, Joe is the only act that could progress and get better and find his style due to his age. Ask most people and they wouldn't know what sort of music Joe could possibly release.

[Stacey.]

Nobody will be huge but I can only really see Stacey having a modest success really.

and Jedward will be even bigger than anyone :D

[Kazanne]

Nobody will be huge but I can only really see Stacey having a modest success really.

I can't see that ,we already have Leona and Alexandria,so how would Stacey be 'different' enough to be successful?

[Lewis.]

This is why Miss Frank should have won :(

[mizzy25]

out of the remaining ones
danyl i cant c many people buying his records he wud be this years equivalent of steve brockstein
olly i personally cannot see the appeal of olly why they keep comparing him to will young i do not know he cant even sing that well
Lloyd well Lloyd just wont win
joe hmmm good looking, lovely personality, fantastic voice, good all rounder, geordie so all of the north east will b behind him like they were with cheryl in popstars. yes i cud see joe winning and going on to be the next will young but far better, but hey even if he comes 2nd look @ JLS
stacey as has been said b4 leona. alex etc nothing special or different

so joe 2 win

[Tom]

Considering he's 18 years old and has JUST been taken straight out of a stage school? If anything, Joe is the only act that could progress and get better and find his style due to his age. Ask most people and they wouldn't know what sort of music Joe could possibly release.

That goes right back to stage school. He just isn't a pop star and never will be. He'll be good in theatre though

[Raph]

That's why Rachel should've won - she would've been a perfect UK Rihanna <3

[Z]

That goes right back to stage school. He just isn't a pop star and never will be. He'll be good in theatre though

I agree. There is no doubting that he's a great singer, but he's not really a pop singer, he belongs on the stage...

[Niamh.]

yeah, he is a bit stage school alright but you have to hand it to him he was by a mile the best last week. I would prefer Olly to win but beacuse of being in the bottom last week, I reckon its between Joe & Stacey now. Out of those 2 I'd go for Joe, I can't warm to Stacey at all, her airhead bit doesn't appeal to me at all

[Crimson Dynamo]

I think that if olly gets this week right he will win so it is academic

Olly has the BIG MO

and if you have the BIG MO

no one, no one I tells ya, can stop you

[Niamh.]

Big mo????

[russellbcox]

Joe is a great singer but he doesn't have the X Factor!

Olly and Stacey do have the "X"



I like Joe and I want him in the final, however he cannot win for the sake of the show. He will have a one hit wonder and never sell records again, this is becuase he has no broad appeal like Stacey, Danyl and Olly do, he is not a 'popstar' and is definately a west end star, his voice sounds amazing but it is theatre. Anyone share my views?

[30stone]

Think stacey will sell the most.


and olly is a bit theatre like joe aswell

[Alf]

and Jedward will be even bigger than anyone :D
i dont dissagree with you, the modern public seem to like talentless entertainment these days.

[Beastie]

I can't see that ,we already have Leona and Alexandria,so how would Stacey be 'different' enough to be successful?

she has a personality too :D